Pecans are about seventy two percent fat by weight, which is the highest of any common nut, and that one number explains the two things worth knowing about them. The first is that they go rancid fast, because unsaturated fat oxidises. A pecan kept in a cupboard for a few months tastes bitter and faintly of paint, and a handful of them will ruin a pie you spent three hours on. Taste one before you bake with them, every time.
The second is that toasting matters more with pecans than with almost anything else, because there is so much fat to develop. Seven to ten minutes at 350 degrees F, or five minutes in a dry pan, and the flavour goes from mild to distinctly nutty. None of the recipes below will tell you off for skipping it, but the difference is large. Times run from twenty minutes to six hours and calories from 74 to 801.
Pecan Pie and Its Variations
Five, and all of them are the same custard in different containers: eggs, sugar, butter and corn syrup or maple, set around pecans. The failure mode is overbaking, which makes the filling weep and crack. Pull it when the centre still has a slight wobble about two inches across.
Pecan Pie Crescents
Nine ingredients in twenty seven minutes, the quickest of the five, eight servings at 227 calories, also the lightest. Crescent dough instead of pastry, so there is no blind baking. View the full recipe — 27 minutes, serves 8, 227 calories
No Bake Lemon Pecan Stupid Pie
Six ingredients, tied for the shortest list on this page, over two hours fifteen at 388 calories. Lemon against the sweetness, which is the one thing a standard pecan pie lacks. View the full recipe — 135 minutes, serves 8, 388 calories
Maple Pecan Pie Bars with Brown Sugar Crust
Thirteen ingredients over two hours, nine bars at 415 calories, with a cup and a half of pecans. Maple instead of corn syrup gives a less cloying filling. View the full recipe — 120 minutes, serves 9, 415 calories
Pecan Pie Dump Cake
Eight ingredients in eighty minutes, twelve servings at 532 calories. Nothing is mixed, which is what dump cake means. View the full recipe — 80 minutes, serves 12, 532 calories
Bourbon Pecan Pie with Flaky Homemade Crust
Fourteen ingredients over four hours at 681 calories, the heaviest of the five, with a cup and a quarter of pecans. Bourbon cuts the sugar, and most of the alcohol bakes off. View the full recipe — 240 minutes, serves 8, 681 calories
Candied, Pralined and Brittle
Four where sugar is cooked onto the nuts. These are the recipes where toasting is built in, because the hot sugar does it for you. Three of them need only six ingredients, and the baklava cups are the lightest thing on this page.
Pecan Baklava Cups with Honey
Nine ingredients in thirty five minutes, thirty cups at 74 calories each, the lightest recipe on this page and the most portions. A cup of pecans across thirty servings. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 30, 74 calories
Brown Sugar Pecan Pralines
Six ingredients, tied for the shortest list here, in thirty minutes, twelve pralines at 259 calories. A cup of pecan halves, and the sugar has to reach soft ball stage or they will not set. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 12, 259 calories
Pecan Praline Cereal Crunch
Six ingredients in thirty five minutes with two cups of pecan halves, tied for the most pecans on this page. Twelve servings at 304 calories. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 12, 304 calories
Pecan Graham Cracker Toffee
Six ingredients in eighty seven minutes with two cups of chopped pecans, also tied for the most. Twelve servings at 381 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 87 minutes, serves 12, 381 calories
Pecan Cakes
Five, and these are the heaviest recipes here. Pecans bring fat rather than structure, so a pecan cake is denser than the same cake without them and it keeps longer, because the fat slows the crumb drying out.
Cream Cheese Pecan Cake
Eight ingredients in eighty five minutes, fifteen servings at 405 calories, the lightest of the five. A cup of chopped pecans. View the full recipe — 85 minutes, serves 15, 405 calories
Pumpkin Layer Cake with Toffee Pecans
Sixteen ingredients over two and a half hours, sixteen servings at 577 calories. Pecan halves candied separately so they stay crisp on top. View the full recipe — 150 minutes, serves 16, 577 calories
Butter Pecan Red Velvet Cheesecake
Twenty four ingredients, the longest list on this page by a wide margin, over six hours, the longest recipe here. Sixteen servings at 663 calories. View the full recipe — 365 minutes, serves 16, 663 calories
Coconut Pecan German Chocolate Cake
Sixteen ingredients in two hours, twelve servings at 737 calories. Coconut and pecan in the frosting is what makes a German chocolate cake German chocolate. View the full recipe — 120 minutes, serves 12, 737 calories
Southern Pecan Caramel Cake
Twelve ingredients over two hours fifteen, twelve servings at 801 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 135 minutes, serves 12, 801 calories
Breads, Cobbler and Custard Pies
Five where pecans go into something softer. Chopped rather than halved is right for all of these, since a whole pecan half in a slice of bread is a hard lump; chopped distributes and you taste it in every bite.
Banana Pecan Bread
Nine ingredients in eighty minutes, eight servings at 298 calories, the lightest in this group. Half a cup of pecans. View the full recipe — 80 minutes, serves 8, 298 calories
Sweet Potato Honey Bun Cake with Pecans
Twenty ingredients over two hours, sixteen servings at 324 calories, with a cup of chopped pecans. View the full recipe — 120 minutes, serves 16, 324 calories
Sweet Alabama Pecan Bread
Twelve ingredients in seventy five minutes, the quickest in this group, ten servings at 368 calories. A cup of chopped pecans, and it is closer to a blondie than a bread. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 10, 368 calories
Oat Pecan Peach Cobbler
Sixteen ingredients in sixty five minutes, eight servings at 415 calories. Oats and pecans in the topping, which both crisp at the same rate. View the full recipe — 65 minutes, serves 8, 415 calories
Brown Sugar Butterscotch Pie with Pecans
Ten ingredients over three hours fifty at 519 calories, the heaviest in this group. Half a cup of chopped pecans in a custard pie. View the full recipe — 230 minutes, serves 8, 519 calories
Savory and Salads
Four where pecans are not dessert, and all four pair them with fruit. That is not decoration: pecans are rich and slightly sweet with no acidity at all, so they need something sharp alongside or they flatten the dish.
Pecan Cranberry Baked Brie
Six ingredients, tied for the shortest list on this page, in thirty minutes, six servings at 256 calories, the lightest of the four. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 6, 256 calories
Cranberry Pecan Chicken Salad
Eleven ingredients in twenty minutes, tied for the quickest recipe on this page, at 376 calories with half a cup of pecans. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 4, 376 calories
Fondant Sweet Potatoes with Maple Butter Pecans
Thirteen ingredients over an hour forty five, the longest in this group, six servings at 399 calories. View the full recipe — 105 minutes, serves 6, 399 calories
Crisp Apple Pecan Salad with Vinaigrette
Ten ingredients in twenty minutes, tied for the quickest here, at 427 calories, the heaviest of the four. A full cup of pecans, and the vinaigrette is doing the sharp work. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 4, 427 calories
Trifle and Lush
Two layered no bake desserts, and pecans do something specific in both: they are the only crisp element in a dish that is otherwise entirely soft. Add them at the last moment or they go soggy in the fridge.
Cherry Pecan Cheesecake Lush
Twelve ingredients over four hours forty, twelve servings at 446 calories, the lighter of the two. Three quarters of a cup of pecans. View the full recipe — 280 minutes, serves 12, 446 calories
Pecan Pie Cheesecake Trifle
Twelve ingredients over two hours forty, eight servings at 657 calories. A cup of chopped pecans layered through. View the full recipe — 160 minutes, serves 8, 657 calories
Before You Choose Your Recipe
Store pecans in the freezer. This is the single most useful thing on this page and almost nobody does it. Pecans are roughly seventy two percent fat, higher than walnuts, almonds or cashews, and that fat is mostly unsaturated, which means it oxidises. Oxidised fat tastes bitter with a faint note of paint or old crayon, and the maddening thing is that rancid pecans look exactly like fresh ones. In a cupboard they turn within two to three months; in the fridge, about six; in the freezer, a year or more with no loss of quality, and you can use them straight from frozen with no thawing. Before you bake, eat one. If it is even slightly bitter, throw the bag out, because a cup of rancid pecans will ruin a pie and you will not know why it tastes wrong. Next, toast them. Spread them on a dry tray at 350 degrees F for seven to ten minutes, shaking once, until they smell nutty and look a shade darker. Or five minutes in a dry frying pan over medium heat, stirring. The high fat content is exactly why this works so well on pecans: there is a lot of oil for the heat to develop. They burn quickly once they start, so stay with them, and let them cool completely before chopping or they will go soft. Halves or chopped is a real decision. Halves look better on top of a pie or a cake and give you a satisfying bite. Chopped distributes through a batter so every mouthful has some, and it is correct for breads, cookies and anything where a whole half would be a hard lump in a soft crumb. Finally, on pecan pie specifically. The filling is a custard, set by eggs, and corn syrup is there to stop the sugar crystallising rather than for sweetness. Overbaked pecan pie weeps liquid and cracks across the top as it cools, so pull it when the centre still wobbles slightly, about two inches across, and let it set out of the oven. It needs at least four hours to firm up properly, which is why the bourbon version above takes four hours in total and only about an hour of that is baking.
Pecan Questions, Answered
How should I store pecans?
In the freezer, where they keep a year or more. They are about seventy two percent fat and that fat oxidises, so a cupboard gives you two to three months at best. They can be used straight from frozen with no thawing.
How do I tell if pecans have gone bad?
Taste one. Rancid pecans are bitter with a faint paint or crayon note, and they look identical to fresh ones. There is no visual test, which is why a batch can quietly ruin a pie.
Should I toast pecans before baking?
Yes, and it matters more than with other nuts because there is so much fat to develop. Seven to ten minutes at 350 degrees F, or five minutes in a dry pan. Cool them completely before chopping.
Halves or chopped pecans?
Halves for the top of a pie or cake, where you want the look and the bite. Chopped for batters, breads and cookies, so the nuts distribute and you do not get a hard lump in a soft crumb.
Why did my pecan pie crack and weep?
Overbaked. The filling is an egg custard, and pushed too far it splits and releases liquid as it cools. Pull it when the centre still wobbles slightly across about two inches and let it finish setting out of the oven.
Why does pecan pie need corn syrup?
To stop the sugar crystallising, not for sweetness. Invert sugars like corn syrup, golden syrup or maple keep the filling smooth. Swapping in granulated sugar alone gives a grainy filling.
Can I substitute walnuts for pecans?
Usually yes, and they behave similarly in baking. Walnuts are more bitter and slightly less fatty, so a pecan pie made with walnuts tastes sharper. Toast them either way.
How long does pecan pie need to set?
At least four hours at room temperature after baking, and overnight is better. The custard continues firming as it cools, and cutting it warm gives you a filling that runs across the plate.
More Nuts and Autumn Baking
Four more pecan recipes and the collections these sit inside.
- Texas Chocolate Pecan Pie — ten ingredients, a cup of pecan halves
- Bacon Pecan Stuffed Sweet Potatoes — twelve ingredients, two hours fifteen
- Old Fashioned Oatmeal Cake — twenty ingredients, a cup of pecans
- Chicken Cranberry Pecan Pinwheels — thirty two pieces, 96 calories each
- Pie Recipes — where the pecan pies belong
- Pumpkin Recipes — the other November pie
- Cake Recipes — the five pecan cakes in wider company
- Christmas Dinner Recipes — where the brie and the sweet potatoes fit
- Oat Recipes — oats and pecans crisp together
- Caramel Recipes — including the caramel cake
Browse all of our recipe collections.
































