11 Mango Recipes, and the Supermarket Sells the Worst One

The mango most American shops stock is Tommy Atkins, and it was bred for the truck rather than the table. It has a thick skin, it bruises slowly, it keeps for weeks, and it is noticeably fibrous and bland next to the alternatives. Its red blush is a varietal trait and tells you nothing whatever about whether it is ripe, which is where most people go wrong with it.

The ones worth looking for are Ataulfo, sold as honey or champagne mango, which is small, yellow, kidney shaped and almost completely free of fibre, and Kent and Keitt, which are larger, greener and sweeter than Tommy Atkins with much less stringiness. If your only option is Tommy Atkins, buy it hard and ripen it at home, and puree it rather than serving it in slices where the fibre shows. Eleven recipes here, from ten minutes to seven hours.

Mango Drinks

Four, all of them ten minutes, and the puree route is right for every one. Blending destroys the fibre that makes a cheap mango disappointing, which is why a mediocre mango makes a perfectly good drink and a poor slice. Two of these are the same mojito written twice, differing by thirteen calories; pick either.

Easy Mango Mojito

Seven ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, two servings at 135 calories, the lightest here. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 2, 135 calories

Mango Puree Mojito

Seven ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, two servings at 148 calories. Near enough identical to the one above. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 2, 148 calories

Spicy Mango Margarita with Limeade and Chili Salt

Eight ingredients, tied for the most in this group, at 217 calories. Mango and chile is one of the oldest pairings the fruit has, and the sweetness is what makes the heat readable. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 4, 217 calories

Frozen Mango Daiquiris

Eight ingredients, tied for the most in this group, two servings at 225 calories, the heaviest of the four. Use frozen mango chunks rather than ice, which dilutes it. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 2, 225 calories

Frozen and Set Desserts

Four of the long ones, and almost all of that time is setting or freezing. Mango puree carries a lot of water, which is why the ice cream here needs the longest freeze of anything on this page and why a mango panna cotta needs its full chill.

Frozen Fruit Bars with Mango and Berries

Six ingredients over four hours fifteen, ten bars at 50 calories each, the lightest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 255 minutes, serves 10, 50 calories

Mango Panna Cotta

Seven ingredients over four hours twenty at 311 calories. View the full recipe — 260 minutes, serves 4, 311 calories

Mango Berry Meringue Slice with Whipped Cream

Ten ingredients, the most in this group, in three and a half hours, the quickest here, twelve servings at 314 calories, tied for the most portions on this page. View the full recipe — 210 minutes, serves 12, 314 calories

Homemade Mango Ice Cream

Four ingredients, the shortest list on this page, over seven hours, the longest recipe here, eight servings at 362 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 415 minutes, serves 8, 362 calories

Baked, Sticky Rice and Savory

Three where the mango is not the whole dish. The sticky rice is the one to make if you have found a good mango, because the fruit is served in plain slices with nothing to hide behind: this is the recipe that rewards an Ataulfo and punishes a stringy Tommy Atkins.

Strawberry Mango Lime Cupcakes

Twelve ingredients in seventy five minutes, the quickest in this group, twelve cupcakes at 338 calories, the lightest here and tied for the most portions on this page. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 12, 338 calories

Thai Mango Sticky Rice

Six ingredients, the fewest in this group, in two hours forty at 414 calories. View the full recipe — 160 minutes, serves 4, 414 calories

One Pan Caribbean Jerk Chicken Skillet with Mango Salsa

Eighteen ingredients, the longest list on this page, in two hours forty five, the longest in this group, at 508 calories, the heaviest recipe here. View the full recipe — 165 minutes, serves 4, 508 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Ripeness first, because colour is the trap. A mango is ripe when it gives slightly under gentle pressure, the way a ripe avocado does, and when it smells sweet and resinous at the stem end. Colour depends entirely on variety: an Ataulfo goes deep yellow and wrinkles slightly, a Keitt stays green even when fully ripe, and a Tommy Atkins develops a red blush regardless of ripeness. Judging by colour will have you cutting into hard mangoes and leaving ripe ones on the shelf. Mangoes are climacteric, meaning they ripen after picking, so a hard one is not a lost cause: leave it on the counter, or speed it up in a paper bag with a banana, which gives off ethylene. Two or three days is usual. What you cannot do is refrigerate an unripe mango, because cold stops the ripening process permanently and it will never improve. Once ripe, the refrigerator holds it for about five days. Cutting follows the anatomy. The pit is large, flat and oval, running the length of the fruit, which is why there is no good way to cut a mango in half. Stand it on end, find the flatter faces, and slice down either side of the pit about a quarter inch off centre to take off the two cheeks. Score each cheek in a grid without cutting the skin, then push the skin inward so the cubes stand up, which is where the hedgehog name comes from. Trim the remaining flesh off the sides of the pit, and the flesh clinging to the pit itself is cook flesh: suck it or scrape it, but it will not cube. On fibre, which is the real quality difference between varieties: the strings run lengthwise along the pit and are most concentrated close to it. A fibrous mango is fine pureed and poor sliced, so match the variety to the use. For drinks, smoothies, ice cream and sorbet, a cheap Tommy Atkins blends into something indistinguishable from a good mango. For sticky rice, a salsa, a salad or anything served in visible pieces, pay for an Ataulfo or a Kent. Two more notes. The skin contains compounds related to those in poison ivy and a few people react to handling it, so peel rather than bite. And underripe mango is a legitimate ingredient in its own right rather than a failure: sour, firm and crunchy, it is what green mango salad is made from, and it holds its shape in a way ripe mango cannot.

Mango Questions, Answered

How do I tell if a mango is ripe?

By feel and smell, never colour. It should give slightly under gentle pressure like a ripe avocado, and smell sweet at the stem end. Colour is a varietal trait: a Keitt stays green when ripe and a Tommy Atkins blushes red whether it is ripe or not.

Which mango variety should I buy?

Ataulfo, sold as honey or champagne mango, which is small, yellow and almost fibre free. Kent and Keitt are also good. Tommy Atkins is the usual supermarket mango and the most fibrous and bland of them, bred for shipping rather than flavour.

Can I ripen a hard mango at home?

Yes. Mangoes ripen after picking, so leave it on the counter for two or three days, or put it in a paper bag with a banana to speed it up with ethylene. What you must not do is refrigerate an unripe mango, which halts ripening permanently.

How do I cut a mango?

Stand it on end, locate the flat faces, and slice down either side of the flat oval pit about a quarter inch off centre to remove the two cheeks. Score each cheek in a grid without cutting the skin, then push the skin inward so the cubes stand up.

Why is my mango stringy?

Variety, mostly. The fibres run lengthwise along the pit and are heaviest close to it, and Tommy Atkins has far more of them than Ataulfo or Kent. A stringy mango is excellent pureed into a drink or ice cream and disappointing in slices.

Should I use fresh or frozen mango?

Frozen is genuinely good for drinks, ice cream and smoothies, and often more reliable than a hard supermarket mango. For anything served in visible pieces, fresh and properly ripe is the only option that works.

How long does a ripe mango keep?

About five days in the refrigerator once it is ripe, and a couple of days on the counter. Cut mango keeps two or three days refrigerated, and freezes well in chunks for several months.

Can I use underripe mango?

Yes, as its own ingredient rather than as a substitute. Green mango is sour, firm and crunchy and holds its shape, which is what green mango salad is built on. It will not behave like ripe mango in a dessert.

More to Try

Browse all of our recipe collections.