There is one piece of pumpkin advice that actually saves people trouble, and it runs against instinct: for baking, use the can. Canned puree is cooked down and strained to a consistent moisture level, while a fresh pumpkin is wetter, stringier and varies from one squash to the next. Substituting fresh for canned in a pie is the most reliable way to end up with a filling that will not set.
The twenty five here split along exactly that line. Twenty of them use canned puree and all twenty are baking. Five use fresh pumpkin by the pound, and all five are savory, where the extra water becomes soup rather than a problem. That is not a coincidence, it is the ingredient telling you what it is for.
Pumpkin Pie
Three versions of the one everyone is looking for in November. All three take three and a half hours or more, and almost all of that is chilling rather than baking. A pumpkin pie that has not been chilled properly will slump when you cut it.
Creamy Pumpkin Pie
Ten ingredients and three hours twenty five, the shortest ingredient list of the three. One and three quarter cups of puree, which is slightly less than a standard can. View the full recipe — 205 minutes, serves 8, 422 calories
Dairy Free Pumpkin Pie with Almond Milk
Twelve ingredients over four hours, the longest of the three, at 259 calories, the lightest. Two and three quarter cups of puree and no cream, which is why it needs the extra setting time. View the full recipe — 240 minutes, serves 8, 259 calories
Pumpkin Pie with Maple Whipped Cream
Fourteen ingredients and 524 calories a serving, the heaviest pie here. A standard fifteen ounce can of puree with maple whipped cream on top. View the full recipe — 215 minutes, serves 8, 524 calories
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Five, and the time spread is the thing to notice: seventy five minutes at one end and eight and a half hours at the other. Cheesecake time is almost entirely chilling, so a no bake version is not quicker to make, it is quicker to finish.
No Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake Balls
Nine ingredients making twenty four balls at 61 calories each, the lightest recipe on this page and the most portions. Seventy five minutes start to finish. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 24, 61 calories
Graham Crust Pumpkin Cheesecake
Eleven ingredients over six and a half hours, twelve servings at 368 calories, the lightest of the four full cheesecakes. One cup of canned puree. View the full recipe — 390 minutes, serves 12, 368 calories
Baked Pumpkin Cheesecake with Brown Sugar and Pumpkin Spice
Ten ingredients and a full fifteen ounce can of puree over six hours ten. The plain baked version, and the one to start from. View the full recipe — 370 minutes, serves 12, 446 calories
No Bake Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake with Pumpkin Spice Whipped Cream
Twelve ingredients at 497 calories, the heaviest cheesecake here, across twelve servings. No oven, but still six and a half hours of chilling. View the full recipe — 390 minutes, serves 12, 497 calories
Instant Pot Pumpkin Cheesecake
Fifteen ingredients over eight and a half hours, the longest recipe on this page. A pressure cooker gives a cheesecake a steam environment, which is what a water bath is for in an oven. View the full recipe — 505 minutes, serves 8, 457 calories
Cakes
Four, and these show what puree actually does in a batter. It is wet and slightly fibrous, so it replaces some of the fat and liquid and gives a dense, moist crumb that keeps for days. A pumpkin cake is harder to dry out than almost any other.
Mini Pumpkin Bundt Cakes with Cinnamon Glaze
Sixteen ingredients, sixty five minutes, the quickest cake here, twelve small cakes at 262 calories, also the lightest. One cup of canned puree. View the full recipe — 65 minutes, serves 12, 262 calories
Pumpkin Patch Poke Cake
Ten ingredients, the shortest list of the four, with a full fifteen ounce can. Ninety minutes and twelve servings at 289 calories. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 12, 289 calories
Pumpkin Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting
Fourteen ingredients over three hours ten, twelve servings at 540 calories. Cream cheese frosting is the standard partner because its acidity cuts the sweetness. View the full recipe — 190 minutes, serves 12, 540 calories
Pumpkin Layer Cake with Toffee Pecans
Sixteen ingredients across sixteen servings at 577 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page. Two and a half hours. View the full recipe — 150 minutes, serves 16, 577 calories
Breakfast and Breads
Five where pumpkin goes into the morning. Two are done in half an hour and three take two hours or more, and the difference is yeast and loaf pans rather than any difficulty.
Pumpkin Pie French Toast
Fourteen ingredients in thirty minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, at 277 calories, the lightest in this group. Half a cup of puree whisked into the custard. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 277 calories
Pumpkin Spice Pancakes with Maple Syrup
Thirteen ingredients, thirty five minutes, 311 calories with three quarters of a cup of puree. Puree makes a heavier pancake, so these need a slightly longer cook over slightly lower heat. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 311 calories
Pumpkin Doughnut Muffins
Nineteen ingredients, forty five minutes, twelve muffins at 363 calories. A muffin rolled in cinnamon sugar, which is what makes it a doughnut muffin. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 12, 363 calories
Pumpkin Spice Bread with Cream Cheese Frosting
Twenty ingredients, the longest list on this page, over two hours twenty five. Ten servings at 424 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 145 minutes, serves 10, 424 calories
Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls with Pecan Filling
Fifteen ingredients and two and a half hours, most of it proving. Two thirds of a cup of puree in the dough, which makes it softer and slower to rise. View the full recipe — 148 minutes, serves 12, 305 calories
Donuts and Small Sweets
Three in under an hour, which makes them the quickest route to something pumpkin flavoured. All three are baked rather than fried, so the texture is cake rather than doughnut, and that is worth knowing before you expect otherwise.
Pumpkin Donut Holes
Sixteen ingredients, thirty seven minutes, twenty four holes at 126 calories each. The lightest per portion in this group because the portion is small. View the full recipe — 37 minutes, serves 24, 126 calories
Pumpkin Cake Donuts
Fourteen ingredients in forty two minutes, twelve at 284 calories. Baked in a donut pan, so they hold a ring shape without frying. View the full recipe — 42 minutes, serves 12, 284 calories
Pumpkin Whoopie Pies
Sixteen ingredients and fifty seven minutes, twelve at 350 calories, the heaviest in this group. Two soft cakes with filling, so the cake has to be sturdy enough to hold. View the full recipe — 57 minutes, serves 12, 350 calories
Savory, Where Fresh Pumpkin Belongs
Five that use actual pumpkin, cut up and weighed by the pound, and they are the only five here that do. Three are soups and two are roasted sides. In every one of them the water content that ruins a pie is doing useful work.
Creamy Pumpkin Soup with Crusty Bread
Two and a half pounds of pumpkin or butternut squash in nine ingredients, thirty five minutes, 252 calories, the lightest in this group. The squash thickens it, so there is no roux. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 252 calories
Thai Coconut Pumpkin Soup with Red Curry Paste
Two and three quarter pounds in twelve ingredients, thirty three minutes, the quickest in this group. Coconut milk and pumpkin are both sweet, so this needs lime or fish sauce to balance. View the full recipe — 33 minutes, serves 6, 323 calories
Roasted Pumpkin with Lemon Yogurt Sauce and Pine Nuts
Two and a half pounds roasted, fourteen ingredients, forty five minutes at 262 calories. Yogurt and lemon against roasted sweetness, which is the oldest pairing for winter squash. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 262 calories
Creamy Thai Red Curry Pumpkin Soup
Four pounds of pumpkin, the most of any recipe here, in twelve ingredients. Forty minutes and six servings at 380 calories. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 6, 380 calories
Maple Roasted Pumpkin with Chili and Feta
Two pounds in ten ingredients, forty minutes, 389 calories, the heaviest in this group. Maple, chili and feta is sweet, hot and salty at once, which is what roasted pumpkin can carry. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 389 calories
Before You Choose Your Recipe
Start with the can. Canned pumpkin puree is a cooked, strained, moisture controlled product, and that consistency is the whole reason recipes are written around it. A fresh pumpkin holds far more water, more fibre, and varies from squash to squash, so swapping it into a pie or a cake is the most common reason a pumpkin filling never sets or a loaf sinks in the middle. If you do want to use fresh for baking, you have to roast it, puree it, and then strain it in a sieve or cheesecloth for an hour or more until it stops dripping, and even then the volume will not match. There is one more label trap. A can marked pumpkin puree or pure pumpkin is pumpkin. A can marked pumpkin pie filling is already sweetened and spiced, and if you use it in a recipe calling for puree the result will be far too sweet. They sit next to each other on the shelf and look nearly identical. Pumpkin pie spice, which several recipes above use alongside the puree, is a blend of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and usually cloves or allspice. It contains no pumpkin, so it adds the flavour people associate with pumpkin without adding any of the vegetable. If you have run out, a teaspoon and a half of cinnamon plus half a teaspoon each of ginger and nutmeg and a pinch of cloves gets you close to a tablespoon of the blend. For the savory side, fresh is the right choice and the water is a feature. A sugar pumpkin, also sold as a pie pumpkin, has denser flesh and better flavour than the large carving varieties, which are bred for size and are watery and bland. Butternut squash is a legitimate substitute in all five savory recipes above and several of them say so.
Pumpkin Questions, Answered
Can I use fresh pumpkin instead of canned puree?
For baking, not without work. Roast it, puree it, then strain it for an hour or more until it stops releasing liquid, because fresh pumpkin is much wetter than canned and will stop a pie from setting. For soups and roasted sides, fresh is better.
What is the difference between pumpkin puree and pumpkin pie filling?
Puree is plain cooked pumpkin. Pie filling is already sweetened and spiced. The cans sit together and look similar, and using filling where a recipe asks for puree makes the result cloyingly sweet. Check the label every time.
Does pumpkin pie spice contain pumpkin?
No. It is cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and usually cloves or allspice. It supplies the flavour people associate with pumpkin, which is why a pumpkin spice latte tastes of it without containing any.
Why did my pumpkin pie crack on top?
Overbaking. The custard sets from the outside in, and once the centre is fully firm in the oven it will crack as it cools. Pull it when the edge is set and the centre still has a slight wobble about two inches across.
How long does a pumpkin pie need to chill?
At least three hours, and overnight is better. The recipes above run three and a half to four hours in total and most of that is chilling. Cutting it warm gives you a filling that slumps.
What kind of pumpkin should I buy for cooking?
A sugar pumpkin or pie pumpkin, which is small and dense. The large carving pumpkins are bred for size and are watery with little flavour. Butternut squash works in any of the savory recipes above and is easier to peel.
Can pumpkin puree be frozen?
Yes, and it is worth doing. Freeze leftover canned puree in measured portions, since recipes call for specific amounts and a fifteen ounce can rarely matches exactly what you need.
What is the quickest pumpkin recipe here?
The pumpkin pie French toast at thirty minutes, followed by the Thai coconut pumpkin soup at thirty three. Everything involving a custard or a cheesecake is a chilling project rather than a cooking one.
More Pumpkin and Autumn Baking
Six more pumpkin recipes and the collections these sit inside.
- Pumpkin Gnocchi with Sage Butter — twelve ingredients, puree in the dough
- Pumpkin Dessert Lasagna — fifteen servings, no baking
- Pumpkin Pie Monkey Bread — eight ingredients, fifty minutes
- Pumpkin Cheesecake Cupcakes — twenty one ingredients, twelve of them
- Pie Recipes — where the pumpkin pies belong
- Cheesecake Recipes — the five pumpkin ones in wider company
- Dessert Recipes — twenty five across every category
- Pecan Recipes — the other November pie
- Pound Cake Recipes — where the bundts belong
Browse all of our recipe collections.
































