17 Grilled Cheese Recipes, and Why Mayo Browns Better

Grilled cheese has one real problem and everything else follows from it. Bread browns at around 300F on dry starch, and it browns fast. Cheese needs sustained heat to go from soft to actually flowing, and that takes time rather than temperature. Put a sandwich in a hot pan and the bread is dark in ninety seconds while the center is still cold cheese. Turn the heat down and the bread dries out before anything melts.

The answer is medium low heat with a lid on the pan. The lid traps steam, and steam carries heat into the sandwich far faster than still air does, so the cheese melts while the bread is still browning gently. Grate the cheese rather than slicing it, since grated cheese melts in a fraction of the time. And butter the bread rather than the pan, which gives even coverage instead of a greasy patch in the middle. Seventeen recipes here, from thirteen minutes to fifty.

Cheese Forward

Four where the cheese is the whole point, which makes the choice of cheese the only decision that matters. Young, moist, low acid cheeses flow when melted: American, young cheddar, fontina, Gruyere, Monterey Jack. Aged and acidic ones do not, and aged cheddar in particular turns stringy and weeps oil.

Pepperoni Mozzarella Grilled Cheese

Six ingredients in eighteen minutes, two servings at 372 calories, the lightest in this group. Mozzarella melts beautifully and tastes of very little, so the pepperoni is doing the work. View the full recipe — 18 minutes, serves 2, 372 calories

Garlic Bread Grilled Cheese

Five ingredients, the fewest in this group, in thirteen minutes, tied for the quickest recipe on this page, two servings at 413 calories. View the full recipe — 13 minutes, serves 2, 413 calories

Garlic Mushroom Grilled Cheese with Cheddar

Eight ingredients, the most in this group, in twenty five minutes, two servings at 471 calories. Cook the mushrooms until they squeak and stop releasing water, or they will steam the bread. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 2, 471 calories

Triple Cheese Bacon Melt

Six ingredients in thirty minutes, the longest in this group, at 605 calories, the heaviest here. Three cheeses is a good idea when one of them is chosen for melt and another for flavour. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 605 calories

Meat Melts

Five, and anything that goes in should be warm and fairly dry. Cold filling means the cheese on either side of it never melts, and wet filling means soggy bread. Drain it, warm it, and keep the layer thin enough that the sandwich still presses flat.

Ground Beef Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Cheddar

Six ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in twenty six minutes, two servings at 635 calories, the lightest of the five. View the full recipe — 26 minutes, serves 2, 635 calories

French Dip Grilled Cheese

Twelve ingredients, the most in this group, in fifty minutes, the longest recipe on this page, at 657 calories. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 4, 657 calories

Sloppy Joe Grilled Cheese

Eleven ingredients in forty five minutes at 660 calories. Sloppy joe filling is deliberately loose, so cook it down further than usual before it goes between bread. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 660 calories

Bacon Pesto Grilled Cheese with Sun Dried Tomatoes

Six ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in thirty minutes, two servings at 665 calories. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 2, 665 calories

Sausage Egg Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Seven ingredients in twenty five minutes, the quickest in this group, two servings at 725 calories, the heaviest here. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 2, 725 calories

Tuna, Bacon and Guacamole

Two with cold fillings that need handling differently. A tuna melt works because the tuna salad is spread thin and the sandwich goes in under a lid, so the filling heats through rather than sitting cold in the middle.

Sourdough Bacon Guacamole Grilled Cheese

Five ingredients in twenty five minutes, the longer of the two, one serving at 726 calories, the lighter. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 1, 726 calories

Skillet Tuna Melt Sandwich

Nine ingredients in twenty minutes, two servings at 834 calories. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 2, 834 calories

Grilled Cheese Burritos

Two that turn the idea inside out: the cheese is griddled onto the outside of a flour tortilla rather than sealed inside bread. It works because a tortilla is thin enough to crisp before the cheese on it burns, which is the opposite of the bread problem.

Beef Grilled Cheese Burrito

Seventeen ingredients, the longest list on this page, in thirty five minutes, the quicker of the two, at 780 calories, the lighter. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 780 calories

Easy Grilled Cheese Burrito

Ten ingredients in forty minutes at 1,120 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page by a wide margin. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 1120 calories

The Unexpected Ones

Four that should not work and mostly do. Three of them pair cheese with something sweet or acidic, which is a sound instinct: cheese is fat and salt, and it wants either acid or sugar against it. The spaghetti one is simply a carbohydrate inside a carbohydrate, and it is better than it sounds.

Glazed Donut Grilled Cheese with Bacon and Maple Syrup

Four ingredients, the shortest list on this page, in twenty five minutes, the longest in this group, two servings at 289 calories, the lightest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 2, 289 calories

Spaghetti Grilled Cheese with Marinara and Mozzarella

Five ingredients in eighteen minutes, tied for the quickest in this group, two servings at 495 calories. View the full recipe — 18 minutes, serves 2, 495 calories

Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese

Five ingredients in eighteen minutes, tied for the quickest in this group, two servings at 538 calories. Blot the pickles dry; their brine is the enemy of crisp bread. View the full recipe — 18 minutes, serves 2, 538 calories

Honey Banana Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Cheddar

Five ingredients in thirteen minutes, tied for the quickest recipe on this page, one serving at 560 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 13 minutes, serves 1, 560 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

The cheese question is more interesting than it looks, and American cheese deserves better than its reputation. Whether a cheese melts into a smooth flowing mass or splits into oil and rubbery strands comes down to how tightly its proteins are bound and how much moisture and acid it holds. Young, moist, low acid cheeses melt well: American, young cheddar, fontina, Gruyere, Monterey Jack, Havarti, provolone. Aged, dry or acidic cheeses do not: parmesan goes grainy, feta and halloumi hold their shape by design, and sharp aged cheddar separates and weeps oil because its protein network has tightened with age. American cheese melts better than any of them for a specific reason: it contains sodium citrate, an emulsifying salt that keeps fat and protein bound together no matter how hot it gets. That is also the trick behind restaurant nacho cheese and behind every smooth homemade mac and cheese sauce. If you want flavour and melt at once, use two cheeses, one chosen for each job. Now the cooking. Medium low heat, a lid, and patience. The lid is the part people skip and it is what makes the difference, because trapped steam conducts heat into the sandwich several times faster than dry air. Grate the cheese, which melts far quicker than slices. Four to five minutes a side is normal and two minutes a side is why your cheese was cold. Butter the bread, not the pan, so every part of the surface is covered. And mayonnaise on the outside browns better than butter, which sounds wrong and is not: butter is around fifteen percent water, which has to boil off before browning starts, while mayonnaise is oil and egg with almost no water and the egg protein browns readily. It also has a higher smoke point, so it is more forgiving. Three more notes. The bread should be sturdy and sliced about half an inch, since thin sandwich bread goes soggy and very thick slices never heat through. Any filling goes in warm and dry, because cold filling stops the cheese melting and wet filling ruins the crust. And press the sandwich gently with a spatula rather than squashing it, which improves contact with the pan without forcing the cheese out of the sides.

Grilled Cheese Questions, Answered

Why is my bread burnt but the cheese not melted?

The heat was too high. Bread browns from about 300F and does it quickly, while cheese needs sustained time to flow. Drop to medium low, put a lid on the pan so trapped steam carries heat inward, and allow four to five minutes a side.

What is the best cheese for grilled cheese?

For melt alone, American, because it contains sodium citrate, an emulsifying salt that keeps the fat and protein bound however hot it gets. For flavour, young cheddar, Gruyere or fontina. The best answer is two cheeses, one picked for each job.

Why does my aged cheddar go stringy and oily?

Aging tightens the protein network and dries the cheese out, so instead of flowing it separates into oil and rubbery strands. Mix it with a younger, moister cheese, or use sodium citrate if you want the sharp flavour and a smooth melt.

Butter or mayonnaise on the outside?

Mayonnaise browns better. Butter is roughly fifteen percent water, which must boil off before browning can start, while mayonnaise is oil and egg with almost no water and its egg protein browns readily. It also has a higher smoke point.

Should I butter the bread or the pan?

The bread. Buttering the pan gives you a greasy patch where the fat pooled and dry bread everywhere else. Spread it right to the edges of the slice.

Does the lid really matter?

More than anything else on this page. Trapped steam conducts heat into the sandwich several times faster than still air, so the cheese melts while the bread browns gently instead of after it has burnt.

What bread should I use?

Something sturdy sliced around half an inch: sourdough, a good white sandwich loaf, or country bread. Thin bread goes soggy under melted cheese and very thick slices never heat through to the middle.

Can I add things to a grilled cheese?

Yes, warm and dry. Cold filling keeps the surrounding cheese from melting, and wet filling steams the bread from inside. Cook mushrooms until they stop releasing water, drain tomatoes, blot pickles, and keep the layer thin.

More to Try

Browse all of our recipe collections.