25 Sandwich Recipes, From a 10 Minute Build to an Eight Hour Braise

A sandwich is the one dish where the structure matters as much as the filling, and almost every sandwich failure is structural rather than culinary. Wet filling against untoasted bread gives you a soggy base within minutes. Too much filling and it squeezes out the back. Bread sliced too thick and you taste only bread. None of that is about the recipe.

These twenty five are sorted by how much cooking they need rather than by what is in them, because that is the decision you are actually making. Four take ten to fifteen minutes with no cooking at all. Five are grilled cheese variations in twelve to thirty minutes. And four are slow cooked beef that needs eight hours before you can even think about bread. Times run from ten minutes to eight and a half hours, and calories from 332 to 1,066.

Grilled Cheese and Cheese Melts

Five, and all five live or die on heat control. Medium low, not medium high: the bread has to brown at the same rate the cheese melts, and a hot pan browns the outside long before the middle goes molten. Butter the bread, not the pan, so the coverage is even.

Cheddar and Mozzarella Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Four ingredients, the shortest list on this page, in twelve minutes, the quickest cooked sandwich here. Cheddar for flavour and mozzarella for stretch, which is the whole reason to use two. View the full recipe — 12 minutes, serves 1, 583 calories

Honey Banana Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Cheddar

Five ingredients in thirteen minutes. Sweet and savory in the same pan, and the honey caramelises against the bread rather than just sitting on it. View the full recipe — 13 minutes, serves 1, 560 calories

Pizza Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Nine ingredients in twenty minutes, four servings at 462 calories, the lightest in this group. Sauce goes inside rather than on, or the bread will not crisp. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 4, 462 calories

Cranberry Brie Mozzarella Grilled Sandwich

Five ingredients at 607 calories, the heaviest of the five. Brie melts at a lower temperature than cheddar, so this needs less time rather than more. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 1, 607 calories

Triple Cheese Bacon Melt

Six ingredients in thirty minutes, the longest in this group, across four servings at 605 calories. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 605 calories

Patty Melts

Three where a burger patty goes between slices of bread rather than in a bun, with griddled onions. The patty has to be thin and wide rather than thick, or the sandwich will not close and the bread burns while the middle cooks.

Swiss Mushroom Burger Melt on Sourdough

Ten ingredients in forty minutes, the quickest of the three, 666 calories across four. Mushrooms need cooking down first or they water the bread. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 666 calories

Mushroom Swiss Patty Melt

Eleven ingredients over an hour at 732 calories. Swiss and mushroom is the classic patty melt pairing because the cheese is mild enough to let the onions through. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 4, 732 calories

Smashing Patty Melts Confidential Sauce

Eleven ingredients, an hour, and 963 calories a serving, the heaviest in this group. Smashed patties get more crust per ounce of beef, which is the point of smashing them. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 4, 963 calories

Chicken Sandwiches

Five, and the time spread tells you what they are doing. Fifteen minutes means chicken salad on bread. Ninety five minutes means brining the chicken first, which is what makes a fried chicken sandwich taste like the ones you queue for.

Bacon Ranch Chicken Salad Sandwich

Twelve ingredients in fifteen minutes, the quickest of the five, at 581 calories. Cooked chicken bound with ranch, so nothing is cooked here at all. View the full recipe — 15 minutes, serves 4, 581 calories

Spicy Chicken Sandwich with Pickles and Tomato

Fifteen ingredients in an hour, 511 calories, the lightest in this group across four servings. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 4, 511 calories

Chicken Pesto Sandwich with Mozzarella and Tomato

Ten ingredients in thirty minutes at 707 calories. Pesto is oily enough to seal the bread against the chicken, which is a useful accident. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 707 calories

Crispy Pickle Brine Chicken Sandwich

Nineteen ingredients, the longest list on this page, over an hour thirty five. The brine is the whole recipe: salt and acid season the chicken through rather than just on the surface. View the full recipe — 95 minutes, serves 4, 679 calories

Crispy Fried Chicken Sandwiches with Buttered Buns

Twelve ingredients in thirty five minutes at 795 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 795 calories

Slow Cooked Beef, Eight Hours and Up

Four that are not weeknight food. All four braise a cheap cut for eight hours or more until it shreds, and three of them serve it with the cooking liquid for dipping. The bread has to be sturdy enough to survive that, which is why these all call for a roll rather than sliced bread.

Crockpot BBQ Beef Sandwiches

Eight ingredients over eight and a quarter hours, eight servings at 573 calories, the lightest of the four. View the full recipe — 495 minutes, serves 8, 573 calories

Slow Cooker Beef Dip Sandwiches

Six ingredients over eight hours ten, four servings at 661 calories. The shortest list of the four, because the slow cooker is doing all the work. View the full recipe — 490 minutes, serves 4, 661 calories

Slow Cooker Chuck Roast French Dip Sandwiches

Twelve ingredients over eight hours twenty, six servings at 866 calories. French dip means the jus is served alongside rather than poured on. View the full recipe — 500 minutes, serves 6, 866 calories

Chicago Style Italian Beef Sandwiches with Pepperoncini

Fourteen ingredients over eight hours twenty, and 1,066 calories a serving, the heaviest recipe on this page by a wide margin. Giardiniera is not optional in this one, it is the acid that makes the fat work. View the full recipe — 500 minutes, serves 6, 1066 calories

Wraps

Four, and a wrap has a different structural problem from a sandwich: it has to roll without splitting and hold without unravelling. Warm the tortilla for ten seconds first, keep the filling in a line rather than spread flat, and fold the sides in before you roll.

Turkey Ranch Club Wrap

Six ingredients in ten minutes, tied for the quickest recipe on this page. One serving at 508 calories, built on sliced roast turkey. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 1, 508 calories

Keto Cheesy Garlic Chicken Wraps

Nine ingredients in twenty minutes at 404 calories, the lightest in this group. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 4, 404 calories

Chicken Pesto Wraps

Nine ingredients in twenty one minutes, four servings at 491 calories. View the full recipe — 21 minutes, serves 4, 491 calories

Skillet Seared Garlic Chicken Wraps

Ten ingredients in twenty minutes at 511 calories, the heaviest of the four. Searing the chicken rather than using leftovers, which is most of the twenty minutes. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 4, 511 calories

No Cooking At All

Four built in ten to twenty minutes with nothing switched on. These are the ones where the bread matters most, because there is no heat to crisp it: toast it anyway, or use a bread firm enough not to need it.

Egg Salad Sandwiches with Chives and Dijon

Eight ingredients in twenty minutes, four servings at 332 calories, the lightest recipe on this page. Boiling the eggs is the only heat involved. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 4, 332 calories

Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich

Five ingredients in ten minutes, tied for the quickest recipe on this page, at 341 calories. Hummus on the bread works as a moisture barrier as well as a filling. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 1, 341 calories

Green Goddess Salad Sandwich

Twelve ingredients in fifteen minutes, two servings at 443 calories. Herb heavy and sharp, which is what a cold sandwich needs. View the full recipe — 15 minutes, serves 2, 443 calories

Dill Pickle Tuna Sandwich with Celery

Twelve ingredients in ten minutes, tied for the quickest here, at 633 calories, the heaviest in this group. Pickle supplies the acid that tuna salad is usually missing. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 4, 633 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Toast the bread. This is the single highest return instruction in sandwich making and almost nobody does it for cold sandwiches. Toasting drives moisture out of the surface and builds a thin barrier that keeps mayonnaise, tomato juice and dressing from soaking in. A cold sandwich on untoasted bread is noticeably worse within five minutes of being made, and if you are packing one for later it will be unpleasant by lunchtime. The other half of the same problem is where you put the wet things. Fat goes against the bread and water goes in the middle: butter, mayonnaise, pesto, hummus or cheese on the slices, then tomato, pickle and dressed leaves in the centre where they touch nothing absorbent. Salt tomatoes separately on a plate and let them drain for a minute before they go in, because a sliced tomato releases a surprising amount of liquid. For a hot sandwich the variable is heat, not time. Grilled cheese wants medium low for six to eight minutes with a lid on for the first half, so the cheese melts by conduction while the bread browns slowly. If your grilled cheese is dark outside and solid inside, the pan was too hot, and no amount of extra time will fix it once the bread has gone. Butter the bread rather than the pan so the coverage is even and nothing burns in the gaps. On bread thickness: about half an inch is right for most things. Thicker than that and bread dominates; thinner and it tears under any filling with weight. And for the slow cooked beef above, use a roll that can take liquid, since sliced sandwich bread dissolves in jus within seconds. Finally, cut sandwiches on the diagonal. This is not a joke; a diagonal cut gives you a longer edge to bite into and less compression at the first bite, which is why every deli does it.

Sandwich Questions, Answered

How do I stop a sandwich going soggy?

Toast the bread, put fat against both slices, and keep wet ingredients in the middle. Mayonnaise, butter, pesto or hummus act as moisture barriers. Salt and drain tomatoes before they go in. These three habits fix almost every soggy sandwich.

What temperature should I cook a grilled cheese at?

Medium low, for six to eight minutes total, with a lid on for the first half. The cheese needs time to melt through, and a hot pan browns the bread long before that happens. Dark outside and solid inside always means too much heat.

Should I butter the bread or the pan?

The bread. Butter in a pan pools and burns in patches, while butter spread to the edges of the slice browns evenly. Mayonnaise on the outside also works and browns at a higher temperature than butter does.

How thick should sandwich bread be?

About half an inch for most fillings. Much thicker and you taste mainly bread; much thinner and it tears. The slow cooked beef sandwiches above need a sturdy roll instead, since sliced bread falls apart in jus.

How do I keep a wrap from splitting?

Warm the tortilla for about ten seconds first, which makes it pliable instead of brittle. Keep the filling in a line slightly off centre rather than spread flat, fold both sides in, then roll tightly away from you.

Can sandwiches be made the night before?

Cold ones, yes, with care. Toast the bread, use fat as a barrier on both slices, and pack wet components separately to add in the morning. The chicken salad and egg salad above hold up best; anything with dressed leaves does not.

What is the difference between a French dip and an Italian beef?

The jus. A French dip serves the cooking liquid on the side for dipping; a Chicago Italian beef has the roll dipped before serving, and comes with giardiniera for acidity. Both are above and both need eight hours.

Which of these is quickest?

Three tie at ten minutes: the turkey ranch wrap, the Mediterranean veggie sandwich and the dill pickle tuna. The quickest cooked one is the grilled cheese at twelve minutes with four ingredients.

More to Put Between Bread

Four more sandwiches, two breads to make them on, and the collections these sit inside.

Browse all of our recipe collections.