22 BBQ Recipes, and Why Sauce Goes On Last

BBQ sauce burns, and it burns early. Most bottled sauce is somewhere between a third and half sugar by weight once you add up the molasses, brown sugar and ketchup in it. Sucrose begins to caramelise around 320F and turns acrid not far above 355F, which is well under the surface temperature of a grill and under most oven settings too. Brush sauce on at the start of a forty minute cook and it is black before the chicken is done, which is the single most common BBQ failure there is.

The fix is simply timing. Cook the meat plain, seasoned with a dry rub if you like, then brush the sauce on in the last five to ten minutes and let it set in two or three thin coats rather than one thick one. Twenty two recipes here, from twenty minutes to twenty four hours.

BBQ Chicken, Oven and Grill

Five cooked fast and hot, which means the sauce timing above matters most in this group. On a grill, keep a cooler zone to move pieces to once the sauce is on, because the moment sugar meets direct flame it has about a minute.

Oven Baked BBQ Chicken Wings

Seven ingredients in sixty minutes at 314 calories, the lightest in this group. Wings need a dry start to crisp the skin, so sauce them after they come out. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 4, 314 calories

Grilled BBQ Chicken Drumsticks with Indirect Heat

Five ingredients, tied for the fewest on this page, in seventy minutes, tied for the longest in this group, at 387 calories. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 4, 387 calories

Oven Baked BBQ Chicken with Homemade Barbecue Sauce

Eleven ingredients, the most in this group, in seventy minutes, tied for the longest here, at 453 calories. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 4, 453 calories

One Pan BBQ Chicken and Rice with Chicken Thighs

Five ingredients, tied for the fewest on this page, in forty five minutes, the quickest in this group, at 459 calories. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 459 calories

Oven Baked Honey BBQ Chicken Rice

Ten ingredients in fifty five minutes at 471 calories, the heaviest in this group. Honey adds more sugar on top of what the sauce already has, so this one needs watching. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 4, 471 calories

Slow Cooker Pulled BBQ Chicken

Seven, and the reason they all run four hours or more is collagen. Connective tissue converts to gelatin only after sustained time above about 160F, and that gelatin is what makes pulled meat moist rather than merely shredded. Thighs have far more of it than breast, which is why pulled chicken breast tends to come out dry and stringy unless it sits in liquid.

Slow Cooker BBQ Chicken Breasts

Nine ingredients over four hours ten, the quickest in this group, six servings at 268 calories, the lightest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 250 minutes, serves 6, 268 calories

Slow Cooker BBQ Pulled Chicken Sandwiches

Ten ingredients over five hours ten, ten servings at 312 calories, tied for the most portions on this page. View the full recipe — 310 minutes, serves 10, 312 calories

Slow Cooker BBQ Chicken for a Crowd

Nine ingredients over six hours ten, the longest in this group, eight servings at 376 calories. View the full recipe — 370 minutes, serves 8, 376 calories

Crock Pot BBQ Pulled Chicken

Twelve ingredients, the most in this group, over five hours ten, six servings at 386 calories. View the full recipe — 310 minutes, serves 6, 386 calories

Italian Dressing BBQ Chicken in the Slow Cooker

Eight ingredients over five hours ten, six servings at 401 calories. The dressing brings acid and oil, which is doing a marinade job rather than a sauce one. View the full recipe — 310 minutes, serves 6, 401 calories

Crockpot BBQ Chicken

Seven ingredients, the fewest in this group, over five hours fifteen, six servings at 409 calories. View the full recipe — 315 minutes, serves 6, 409 calories

Brown Sugar Mustard BBQ Chicken in the Crock Pot

Eleven ingredients over five hours ten, six servings at 520 calories, the heaviest in this group. Mustard is the right partner for brown sugar here, since its acid cuts sweetness that would otherwise be cloying. View the full recipe — 310 minutes, serves 6, 520 calories

BBQ Beef, Brisket and Ribs

Four of the long ones, and in a slow cooker they are all effectively braises rather than barbecue. That is not a criticism, it is just worth naming: real barbecue is dry heat with smoke at 225F to 275F for hours, and a covered pot is moist heat. The meat comes out tender either way and it tastes of sauce rather than smoke.

Slow Cooked Beef Ribs with Barbecue Sauce

Nineteen ingredients, tied for the longest list on this page, over eight hours twenty five, six servings at 398 calories, the lightest in this group. View the full recipe — 505 minutes, serves 6, 398 calories

Slow Cooker BBQ Brisket with Caramelized Sauce

Nineteen ingredients, tied for the longest list on this page, over ten hours forty five, eight servings at 497 calories. Slice brisket across the grain or it will be stringy however long it cooked. View the full recipe — 645 minutes, serves 8, 497 calories

Crockpot BBQ Beef Sandwiches

Eight ingredients, the fewest in this group, over eight hours fifteen, the quickest here, eight servings at 573 calories. View the full recipe — 495 minutes, serves 8, 573 calories

Galbi Korean BBQ Short Ribs

Fifteen ingredients over about twenty four hours, the longest recipe on this page, at 690 calories, also the heaviest. Most of that is a marinade, and Korean barbecue is grilled fast rather than smoked slow. View the full recipe — 1465 minutes, serves 4, 690 calories

Wings, Sausages and Smoked

Four more, including the only genuinely smoked recipe here. Smoke flavour comes from compounds in wood smoke binding to the surface of the meat, and it binds best to a cool damp surface, which is why smoking starts low and why patting the meat dry is the wrong move at the beginning.

Crispy Slow Cooker BBQ Wings with a Broiled Finish

Eight ingredients over four hours ten, the longest in this group, at 380 calories, the lightest here. View the full recipe — 250 minutes, serves 4, 380 calories

Smoked BBQ Chicken

Eleven ingredients, the most in this group, over four hours at 414 calories. View the full recipe — 240 minutes, serves 4, 414 calories

Crockpot BBQ Cocktail Sausages

Six ingredients, the fewest in this group, over four hours five, ten servings at 462 calories, tied for the most portions on this page. View the full recipe — 245 minutes, serves 10, 462 calories

Smoked Sausage BBQ Pasta Skillet

Ten ingredients in thirty five minutes, the quickest in this group by a wide margin, at 669 calories, the heaviest here. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 669 calories

BBQ and Bacon

Two where bacon is carrying the smoke that the cooking method does not. It is a legitimate shortcut: bacon is cured and smoked, so it brings the flavour of a smoker to something that spent forty five minutes in an oven.

BBQ Bacon Ranch BLT Sandwich

Six ingredients in twenty minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, two servings at 403 calories, the lighter of the two. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 2, 403 calories

Ranch Style BBQ Bacon Cheddar Chicken

Twelve ingredients in forty five minutes at 542 calories. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 542 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Two definitions worth separating before anything else. Barbecue, strictly, is low indirect heat with wood smoke, 225F to 275F for several hours, which is what breaks down tough connective tissue and lays smoke compounds on the surface. Grilling is high direct heat for minutes. Most of what Americans call BBQ chicken is grilled or oven baked chicken with barbecue sauce on it, and that is a perfectly good dinner, it is simply a different technique. Only one recipe on this page is actually smoked, and the slow cooker ones are braises. Knowing which you are doing tells you what to expect: braised meat is tender and tastes of its sauce, smoked meat has a ring of flavour on the outside and tastes of wood. Now the sauce rule, which is the most useful thing on this page. Barbecue sauce is heavily sugared, and sugar caramelises from about 320F and burns not long after. Grill grates run hotter than that, so sauce applied early is carbon by the time the inside is cooked. Cook plain, sauce in the last five to ten minutes, and build two or three thin layers rather than one thick one, letting each set before the next. In the oven the same applies with a little more latitude, since 375F dry heat is gentler on sugar than a flame is. If you want flavour on the meat from the start, use a dry rub, which is mostly salt, paprika, pepper and a modest amount of sugar, and it handles heat far better than sauce. Three more things. Salt early: a dry brine of salt on the surface an hour ahead, or overnight for larger cuts, gives you meat seasoned through rather than seasoned on top. Rest the meat before cutting, five minutes for chicken pieces and twenty or more for brisket, because juices redistribute as the muscle fibres relax. And cut across the grain, which matters enormously on brisket and short ribs: the same meat cut the wrong way is stringy no matter how long it cooked. For pulled meat, the target is not an internal temperature but a texture. Collagen needs sustained time above roughly 160F to become gelatin, so pulled pork and pulled chicken thighs are done when they shred under a fork and not before, which is usually well past the point where a thermometer says they are safe to eat.

BBQ Questions, Answered

When should I put BBQ sauce on?

In the last five to ten minutes. BBQ sauce is a third to half sugar, and sugar caramelises from around 320F and burns shortly after, which is cooler than a grill surface. Brush on two or three thin coats at the end rather than one thick one at the start.

Why does my BBQ chicken burn on the outside and stay raw inside?

The sauce went on too early. The sugar in it blackens long before the chicken reaches 165F. Cook it plain or with a dry rub, then sauce it at the end, and keep a cooler zone on the grill to move pieces to once the sauce is on.

Is slow cooker BBQ really barbecue?

No, it is a braise. Barbecue is dry heat with wood smoke at 225F to 275F for hours. A covered pot is moist heat with no smoke. The meat still comes out tender, it just tastes of the sauce rather than of wood.

Should I use chicken breast or thighs for pulled chicken?

Thighs. Pulled meat is moist because collagen has turned to gelatin, and breast has very little collagen, so pulled breast is really just shredded chicken and it dries out. If you only have breast, keep it submerged in liquid.

Dry rub or sauce?

Both, at different times. A rub is mostly salt, paprika and pepper with modest sugar, so it stands up to long heat and seasons the surface throughout cooking. Sauce is for the end. Using only sauce means the inside of the meat tastes of nothing.

How do I know when pulled pork or chicken is done?

By texture, not temperature. It is ready when it shreds easily under a fork, which happens well after it is technically safe to eat, because collagen needs sustained hours above about 160F to convert to gelatin.

Why is my brisket tough even after ten hours?

Either it needs longer, or it was sliced with the grain. Those are different problems with the same symptom. Slice across the grain always, and if it still resists a fork it simply has not finished converting its collagen.

Can I get smoke flavour without a smoker?

Partly. Smoked paprika, a few drops of liquid smoke, or bacon in the dish all contribute something, and two recipes above use bacon for exactly this. None of them reproduce real smoke, which binds to the meat surface over hours, but they get you closer than nothing.

More to Try

Browse all of our recipe collections.