9 Pizza Casserole Recipes, Pizza Flavour Without a Crust

The flavour people recognise as pizza does not come from the crust. It is a specific stack: glutamate from cooked tomato, more glutamate from aged cheese, the cured pork compounds in pepperoni, and oregano over the top. None of that depends on dough, which is why pizza flavour transfers cleanly into pasta, into a burger patty and into a sloppy joe, and why all nine of these read as pizza rather than as something pretending.

The one thing that goes wrong in all of them is pepperoni fat. A layer of pepperoni renders a surprising amount of grease, and in a covered bake that fat has nowhere to go: it pools and the whole dish turns oily. Crisp the pepperoni in a dry pan first and drain it. The second thing is that pepperoni only crisps when it is exposed, so pepperoni buried in a casserole stays soft and faintly rubbery. Keep a handful back and scatter it on top for the last ten minutes. Nine recipes here, from twenty five minutes to seventy.

Pizza Pasta Bakes

Four, and the pasta rule is the same as every other baked pasta: boil it two minutes short of the package time, because it keeps cooking in the oven and then keeps absorbing sauce on the plate. Make the sauce looser than looks right going in.

Pizza Lasagna Bake

Twelve ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in seventy minutes, the longest recipe on this page, eight servings at 510 calories, the lightest here. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 8, 510 calories

Cheese Tortellini Pepperoni Pizza Casserole

Twelve ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in fifty five minutes, eight servings at 549 calories. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 8, 549 calories

Loaded Pizza Spaghetti Bake

Fourteen ingredients, the longest list on this page, in fifty five minutes, six servings at 703 calories. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 703 calories

Cheesy Pizza Tortellini One Pan

Twelve ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in forty minutes, the quickest in this group, six servings at 729 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page. Tortellini is already filled, so it needs even less boiling than plain pasta. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 6, 729 calories

Pizza Burgers and Sloppy Joes

Three, and these are the quickest things here because there is no bake at all. The pizza element is in the mix rather than on top: tomato paste rather than sauce, so the patty or the mince does not go wet, plus oregano and diced pepperoni worked through.

Pepperoni Pizza Burger

Eight ingredients, tied for the fewest on this page, in twenty five minutes, the quickest recipe here, at 568 calories, also the lightest. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 568 calories

Juicy Pizza Burgers

Eleven ingredients, the most in this group, in thirty minutes at 571 calories. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 571 calories

Pepperoni Pizza Sloppy Joes

Eight ingredients, tied for the fewest on this page, in thirty five minutes, the longest in this group, at 578 calories, the heaviest of the three. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 578 calories

Stromboli and a Double Crust Pie

Two with dough after all, rolled or layered rather than flat. Both need a vent cut in the top before baking, and that is not decorative: the filling releases steam, and steam with nowhere to go will split the seam and push the filling out through the gap.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Stromboli

Ten ingredients, the fewer of the two, in sixty minutes, the longer here, six servings at 581 calories, the lighter. A stromboli is rolled like a log and sliced; a calzone is folded in half. Rolled means the filling has to be spread thin and kept well back from the edges. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 6, 581 calories

Double Crust Pepperoni Sausage Pie

Thirteen ingredients in fifty five minutes, eight servings at 645 calories. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 8, 645 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Three problems and three fixes cover this whole page. Grease is the first and the worst. Pepperoni is typically around forty percent fat, and sausage is not far behind, so a casserole built with either straight from the packet ends up with a slick of orange fat across the top. Crisp the pepperoni in a dry pan over medium heat for three or four minutes, tip it onto paper towel, and discard the rendered fat or keep a spoonful to cook the onions in. Do the same with sausage: brown it, drain it, then build. This single step is the difference between a dish that tastes rich and one that tastes oily. Rubbery pepperoni is the second, and it is a consequence of the first fix being incomplete. Pepperoni only develops that cupped, crisp, slightly blackened edge when it is exposed to dry heat. Buried under cheese and sauce it steams instead, and it comes out soft with the texture of wet salami. So split it: most of it crisped and folded into the dish for flavour, and a generous handful scattered over the top in the last ten minutes of baking, where it can curl and crisp properly. Watery sauce is the third. Pizza sauce as sold is thinner than it needs to be here, because on a pizza it reduces in a 500F oven while a casserole is covered and holds every drop of moisture. Use tomato paste or a thick marinara, or reduce a jar of sauce by a third in a pan first. For the burgers and sloppy joes, tomato paste only: anything wetter and the patty will not hold or the mince will be soup. Two notes on the pasta bakes. Undercook the pasta by two minutes, always, and remember that tortellini and other filled shapes need less time again. Cover for most of the bake so the pasta hydrates evenly, then uncover for the last ten or fifteen minutes to brown the cheese and crisp the pepperoni on top. And for the stromboli, cut two or three vents in the top, chill the rolled log for fifteen minutes before baking so it holds its shape, and brush it with egg wash for colour. Let it rest five minutes before slicing or the filling runs out.

Pizza Casserole Questions, Answered

Why is my pizza casserole greasy?

Pepperoni and sausage are both very high in fat, and in a covered bake that fat has nowhere to escape. Crisp the pepperoni in a dry pan first and drain it on paper towel, and brown and drain any sausage before it goes in.

Why is the pepperoni in my casserole soft and rubbery?

Because it was buried. Pepperoni needs exposure to dry heat to curl and crisp, and under sauce and cheese it steams instead. Keep a handful back and scatter it over the top for the last ten minutes.

Can I use jarred pizza sauce?

Yes, but reduce it first. Pizza sauce is formulated to thin out and reduce in a very hot oven, and a covered casserole holds all that moisture instead. Reduce it by about a third in a pan, or use a thick marinara or tomato paste.

How much should I undercook the pasta?

Two minutes short of the package time, and less again for filled shapes like tortellini. It keeps cooking in the oven and then keeps absorbing sauce on the plate, so a bake that looked right coming out is dry twenty minutes later.

What is the difference between a stromboli and a calzone?

A stromboli is rolled up like a log and sliced across; a calzone is folded in half into a half moon. Rolling means the filling has to be spread thin and kept well back from the edges, and both need venting.

Why did my stromboli split open?

Steam. The filling releases it and it has to go somewhere, so cut two or three vents in the top before baking. Chilling the rolled log for fifteen minutes first also helps it hold its shape.

How do I keep a pizza burger from falling apart?

Use tomato paste rather than sauce, and keep the additions modest. Anything wet in a patty stops the proteins binding, and diced pepperoni and cheese already add fat that will render out and loosen it further.

Should I cover a pizza casserole while it bakes?

Cover it for most of the time so the pasta hydrates evenly, then uncover for the last ten to fifteen minutes. That is when the cheese browns and any pepperoni on top gets its chance to crisp.

More to Try

Browse all of our recipe collections.