20 Mac and Cheese Recipes, and Why 17 of Them Start With a Roux

Mac and cheese is a sauce recipe wearing a pasta costume. The macaroni is the easy part. Everything that makes it good or grainy happens in the pan before the pasta goes in, and seventeen of these twenty prove it: they start by cooking flour into melted butter, then whisking in milk. That is a roux, and it is what keeps the cheese from splitting.

The three that skip it are all slow cooker or casserole hybrids, where long gentle heat and starch do a similar job. Everything else here is a variation on the same sauce, and twelve of the twenty finish with a crumb topping. Times run from thirty minutes to six and a half hours.

Stovetop, Thirty to Forty Five Minutes

Four that never see an oven, which makes them the creamiest versions here. Baking sets a mac and cheese and dries it slightly; a stovetop one stays loose and glossy, which is the right answer on a Tuesday.

Southern Macaroni and Cheese

Seven ingredients, the shortest list on this page, in thirty minutes. Six servings at 677 calories, the heaviest of the four, because the ratio of cheese to pasta is high. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 6, 677 calories

diner style mac and cheese

Eight ingredients and thirty minutes, 644 calories across four. The sauce is deliberately thin going in, because it tightens as it sits. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 644 calories

Creamy Stovetop Mac and Cheese

Nine ingredients, thirty five minutes, 619 calories, the lightest of the four. The plain stovetop version to learn the roux on. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 6, 619 calories

Sharp Cheddar Blue Cheese Macaroni

Ten ingredients at 650 calories. Blue cheese is strong enough that a little changes the whole dish, which is why it is paired with sharp cheddar rather than mild. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 6, 650 calories

Baked, With a Crumb Top

Six that go into the oven with breadcrumbs or panko on top. The topping is not decoration, it is the textural contrast that makes baked mac worth the extra half hour. Butter the crumbs before they go on or they will not brown.

One Pot Baked Mac and Cheese with Panko Topping

Twelve ingredients in forty minutes, the quickest baked version here, at 568 calories, also the lightest. One pot means the pasta cooks in the sauce liquid. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 6, 568 calories

Homemade Macaroni and Cheese

Ten ingredients, forty five minutes, six servings at 725 calories. The straightforward baked version, roux and crumbs and nothing clever. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 6, 725 calories

Baked Three Cheese Mac and Cheese

Eleven ingredients at 653 calories across four. Three cheeses blended rather than one, which gives a more complex flavour and a slightly softer set. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 4, 653 calories

Gruyere Baked Mac and Cheese with Panko Topping

Sixteen ingredients over an hour. Gruyere melts smoothly and browns well, which is why it turns up in so many baked versions. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 6, 595 calories

Three Cheese Baked Macaroni

Twelve ingredients at 871 calories across four servings, the heaviest in this group. A rich version rather than a sensible one. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 4, 871 calories

Panko Baked Mac and Cheese

Fifteen ingredients over seventy minutes, eight servings at 768 calories. Panko stays crisper than ordinary breadcrumbs because the flakes are larger and drier. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 8, 768 calories

Where the Cheese Is the Whole Point

Three built around the cheese choice rather than the method. Worth knowing: pre shredded cheese is coated in starch to stop it clumping in the bag, and that starch is a common cause of a grainy sauce. Grate your own.

Cheddar Gruyere Mac and Cheese

Eleven ingredients, fifty minutes, 485 calories, the lightest recipe on this page. Cheddar for flavour and gruyere for melt, which is the standard pairing. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 6, 485 calories

Easy Homemade Mac and Cheese

Thirteen ingredients in forty five minutes across eight servings at 743 calories. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 8, 743 calories

Baked Cavatappi Mac and Cheese

Eleven ingredients and 943 calories a serving, the heaviest recipe on this page. Cavatappi rather than elbows, and the only recipe here using evaporated milk, which resists splitting better than fresh milk does. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 8, 943 calories

With Something In It

Four where mac and cheese becomes dinner rather than a side. All four run fifty five minutes to an hour, because browning the protein happens before the sauce does.

Mac and Cheese Meatloaf Casserole

Nine ingredients at 587 calories, the lightest in this group, and one of the three here with no roux. Meatloaf and mac in one dish, which is more sensible than it sounds. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 6, 587 calories

Cheesy Beef Macaroni Bake

Seventeen ingredients over fifty five minutes, six servings at 760 calories. Ground beef in the sauce rather than layered. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 760 calories

Baked Chicken Broccoli Mac and Cheese

Fifteen ingredients in an hour, 833 calories across four. The broccoli goes in with enough bite left to cut through the sauce. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 4, 833 calories

Lobster Mac and Cheese with Gruyere and Cheddar

Eighteen ingredients, the longest list on this page, over an hour. Eight servings, and the lobster goes in at the end so it does not toughen under the bake. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 8, 834 calories

Slow Cooker and Smoker

Three that trade attention for time. The two slow cooker versions are also two of the three recipes here without a roux, because several hours of gentle heat plus the starch from the pasta thickens the sauce on its own.

Smoked Mac and Cheese with Cheddar and Gouda

Thirteen ingredients over an hour thirty five, eight servings at 655 calories. Made with a roux and then smoked, which is the only way to get smoke into a cheese sauce. View the full recipe — 95 minutes, serves 8, 655 calories

Crockpot Chicken and Broccoli Mac and Cheese

Ten ingredients over four hours ten, 502 calories, the lightest in this group. No roux and no stirring. View the full recipe — 250 minutes, serves 6, 502 calories

Slow Cooker Chili Mac and Cheese

Twelve ingredients over six and a half hours, the longest recipe on this page, six servings at 532 calories. Chili and mac in one pot, no roux. View the full recipe — 385 minutes, serves 6, 532 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Three things cause bad mac and cheese and all three are fixable. The first is pre shredded cheese. It is coated in potato starch or cellulose so the shreds do not stick together in the bag, and that coating is the single most common cause of a grainy, slightly chalky sauce. Buy a block and grate it. It takes two minutes and it is the biggest single improvement available. The second is heat. Cheese protein tightens and squeezes out its fat when it gets too hot, which is what splitting is: the oily puddle on top is the fat that has left the sauce. Take the pan off the heat before the cheese goes in, add it in handfuls, and stir until each one disappears. A sauce that has split cannot be fully rescued, though a splash of milk and vigorous whisking off the heat recovers most of it. The third is the pasta. Cook it two minutes short of the box time, because it will keep absorbing sauce afterwards, and in a baked version it carries on cooking in the oven. Fully cooked pasta going into a baked mac comes out mushy every time. On the roux itself: equal weights of butter and flour, cooked together for a minute or two until it smells faintly of biscuits rather than raw flour, then milk added gradually while whisking. That sauce is a bechamel, and once you can make it you can make every recipe on this page. Cheese choice matters less than people think, with one rule: you need a good melter and a good flavour, and they are rarely the same cheese. Sharp cheddar brings flavour but can go oily alone; gruyere, fontina or young gouda melt beautifully but taste mild. Use both, which is what the recipes above do.

Mac and Cheese Questions, Answered

Why is my cheese sauce grainy?

Almost always pre shredded cheese. The anti caking starch on the shreds does not dissolve, and you taste it as grit. Grate cheese from a block, and add it off the heat rather than over a flame.

Why did my cheese sauce split into oil?

It got too hot. Cheese releases its fat when the protein tightens, and that is the oil on top. Pull the pan off the heat before adding cheese, and add it gradually. Whisking in a little milk off the heat recovers most of a split sauce.

Do I need to make a roux?

Not strictly, and three recipes here do not, but seventeen do for a reason. A flour based sauce holds the cheese in suspension and will not split as easily. The alternatives are evaporated milk, which resists splitting, or a slow cooker where the pasta starch does the thickening.

Should I use pre shredded cheese?

No. It is the main cause of a grainy sauce. If you must, add a splash more milk and expect a slightly less smooth result.

How long should I cook the pasta?

Two minutes less than the package says. It keeps absorbing liquid after draining, and in a baked version it continues cooking in the oven. Fully cooked pasta going into a bake comes out soft.

Stovetop or baked?

Stovetop is creamier and faster, and four of the recipes here take thirty to forty minutes. Baked gives you a browned crumb top and a firmer set, and costs an extra half hour. Neither is more authentic than the other.

What are the best cheeses for mac and cheese?

A combination. Sharp cheddar for flavour, plus a good melter like gruyere, fontina or young gouda for texture. Cheeses that taste strongest tend to melt worst, which is why almost every recipe above uses two or more.

Can mac and cheese be made ahead?

Yes, assembled and refrigerated up to a day before baking, with the crumbs added just before it goes in. Add a splash of milk when reheating leftovers, since the pasta keeps absorbing sauce in the fridge.

More Pasta and Comfort Food

Three more macaroni recipes and the collections these sit inside.

Browse all of our recipe collections.