25 Pudding Recipes, and the Four Things That Word Means

Pudding means four unrelated things depending on the recipe, and the word tells you nothing. It can be a cooked custard you eat with a spoon. It can be a bread pudding, which is a baked dish of soaked bread. In British usage it is a self saucing sponge cake. And in eleven of our thirty three pudding recipes it is not a dessert at all: it is a box of instant pudding mix used as a thickener and a flavouring inside something else, like a cake, a frosting or a layered lush.

The two that are easiest to confuse in the kitchen are custards, and they follow opposite rules. An egg thickened custard must never boil, because the eggs scramble above about 180 degrees F. A cornstarch thickened pudding must boil, because starch does not gel until it does. Same bowl, same spoon, completely contradictory instruction, and getting them the wrong way round is the most common pudding failure there is.

Pudding You Eat With a Spoon

Five made from scratch rather than from a box. Three of them are stovetop, which means constant stirring and a low heat, and that is the entire skill. Press cling film directly onto the surface while it cools or a skin forms.

Stovetop Vanilla Custard

Five ingredients, tied for the shortest list on this page, in twenty two minutes at 196 calories, the lightest pudding in this group. The base recipe to learn, since everything else here is a variation on it. View the full recipe — 22 minutes, serves 4, 196 calories

Vanilla Chia Seed Pudding

Nine ingredients over two hours ten at 209 calories. No cooking at all; the chia seeds thicken it by absorbing liquid, which takes time rather than heat. View the full recipe — 130 minutes, serves 2, 209 calories

Creamy Baked Cinnamon Rice Pudding

Eight ingredients over eighty minutes, eight servings at 251 calories. Baked rather than stirred, which gives a firmer set and a skin on top that some people want. View the full recipe — 80 minutes, serves 8, 251 calories

Mexican Rice Pudding

Nine ingredients in fifty five minutes, the quickest of the two rice puddings, eight servings at 263 calories. Cinnamon and condensed milk. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 8, 263 calories

Stovetop Banana Pudding with Vanilla Wafers

Eleven ingredients over four hours fifty, 396 calories, the heaviest in this group. The custard is cooked from scratch rather than from a packet, which is why it takes so much longer than the layered version below. View the full recipe — 290 minutes, serves 8, 396 calories

Mousse and Panna Cotta

Four set with air or gelatin rather than starch or egg. The rule for all of them is folding rather than stirring: once you have whipped air into cream or egg white, stirring knocks it straight back out and you get a dense, sad result.

White Chocolate Raspberry Mousse Cake

Eight ingredients over four and a half hours, eight servings at 289 calories, the lightest in this group. Raspberry acidity against white chocolate, which needs it. View the full recipe — 270 minutes, serves 8, 289 calories

Mango Panna Cotta

Seven ingredients over four hours twenty at 311 calories. Panna cotta is set with gelatin, which has to be bloomed in cold liquid first or it will not dissolve evenly. View the full recipe — 260 minutes, serves 4, 311 calories

Dark Chocolate Mousse with Whipped Cream

Seven ingredients over three hours twenty five at 371 calories across four servings. Dark chocolate sets firmer than milk, so this needs no gelatin at all. View the full recipe — 205 minutes, serves 4, 371 calories

Chocolate Mousse Brownie Cake

Eleven ingredients over three hours, twelve servings at 408 calories, the heaviest in this group. A baked base under a set mousse. View the full recipe — 182 minutes, serves 12, 408 calories

Baked Custards and Custard Cakes

Four set in the oven. These are egg custards, so the one number that matters is temperature: above roughly 180 degrees F the egg proteins tighten and you get a grainy, watery result instead of a smooth set. A water bath is the usual insurance.

Flan Patissier with Vanilla Custard and Puff Pastry

Ten ingredients over five hours twenty, ten servings at 255 calories, the lightest in this group. A thick set pastry custard, baked until the top is almost burnt, which is correct. View the full recipe — 320 minutes, serves 10, 255 calories

Three Layer Custard Cake

Nine ingredients over three hours ten, nine servings at 259 calories. One batter that separates into three layers in the oven, which happens because the batter is thin enough for the heavier custard to sink. View the full recipe — 190 minutes, serves 9, 259 calories

Blueberry Custard Cake with Lemon Zest

Sixteen ingredients over two hours ten, eight servings at 328 calories. View the full recipe — 130 minutes, serves 8, 328 calories

Chocolate Custard Cake with Chocolate Cookie Crust

Twelve ingredients over three hours, eight servings at 594 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 180 minutes, serves 8, 594 calories

Self Saucing Puddings

Three where the sauce makes itself. The method looks like a mistake: you pour hot water or liquid over the raw batter and do not stir it. As it bakes the batter rises through and the liquid sinks, leaving cake on top and sauce underneath. Stirring it ruins the whole thing.

No Bake Cherry Pudding Cake

Five ingredients, tied for the shortest list on this page, over four hours fifteen, twelve servings at 220 calories, the lightest in this group. View the full recipe — 255 minutes, serves 12, 220 calories

Hot Fudge Chocolate Pudding Cake

Twelve ingredients in fifty minutes at 246 calories across eight servings. The classic version, and the one where not stirring matters most. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 8, 246 calories

Chocolate Self Saucing Pudding

Twelve ingredients in forty five minutes, the quickest in this group, six servings at 357 calories, the heaviest here. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 6, 357 calories

Bread Pudding

Four where stale bread soaks up custard and bakes. Use bread that is genuinely dry, a day or two old, because fresh bread collapses into mush. Give it at least twenty to thirty minutes to soak before it goes in the oven, and press it down so every piece is wet.

Blueberry Bread Pudding

Ten ingredients in ninety five minutes, the longest in this group, twelve servings at 372 calories, the lightest here. View the full recipe — 95 minutes, serves 12, 372 calories

Brown Sugar Banana Bread Pudding

Twelve ingredients in sixty minutes, the quickest in this group, six servings at 394 calories. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 6, 394 calories

Savory Cheddar Bread Pudding

Nine ingredients in eighty minutes, eight servings at 442 calories. Savory rather than sweet, which is closer to what bread pudding originally was. View the full recipe — 80 minutes, serves 8, 442 calories

Caramel Banana Bread Pudding

Seventeen ingredients, the longest list on this page, in ninety minutes, twelve servings at 460 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 12, 460 calories

Where a Box of Pudding Mix Is Just an Ingredient

Five where instant pudding mix goes into something else. It is worth knowing what it actually is: modified cornstarch with flavouring and no eggs, which sets cold in about five minutes without any heat at all. That makes it a very reliable thickener, and it is why these recipes are fast and foolproof.

Whipped Topping and Pudding Frosting

Five ingredients, tied for the shortest list here, in fifteen minutes, twelve servings at 130 calories, the lightest recipe on this page. The mix stabilises the whipped topping so it holds for days. View the full recipe — 15 minutes, serves 12, 130 calories

Vanilla Pudding Fruit Salad

Ten ingredients in ten minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, six servings at 306 calories. The pudding is the dressing rather than the dessert. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 6, 306 calories

Banana Pudding Lush

Nine ingredients over four hours forty five, twelve servings at 423 calories. Layered rather than cooked, which is the whole appeal. View the full recipe — 285 minutes, serves 12, 423 calories

Layered Banana Pudding

Seven ingredients over five and a half hours, the longest recipe on this page, twelve servings at 444 calories. Compare it with the stovetop banana pudding above: the mix version takes longer to chill but far less attention. View the full recipe — 330 minutes, serves 12, 444 calories

Chocolate Pudding Bundt Cake

Fourteen ingredients over two and a half hours, twelve servings at 678 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page. The mix goes into the batter to keep the crumb moist for days. View the full recipe — 150 minutes, serves 12, 678 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

The two custard rules are opposites and almost everything else follows from knowing which one you are in. If the thickener is egg yolk, the mixture must never boil. Above about 180 degrees F the proteins tighten into curds and you get something grainy that no amount of whisking will rescue. Cook it over a low heat, stir constantly, and pull it the moment it coats the back of a spoon. If the thickener is cornstarch, it must boil, because starch granules do not swell and gel until they reach boiling point. A cornstarch pudding pulled early stays thin no matter how long it chills. Many recipes use both, in which case bring it to a boil for the starch and then take it off the heat quickly for the eggs, and temper the eggs first by whisking a ladle of the hot liquid into them before they go into the pan. Then cover it properly. A skin forms on cooling custard because the surface proteins dry out, so press cling film flat onto the surface rather than over the top of the bowl. For bread pudding, the bread does the work and it has to be stale. A day or two old, torn rather than cubed if you want ragged crisp edges, and soaked for a minimum of twenty to thirty minutes with something pressing it down. Fresh bread turns to paste. For self saucing puddings, the instruction that looks wrong is right: pour the hot liquid over the raw batter and do not stir. The batter is lighter and rises through the liquid as it bakes, which is what separates cake from sauce. For panna cotta and mousse, bloom gelatin in cold liquid for five minutes before warming it, and fold whipped cream or egg white in with a spatula in three additions rather than stirring, since stirring removes the air you just added. Finally, on instant pudding mix. It is modified cornstarch plus flavouring and it sets cold in about five minutes, which makes it genuinely useful as a stabiliser in frostings and a moisture keeper in cakes. Cook and serve pudding mix is a different product in a similar box and does need heating, so check which one a recipe means.

Pudding Questions, Answered

Why did my custard go grainy?

It boiled. Egg thickened custard curdles above roughly 180 degrees F, and the grain is scrambled egg. Keep the heat low, stir constantly, and pull it as soon as it coats a spoon. Straining it rescues a mildly overcooked one.

Why is my pudding still runny after chilling?

If it was thickened with cornstarch, it did not boil. Starch needs to reach boiling point to gel, and a pudding taken off early will never set however long it chills. Bring it to a full bubble for a minute while whisking.

How do I stop a skin forming on pudding?

Press cling film flat onto the surface of the pudding while it is still warm, not stretched across the top of the bowl. The skin is the surface drying out, so removing the air gap prevents it.

What is instant pudding mix made of?

Modified cornstarch with flavouring, sugar and no eggs, which is why it sets cold in about five minutes. Cook and serve mix looks almost identical on the shelf but must be heated, so read the box.

What bread should I use for bread pudding?

Stale bread, a day or two old. Brioche, challah or a plain white loaf all work. Fresh bread collapses into paste. Tear it rather than cubing it if you want crisp ragged edges on top.

Do I really not stir a self saucing pudding?

Correct, do not stir. You pour the hot liquid over the raw batter and put it straight in the oven. The batter rises through and the liquid sinks, which is what makes the sauce. Stirring gives you one muddy layer.

Why did my mousse come out dense?

It was stirred rather than folded. Whipped cream and whipped egg white hold air that stirring immediately knocks out. Fold with a spatula in three additions, cutting down through the middle and lifting over.

How long does homemade pudding keep?

Three to four days refrigerated with cling film on the surface. Bread pudding keeps three days and reheats well. Anything containing whipped cream or whipped topping is best within two days.

More Desserts to Try

Four more pudding recipes and the collections these sit inside.

Browse all of our recipe collections.