23 Buttermilk Recipes, and You Cannot Just Use Milk

Buttermilk is in a recipe because it is acidic, at a pH of around 4.5, and that acid does two separate jobs. The first is leavening: it reacts with baking soda to produce carbon dioxide, which is why buttermilk recipes call for soda rather than baking powder. Swap in regular milk and that reaction never happens. You are left with raw baking soda, which tastes faintly soapy and metallic, and a pancake that does not rise. This is the single most common buttermilk mistake and it is not fixable at the table.

The second job is tenderising. Acid weakens gluten, so a buttermilk cake has a finer, softer crumb than the same cake made with milk, and it stays moist longer. In fried chicken it does something slightly different: it denatures the protein at the surface, and because buttermilk is thick and viscous it clings to the meat and holds the flour coating in place, which is where a craggy crust comes from. Twenty three recipes here, from twenty five minutes to over five hours.

Buttermilk Pancakes and Waffles

Six, and this is where buttermilk earns its reputation. The soda reacts the moment it meets the acid, so the batter starts producing gas immediately and loses lift as it sits. Mix it, rest it five minutes for the flour to hydrate, and cook it. A batter made an hour ahead will be flat.

Small Batch Buttermilk Pancakes

Nine ingredients in twenty five minutes, tied for the quickest recipe on this page, at 232 calories, also the lightest in this group. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 232 calories

Fluffy Pancakes Without Buttermilk

Ten ingredients in twenty five minutes, tied for the quickest recipe on this page, three servings at 348 calories. The honest comparison: no buttermilk, so baking powder does the work instead. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 3, 348 calories

Classic Buttermilk Pancakes

Ten ingredients in forty five minutes, the longest in this group, at 399 calories. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 399 calories

Buttermilk Waffles

Eight ingredients, the shortest list on this page, in twenty five minutes, tied for the quickest recipe here, at 496 calories. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 496 calories

Light Buttermilk Pancakes

Ten ingredients in forty minutes, five servings at 513 calories. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 5, 513 calories

Buttermilk Pancakes with Warm Buttermilk Syrup

Fourteen ingredients, the most in this group, in thirty minutes at 849 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page. Buttermilk in the syrup as well, where its acid stops the sugar crystallising. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 849 calories

Buttermilk Fried Chicken

Six, and the marinade is doing less than people think and something more useful than they expect. Buttermilk penetrates only a few millimetres into the meat, so it is not tenderising the chicken through. What it does is denature the surface proteins and, because it is thick, cling to the chicken so the flour grips. That grip is the crust.

Air Fryer Buttermilk Chicken Tenders

Ten ingredients, tied for the most in this group bar one, in forty two minutes, the quickest here, at 269 calories, also the lightest. View the full recipe — 42 minutes, serves 4, 269 calories

Air Fryer Buttermilk Chicken Thighs and Drumsticks

Ten ingredients in ninety minutes at 436 calories. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 4, 436 calories

Crunchy Buttermilk Chicken Tenders

Nine ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in eighty five minutes at 440 calories. View the full recipe — 85 minutes, serves 4, 440 calories

Oven Baked Fried Chicken with Buttermilk Marinade

Nine ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in sixty minutes at 455 calories. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 4, 455 calories

Craggy Fried Chicken with Buttermilk Marinade

Eighteen ingredients, the longest list on this page, in two hours forty five, six servings at 622 calories. Craggy means buttermilk splashed into the flour so it clumps, and those clumps are the whole point. View the full recipe — 165 minutes, serves 6, 622 calories

Brined Buttermilk Fried Chicken

Twelve ingredients in two hours fifty five, the longest in this group, at 719 calories, the heaviest here. View the full recipe — 175 minutes, serves 4, 719 calories

Buttermilk Cakes

Six, and these are the clearest demonstration of what the acid does to a crumb. Weakened gluten means a finer, softer texture, and the acidity also helps the cake hold moisture, so buttermilk cakes keep noticeably better than milk ones. All six serve nine or more.

Blueberry Lemonade Buttermilk Cake

Thirteen ingredients, tied for the most in this group bar one, in seventy five minutes, nine servings at 390 calories, the lightest here. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 9, 390 calories

Peach Buttermilk Pound Cake

Twelve ingredients in two hours twenty, the longest in this group, twelve servings at 423 calories. View the full recipe — 140 minutes, serves 12, 423 calories

Blueberry Buttermilk Crumb Cake

Thirteen ingredients in ninety minutes, twelve servings at 427 calories. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 12, 427 calories

Strawberry Buttermilk Pound Cake

Ten ingredients, the fewest in this group, in ninety minutes, twelve servings at 459 calories. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 12, 459 calories

Buttermilk Spice Cake

Fifteen ingredients, the most in this group, in sixty minutes, the quickest here, twelve servings at 496 calories. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 12, 496 calories

Buttermilk Cake with Buttercream Frosting

Twelve ingredients in two hours, twelve servings at 600 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 120 minutes, serves 12, 600 calories

Breads, a Salad and a Sandwich

Five of the rest. The potato salad and the sandwich are the two places here where real cultured buttermilk matters most, because you are tasting it directly rather than using it for a chemical reaction.

Buttermilk Mexican Cornbread

Thirteen ingredients in fifty minutes, eight servings at 210 calories, the lightest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 8, 210 calories

Buttermilk Banana Bread

Nine ingredients, the fewest in this group, in sixty five minutes, ten servings at 302 calories. View the full recipe — 65 minutes, serves 10, 302 calories

Buttermilk Dressing Potato Salad

Ten ingredients in thirty five minutes, the quickest in this group, eight servings at 363 calories. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 8, 363 calories

Buttermilk Cheddar Bread Loaf

Ten ingredients in two hours twenty five, eight servings at 413 calories. View the full recipe — 145 minutes, serves 8, 413 calories

Buttermilk Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich

Seventeen ingredients, the most in this group, over five hours twenty, the longest recipe on this page, at 618 calories, also the heaviest here. View the full recipe — 320 minutes, serves 4, 618 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

A note on what buttermilk actually is, because the name is now misleading. Traditional buttermilk was the thin liquid left in the churn after butter was made, slightly tangy from the natural fermentation of the cream. What sells as buttermilk today is cultured buttermilk: low fat milk deliberately inoculated with lactic acid bacteria, which thickens it and acidifies it to around pH 4.5. The modern product is more acidic and thicker than the original, and it is what every recipe on this page assumes. The substitution question comes up constantly and deserves a precise answer rather than a yes or no. A tablespoon of vinegar or lemon juice in a cup of milk, left to stand ten minutes, gives you roughly the right acidity and nothing else. For leavening, that is enough: the soda will react and the cake will rise. For anything where you taste the buttermilk, or where its body matters, it falls short. It is thin rather than viscous, so it will not cling to chicken the way buttermilk does, and it tastes of vinegar rather than of lactic fermentation, which is obvious in a dressing or a dip. Plain yogurt or sour cream thinned with milk is a much better substitute for those uses. What you cannot do is use plain milk in a recipe built on buttermilk and baking soda. Without acid the soda does not react, so you get no lift and a soapy, metallic aftertaste from the unreacted alkali. If you must, replace the soda with baking powder, roughly three times as much, since baking powder contains its own acid. Three practical notes. Buttermilk batters should be mixed and cooked, not held: the soda reaction begins immediately and the gas escapes as the batter sits, so an hour old pancake batter is flat. Five minutes of rest for the flour to hydrate is useful; an hour is not. Buttermilk keeps far longer than milk because its acidity suppresses spoilage organisms, often two weeks past the printed date, and it separates naturally, so shake it rather than throwing it out. And it freezes well in an ice cube tray, which solves the problem of buying a quart for a recipe that needs half a cup.

Buttermilk Questions, Answered

Can I use regular milk instead of buttermilk?

Not in a recipe that also calls for baking soda. The soda needs the acid in buttermilk to react and produce lift, and without it you get a flat result with a soapy metallic aftertaste from the unreacted soda. Replace the soda with about three times as much baking powder if you must.

Does the milk and vinegar substitute work?

For leavening, yes: a tablespoon of vinegar or lemon juice per cup of milk gives roughly the right acidity. For anything you taste, no. It is thin rather than thick and tastes of vinegar rather than fermentation, so it will not cling to chicken or work in a dressing. Thinned yogurt is better for those.

What does buttermilk do in fried chicken?

Less than people assume to the inside and more to the outside. It penetrates only a few millimetres, so it is not tenderising the meat through. It denatures the surface proteins and, because it is thick, it clings so the flour grips, which is what produces a craggy crust.

Why are my buttermilk pancakes flat?

The batter sat too long. The acid and soda start reacting the moment they meet and the gas escapes as the batter stands, so mix it, rest it five minutes for the flour to hydrate, and cook it. An hour old batter has already spent its lift.

Is buttermilk actually left over from making butter?

Not any more. Traditional buttermilk was the liquid left in the churn, but what shops sell is cultured buttermilk: low fat milk inoculated with lactic acid bacteria. It is thicker and considerably more acidic than the original, and it is what these recipes assume.

How long does buttermilk keep?

Often two weeks past the printed date, because its acidity suppresses the organisms that spoil milk. It separates naturally as it sits, which is normal; shake it before using rather than discarding it.

What should I do with leftover buttermilk?

Freeze it in an ice cube tray, which solves the problem of buying a quart for half a cup. It also makes an excellent marinade for any chicken, a base for ranch dressing, and a liquid for mashed potatoes.

Why does buttermilk make cakes more tender?

Its acid weakens gluten, so the crumb is finer and softer than the same cake made with milk. The acidity also helps the cake hold moisture, which is why buttermilk cakes keep noticeably better over two or three days.

More to Try

Browse all of our recipe collections.