For anything cooked, canned tomatoes beat fresh, and this is not a compromise. Canned tomatoes are picked ripe and processed within hours, while supermarket fresh tomatoes are picked green so they survive shipping and are ripened afterwards with ethylene gas, which colours them without developing flavour. Our own archive reflects it: of sixty two tomato recipes, twenty six call for canned, eighteen for fresh, fifteen for sun dried and two for paste, and the canned ones are overwhelmingly the dishes that get cooked down.
Fresh tomatoes earn their place where they stay raw or barely cooked: salads, salsas, a quick pan sauce in August. Sun dried are a different ingredient again, concentrated and almost savoury, and fifteen recipes here use them, eleven of those with chicken. The one storage rule that matters: never refrigerate a fresh tomato, because below about 54 degrees F the compounds that make it taste of anything break down and the texture goes mealy. That damage is permanent.
Tomato Soup, Six Ways
Six, and five of them start with a tin, which is correct. The variable is whether the tomatoes are roasted first, which concentrates them and adds a sweetness no amount of simmering will.
Pantry Tomato Basil Soup with Canned Tomatoes
Nine ingredients in forty minutes, 132 calories, the lightest soup here. One large tin of crushed tomatoes and little else. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 132 calories
Roasted Tomato Basil Soup
Twelve ingredients in sixty five minutes, the longest of the six, six servings at 181 calories. Two and a half pounds of fresh tomatoes roasted first, which is the one version where fresh is worth it. View the full recipe — 65 minutes, serves 6, 181 calories
Creamy Tomato Basil Soup
Nine ingredients in forty minutes at 334 calories. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 334 calories
Tomato Basil Cream Soup with Fresh Basil
Ten ingredients in thirty five minutes, the quickest of the six, at 335 calories. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 335 calories
Creamy Tomato Bisque Soup
Thirteen ingredients in forty minutes at 365 calories. A bisque is blended smooth and enriched, which is the difference from the versions above. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 365 calories
Grilled Cheese and Creamy Tomato Soup
Eight ingredients in thirty minutes at 545 calories, the heaviest in this group. Both halves of the pairing in one recipe. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 545 calories
Sun Dried Tomato and Chicken
Five from the fifteen sun dried recipes in the archive, eleven of which pair it with chicken. Sun dried tomatoes are concentrated to the point of being almost savoury rather than fruity, and oil packed ones can go straight in while dry packed need twenty minutes in hot water first.
Sun Dried Tomato Crockpot Chicken
Eight ingredients over four hours ten, 384 calories, the lightest of the five. The least work and the longest wait. View the full recipe — 250 minutes, serves 4, 384 calories
Sun Dried Tomato Spinach Chicken
Eleven ingredients in forty minutes at 506 calories. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 506 calories
Creamy Sun Dried Tomato Chicken in the Crockpot
Twelve ingredients over five hours fifteen, the longest recipe on this page, at 540 calories. View the full recipe — 315 minutes, serves 4, 540 calories
Creamy Parmesan Chicken with Sun Dried Tomatoes and Basil
Nine ingredients in thirty five minutes, tied for the quickest of the five, at 595 calories. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 595 calories
Creamy Tuscan Chicken Skillet with Sun Dried Tomatoes
Nine ingredients in thirty five minutes, two servings at 954 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page. The oil the tomatoes are packed in goes into the sauce, which is where some of that sits. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 2, 954 calories
Fresh Tomato With a Protein
Four where fresh tomatoes go into a hot pan briefly. Cherry and grape tomatoes are the right choice for this: they have thicker skins and less water than a sliced beefsteak, so they burst and concentrate rather than flooding the pan.
Garlic Tomato Baked Chicken
Eight ingredients in forty minutes at 295 calories, the lightest of the four. Three cups of cherry tomatoes roasted alongside the chicken. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 295 calories
Basil Garlic Tomato Chicken Breasts
Nine ingredients in thirty five minutes at 351 calories. Two large tomatoes, chopped rather than halved, so they break into a sauce. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 351 calories
Cherry Tomato White Wine Chicken
Twelve ingredients in thirty minutes at 423 calories. Wine and tomato both bring acid, so this needs no lemon. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 423 calories
Creamy Tuscan Chicken with Cherry Tomatoes and Lemon
Eleven ingredients in forty five minutes, the longest of the four, at 574 calories, the heaviest. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 574 calories
Canned Tomato With Pasta, Rice and Beef
Four built on a tin, and this is where canned tomatoes are not merely acceptable but better. One tip worth more than it sounds: buy whole peeled rather than diced. Diced tomatoes contain calcium chloride to hold their shape, so they never fully break down, while whole ones crushed by hand collapse into a sauce.
Ground Beef Tomato Macaroni
Eight ingredients in thirty five minutes, six servings at 432 calories, the lightest of the four. Tomato paste rather than tinned tomatoes, which gives depth without liquid. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 6, 432 calories
Ground Beef Tomato Rice Casserole with Cheddar
Ten ingredients in fifty five minutes, six servings at 458 calories. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 458 calories
Tomato Tuna Pasta Bake with Mozzarella
Fifteen ingredients in fifty five minutes at 548 calories, with twenty eight ounces of crushed tomatoes. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 4, 548 calories
Stovetop Tomato Cream Beef Pasta
Ten ingredients in forty minutes at 631 calories, the heaviest of the four. Cream added at the end, after the tomatoes have cooked down, or it splits. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 631 calories
Raw and Cold
Three where the tomato is never cooked, and these are the recipes that actually depend on good fruit. Salt the tomatoes ten minutes ahead, let them release their juice, and use that juice in the dressing rather than pouring it away.
Cucumber Tomato Feta Salad
Nine ingredients in twenty five minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, at 218 calories, the lightest of the three. A pound of tomatoes, and feta supplies the salt. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 218 calories
Sizzled Garlic Farro Salad with Roasted Tomatoes
Fifteen ingredients over ninety minutes, the longest of the three, at 360 calories. Fourteen ounces of grape tomatoes. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 4, 360 calories
Bocconcini Pesto Pasta Salad with Cherry Tomatoes
Fourteen ingredients in forty five minutes, six servings at 530 calories, the heaviest of the three. Eight ounces of cherry tomatoes with small mozzarella balls. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 6, 530 calories
Sauces, Pies and Fried Green
Three more fresh tomato dishes, including the only one here that uses them unripe. Green tomatoes are firm and tart and hold their shape through frying in a way a ripe one cannot.
Fresh Tomato Chili Sauce
Nine ingredients in thirty minutes, eight servings at 46 calories, the lightest recipe on this page. A cup of ripe tomatoes cooked down with chilli. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 8, 46 calories
Southern Fried Green Tomatoes
Nine ingredients in forty minutes at 197 calories. Four medium green tomatoes, and unripe is the point rather than a substitution. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 197 calories
Crustless Cheesy Tomato Pie
Eight ingredients in sixty minutes, the longest of the three, six servings at 230 calories. Three large ripe tomatoes, salted and drained first or the pie goes watery. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 6, 230 calories
Before You Choose Your Recipe
Never put a fresh tomato in the fridge. Below about 54 degrees F the enzymes that produce the aroma compounds in a tomato shut down and the cell walls degrade, which is why a refrigerated tomato tastes of nothing and has that dry, mealy texture. The damage does not reverse when it warms up. Keep them stem side down on the counter, out of direct sun, and use them within a few days. The only exception is a tomato already cut, which does need refrigerating and will never be as good again. Canned is better for cooking, and that is not a concession. Tomatoes destined for tins are harvested ripe and processed within hours; tomatoes destined for a supermarket shelf are picked green and gassed with ethylene to turn them red, which develops colour and almost no flavour. For a soup, a sauce, a braise or anything simmered, a good tin beats an average fresh tomato every time, and it is cheaper. Buy whole peeled rather than diced: diced tomatoes have calcium chloride added to keep the cubes intact, which means they stay as cubes no matter how long you cook them, while whole peeled ones crushed in your hand collapse into a proper sauce. Plum varieties, San Marzano among them, have denser flesh and less water. Fry your tomato paste. This is the most underused tomato technique there is: before adding any liquid, cook the paste in the hot oil for a minute or two until it darkens from bright red to brick, stirring constantly. It caramelises, loses the raw tinny edge, and adds a depth that stirring it into liquid never will. On acidity, do not reach for sugar. Sugar masks the sharpness rather than removing it, and the dish ends up sweet instead of balanced. Salt and a longer cook does more, and if a sauce is genuinely too acidic a pinch of baking soda neutralises it chemically, though it will foam and you should add it off the heat. For sun dried tomatoes, oil packed ones go straight in and the oil is worth using in the dish. Dry packed ones are leathery and need twenty minutes in hot water or stock before they are pleasant. And when a recipe wants fresh tomatoes in a pie, a tart or a bake, salt the slices and let them drain for twenty minutes first. A tomato is about ninety five percent water and all of it comes out in the oven.
Tomato Questions, Answered
Should I store tomatoes in the fridge?
No. Below about 54 degrees F the aroma compounds stop being produced and the texture goes mealy, and neither comes back. Keep them on the counter, stem side down, out of direct sunlight. Cut tomatoes do need refrigerating.
Are canned tomatoes really better than fresh for cooking?
For anything cooked down, yes. Canned tomatoes are picked ripe and processed within hours, while fresh supermarket ones are picked green and gas ripened, which gives colour without flavour. They are also cheaper.
Should I buy whole peeled or diced canned tomatoes?
Whole peeled. Diced tomatoes have calcium chloride added so the cubes keep their shape, which means they never break down into a sauce. Crush whole ones by hand in the pan.
Why should I fry tomato paste?
Cooking the paste in hot oil for a minute or two until it darkens caramelises it and removes the raw, tinny taste. It is the single biggest improvement you can make to a tomato sauce and it costs two minutes.
How do I reduce the acidity in a tomato sauce?
Salt and a longer cook do most of it. Sugar masks acidity rather than fixing it and leaves the sauce sweet. If it is genuinely too sharp, a pinch of baking soda off the heat neutralises the acid chemically, though it will foam.
What is the difference between oil packed and dry sun dried tomatoes?
Oil packed are soft and ready to use, and the oil itself is worth putting in the dish. Dry packed are leathery and need twenty minutes soaking in hot water or stock first, or they stay tough.
How do I stop a tomato pie or tart going watery?
Salt the slices and leave them to drain in a colander for twenty minutes, then pat them dry. A tomato is roughly ninety five percent water and it all comes out in the oven otherwise.
Which tomatoes are best for a quick pan sauce?
Cherry or grape. Thicker skins and less water than a large sliced tomato, so they burst and concentrate rather than flooding the pan. Four of the recipes above use them for exactly that reason.
More to Try
Four more tomato recipes and the collections these sit inside.
- Marinated Cherry Tomatoes — twelve ingredients, three pints
- Sun Dried Tomato Pesto Sauce — eight ingredients, thirteen minutes
- Quick Tomato Chutney — eleven ingredients, 42 calories
- Bacon Onion Tomato Pie — twelve ingredients, eight servings
- Soup Recipes — where the tomato soups belong
- Pasta Recipes — twenty five across every shape
- Italian Recipes — where the Tuscan dishes sit
- Chicken Recipes — nine of these are chicken
- Pesto Recipes — including sun dried tomato pesto
Browse all of our recipe collections.
































