9 Crab Recipes, and Which Grade to Buy

Crab meat is sold in three grades at three prices, and buying the wrong one is the most expensive mistake on this page. Jumbo lump is whole muscles from the swimming legs: large, pale, sweet, and the only grade worth using where you will actually see the meat. Backfin or lump is broken pieces of the same thing, cheaper, and right for most cooking. Claw meat is darker, stronger flavoured and much cheaper, and it belongs in dips, soups and anything where it disappears into a mixture.

Put jumbo lump into a dip and you have paid several times over for texture that nobody will notice. Put claw meat into a crab cake and you get a brown, slightly fishy patty with no lumps in it. Match the grade to the job and crab is far better value than its reputation suggests. Nine recipes here, from twenty seven minutes to just over an hour forty.

Crab Cakes and Fried

Three, and the rule for crab cakes is that the binder is the enemy. A good crab cake is eighty percent or more crab, with just enough breadcrumb and mayonnaise to stop it collapsing. Fold it with a spatula rather than stirring, so the lumps survive, then chill the shaped cakes for at least thirty minutes before they meet the pan: a cold cake holds while its surface browns, and a warm one falls apart.

Pan Fried Lump Crab Cakes

Ten ingredients, the fewest in this group, in fifty three minutes, the quickest here, at 242 calories, also the lightest. View the full recipe — 53 minutes, serves 4, 242 calories

Skillet Crab Cakes with Dijon

Eleven ingredients in fifty five minutes at 318 calories. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 4, 318 calories

Shrimp Crab Nacho Corn Dogs

Thirteen ingredients, the most on this page, in seventy five minutes, the longest in this group, at 420 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 4, 420 calories

Crab Rangoon and Pastries

Four where the crab is mixed into cream cheese, which is exactly the case for buying claw meat and saving the money. Crab rangoon is an American invention rather than a Chinese one, and it is cream cheese first and crab second, which is why the cheaper grade is the sensible choice.

Crab Rangoon Bombs

Eight ingredients, tied for the most in this group, in an hour forty two, the longest recipe on this page, twenty four bombs at 82 calories each, the lightest recipe here and the most portions. View the full recipe — 102 minutes, serves 24, 82 calories

Homemade Crab Rangoon

Seven ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in forty minutes, twelve servings at 166 calories. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 12, 166 calories

Cheesy Crab Stuffed Bread

Seven ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in thirty minutes, eight servings at 229 calories. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 8, 229 calories

Crab and Cheese Filled Crescent Rolls

Eight ingredients, tied for the most in this group, in twenty seven minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, eight servings at 231 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 27 minutes, serves 8, 231 calories

Crab Salads

Two served cold, both forty five minutes, and this is where jumbo lump earns its price. The meat is barely dressed and entirely visible, so its size and sweetness are the whole point. Dress it at the last moment, since salt and acid draw water out of crab meat and leave it stringy.

Creamy Lump Crab Salad

Ten ingredients, the more of the two, at 260 calories, the lighter. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 260 calories

Cucumber Salad with Crab Meat

Eight ingredients at 280 calories. Salt and drain the cucumber first or it will water down the dressing within the hour. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 280 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Buying is most of the skill with crab, so a little more on the grades. In American markets, pasteurised crab meat in a tub is the usual form, and it is genuinely good: it has been cooked, packed and heat treated, and it keeps refrigerated for months unopened and a few days once opened. Jumbo lump is two whole muscles from the back fin and comes in large pale pieces; lump or backfin is a mixture of broken lump and smaller body meat; special or claw is the small shreds and the darker leg meat. Price falls steeply across that range and so does the visible texture, but the flavour of claw meat is arguably stronger rather than worse. Whatever you buy, tip it out and pick through it with your fingers before using it, because shell and cartilage fragments are common even in expensive tubs and finding one at the table is memorable for the wrong reason. Drain it well, and do not rinse it, which washes away flavour. Handle it as little as possible. Crab meat is already cooked, so everything on this page is really about heating it through and binding it, and every stir breaks more lumps. Fold with a rubber spatula, in as few movements as will distribute it, and accept that the mixture will look underbound. It will hold once chilled. For crab cakes specifically: chill the shaped cakes thirty minutes minimum and an hour is better, cook them in a mixture of butter and oil over medium rather than high heat, and turn them once. If they are still collapsing, the answer is more chilling time rather than more breadcrumb. On imitation crab, which deserves a plain explanation rather than snobbery: it is surimi, a paste made from whitefish, usually Alaska pollock, that has been washed, bound with starch and egg white, flavoured, coloured and formed into sticks. It is already salted and sweetened. It is a reasonable ingredient in a dip, a California roll or a cold salad where it is one component among many, and it is completely wrong in a crab cake or anywhere the texture of crab is the point, because it has none. It is also not a budget version of the same thing nutritionally; it is a different food. Two last notes. Old Bay seasoning is the traditional American partner for crab and it is mostly celery salt, paprika and black pepper, so go gently if your dish already has salt in it. And crab is delicate enough that lemon, butter, chives and a little mayonnaise are usually all it wants; strong spicing covers up exactly what you paid for.

Crab Questions, Answered

What is the difference between jumbo lump and claw crab meat?

Jumbo lump is whole muscles from the swimming legs, large, pale and sweet, and the only grade worth using where the meat is visible. Claw meat is darker, stronger flavoured and far cheaper, and belongs in dips and soups. Lump or backfin sits in between.

Why do my crab cakes fall apart?

Not enough chilling, usually. Shape them and refrigerate for at least thirty minutes so the binder sets, then cook over medium heat and turn once. Adding more breadcrumb fixes the symptom and ruins the cake.

How much binder should a crab cake have?

As little as will hold it together. A good crab cake is eighty percent or more crab meat, with breadcrumb and mayonnaise as glue rather than bulk. The mixture should look barely bound before it goes in the refrigerator.

Should I rinse canned or pasteurised crab meat?

No, rinsing washes away flavour. Drain it well, then tip it out and pick through it with your fingers, because shell and cartilage fragments are common even in the expensive grades.

What is imitation crab made of?

Surimi: a paste of washed whitefish, usually Alaska pollock, bound with starch and egg white, then flavoured, coloured and formed. It is fine in a dip or a cold salad and completely wrong in a crab cake, because it has none of the texture of crab.

Is crab meat already cooked?

Yes. Pasteurised tub crab and canned crab are both cooked, so every recipe here is about heating it through and binding it rather than cooking it. That is also why it should be added late and handled as little as possible.

When should I dress a crab salad?

Just before serving. Salt and acid draw water out of crab meat and leave it stringy, so a crab salad dressed an hour ahead is noticeably worse than one dressed at the table.

How long does crab meat keep?

An unopened pasteurised tub keeps for months refrigerated, but once opened, two or three days at most. It should smell sweet and faintly of the sea; any ammonia note means it is finished.

More to Try

Browse all of our recipe collections.