25 Pizza Recipes, and the Oven Temperature Nobody Mentions

Pizza at home is mostly an oven problem. A pizzeria deck runs at 700 to 900 degrees F and a home oven tops out around 500, which is why a thin crust at home browns on top before the base ever crisps. Of the twenty five recipes here, four run the oven at 450 degrees F or above and fourteen run it at 400 or below, and that split tells you which ones are pizza and which ones are pizza flavoured.

Neither is worse. A pizza bomb at 400 degrees F is doing something a deck oven cannot, which is feed twelve people from one can of dough. So these are grouped by what the crust actually is, from a ball of real dough down to a flour tortilla and finally to no crust at all.

Real Pizza, as Hot as a Home Oven Goes

The four hottest recipes here, plus two more that earn their place. At 450 degrees F and above the base sets before the toppings overcook, which is the whole trick, and a preheated steel or stone matters more than anything you put on top.

Garlic Cheese Pizza

Six ingredients at 480 degrees F, the hottest oven and the fastest recipe on this page. One ball of dough, eighteen minutes, and almost nothing on it, which is exactly what a hot oven rewards. View the full recipe — 18 minutes, serves 4, 545 calories

Roasted Garlic White Chicken Pizza

A pound of dough at 475 degrees F with no tomato at all, so there is nothing wet to stop the base crisping. Ten ingredients across eight servings. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 8, 347 calories

Sheet Pan School Pizza

Twenty one ingredients, the longest list on this page, at 475 degrees F in a sheet pan for twelve. The thicker base is why a sheet pan survives that heat where a thin round would not. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 12, 332 calories

Sourdough Focaccia Pizza with Freshly Milled Flour

Five hours, hard white wheat flour, eighteen ingredients, baked at 450. A focaccia base is forgiving in a way a thin crust is not, since it is meant to be thick. View the full recipe — 305 minutes, serves 8, 457 calories

Cranberry Chicken Brie Pizza

A twelve inch crust at 425 with brie and cranberry, seven ingredients. Soft cheese and fruit is a combination that needs the shorter bake a bought crust gives you. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 490 calories

Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza on Fathead Crust

An almond flour crust at 400 degrees F, which is lower on purpose because almond flour browns far faster than wheat. Fourteen ingredients and thirty seven grams of protein. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 485 calories

Deep Dish, and Breakfast

Thick bases change the rules: the oven goes down and the time goes up, because heat has to reach the middle of something an inch deep without burning the edge.

Stuffed Deep Dish Pizza Pie

A pound of dough and a pound of beef at 400 degrees F, twelve ingredients. Stuffed means a second layer of dough on top, so the filling steams rather than roasts. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 8, 475 calories

Deep Dish Hamburger Pizza Pie

Two cups of flour made into a deep base at 375, eleven ingredients, nearly two hours. The lower oven is what a thick dough needs. View the full recipe — 115 minutes, serves 8, 561 calories

Sausage Gravy Biscuit Breakfast Pizza

A biscuit base made from scratch, fifteen ingredients, at 425 degrees F for eight servings. Sausage gravy instead of tomato sauce. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 8, 413 calories

Sausage Gravy Breakfast Pizza

The same idea from a can of biscuit dough, nine ingredients, four servings. At 835 calories a serving it is the heaviest recipe on this page, which is what four servings rather than eight does to the same dish. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 835 calories

Handheld, and Built for a Crowd

Six that put the filling inside rather than on top, which is why they all run at 400 degrees F or below: a sealed parcel cooks by steam as much as by heat, and a hotter oven only burns the outside.

Marinara Pizza Dough Roll Ups

Four ingredients, the shortest list on this page, and 146 calories each, the lightest recipe here. Twelve from one can of dough. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 12, 146 calories

Mozzarella Pepperoni Pizza Bombs

Refrigerated pizza dough wrapped around marinara, mozzarella and pepperoni, six ingredients, twelve servings at 175 calories. View the full recipe — 43 minutes, serves 12, 175 calories

Yeast Dough Pizza Pockets

Three cups of flour made into dough from scratch rather than a can, eight ingredients. The hour and three quarters is nearly all rising. View the full recipe — 105 minutes, serves 8, 232 calories

Air Fryer Pizza Bombs

Refrigerated biscuits rather than pizza dough, with a garlic parmesan butter brushed on, nine ingredients. The air fryer does what a 350 degree oven would, in a quarter of the space. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 8, 263 calories

Tortilla Pizza Roll Ups

Twenty servings from twenty small tortillas, the most portions on this page, with four pepperoni slices in each. Seven ingredients. View the full recipe — 43 minutes, serves 20, 267 calories

Four Cheese Pepperoni Pizza Knots

Three cups of flour tied into knots, fourteen ingredients, twelve servings. Knots give you far more browned surface than a flat crust does. View the full recipe — 110 minutes, serves 12, 291 calories

Calzone, Monkey Bread and a Quesadilla

Four more shapes, all of which solve the same problem: how to eat pizza without a plate.

Skillet Pepperoni Pizza Quesadillas

Five ingredients, twenty six minutes, in a skillet rather than an oven. A flour tortilla browns in two minutes, which is the one way to get crust without heat you do not have. View the full recipe — 26 minutes, serves 4, 385 calories

Pepperoni Pizza Monkey Bread

Two cans of biscuit dough pulled apart and layered with pepperoni at 375 degrees F. Seven ingredients, built to be torn rather than sliced. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 8, 473 calories

Lunchbox Pizza Bread with Pepperoni and Cheese

Baked at 350 and designed to be good cold the next day, which almost no pizza is. Fifteen ingredients, eight servings. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 8, 378 calories

Pepperoni Pizza Calzones

Three cups of flour at 425, eight ingredients, nearly two hours. A calzone is pizza folded over, and the sealed edge is why it bakes hotter than a pocket but cooler than a flat pizza. View the full recipe — 115 minutes, serves 8, 329 calories

Pizza Flavour, No Crust

Three that drop the dough entirely. All three bake at 350 to 425, because without a base there is nothing that needs the high heat.

Tater Tot Pizza Casserole

Tater tots standing in for the crust at 425 degrees F, ten ingredients, eight servings. The tots crisp at the same temperature a pizza base would want. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 8, 357 calories

Low Carb Crustless Pizza Bowl

Italian sausage, cheese and toppings with no dough at all, nine ingredients, thirty seven grams of protein a serving. Thirty five minutes. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 562 calories

Meat Lovers Pizza Casserole

Forty eight grams of protein a serving, the most on this page, from eight ingredients. There is no pretence of a crust here. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 720 calories

The Dough and the Sauce

Two components rather than dishes, and the two things that decide whether any of the above is good.

Artisan Pizza Dough

Five ingredients and eight hours, almost all of it a slow cold rise, which is where the flavour in a crust comes from rather than from anything added to it. The longest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 480 minutes, serves 4, 427 calories

Homemade Pizza Sauce

Nineteen ingredients, thirty minutes, and no cooking the tomatoes down for hours. A raw or barely cooked sauce tastes brighter and will not make the base soggy the way a thin simmered one does. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 253 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

The single most useful fact about home pizza is the temperature gap. A commercial deck oven runs at 700 to 900 degrees F and bakes a thin pizza in ninety seconds, which sets the base before the cheese has time to overcook. A domestic oven tops out around 500 and most run to 450, so the same pizza takes eight to twelve minutes, and in that time the toppings finish long before the base is crisp. That is the whole reason home thin crust disappoints, and it is not a recipe problem. Four of the twenty five here run at 450 degrees F or above, and those are the ones built around it. Three things actually close the gap. Preheat a steel or a stone for a full forty five minutes, not ten, because the point is stored heat hitting the base from below rather than air temperature. Keep the toppings sparse, since every wet thing you add is water the base has to drive off before it can brown, which is why the 480 degree recipe here has six ingredients total. And use less sauce than feels right. If a high oven is not available, stop fighting it: the fourteen recipes here at 400 degrees F or below are not compromises, they are different dishes that work at the temperature you have, and a skillet quesadilla browns a tortilla in two minutes without any oven at all.

Pizza Questions, Answered

Why is my homemade pizza base soggy?

Too much sauce, too many wet toppings, or not enough stored heat underneath. A pizza steel or stone preheated for forty five minutes gives the base a blast of conducted heat that a bare oven rack cannot, and that is what drives the water off before the cheese finishes.

What is the hottest I should run my oven?

As hot as it goes, for real pizza. The hottest recipe here is 480 degrees F, and a 500 degree oven with a preheated stone is about as close to a pizzeria as a domestic kitchen gets. Watch it rather than trusting a timer, because at that heat two minutes is the difference between browned and burnt.

Is shop bought dough fine?

Yes, and several recipes here use it deliberately. What a long slow homemade rise gives you is flavour in the crust rather than better structure, which is what the eight hour dough on this page is for. For a Tuesday, a can of dough and a hot oven beats a mediocre dough and a cool one.

What is the fastest pizza here?

The garlic cheese pizza at eighteen minutes, which is also the hottest oven and the shortest topping list. Those three facts are connected: fewer toppings means less water, which means the base crisps in the time a hot oven gives you.

Which recipe feeds the most people?

The tortilla pizza roll ups at twenty servings, then the sheet pan school pizza and three others at twelve. A sheet pan is the most practical format for a crowd, because the thicker base tolerates a long bake without drying.

Can pizza be made ahead?

The dough yes, and it improves for it: a cold rise of eight to twenty four hours develops flavour. An assembled raw pizza no, because the sauce starts soaking into the base immediately. The lunchbox pizza bread on this page is the exception, since it is designed to be eaten cold the next day.

Why do the crustless versions bake cooler?

Because high heat exists to crisp a base. With no dough there is nothing that benefits from 475 degrees F, and the cheese and meat would simply overcook, so those three recipes sit at 350 to 425 where a casserole belongs.

More Pizza Night to Try

The pizza flavoured dishes that did not fit above, plus the collections these sit inside.

Browse all of our recipe collections.