8 Cucumber Salad Recipes, Sharp to Creamy

A cucumber is ninety six percent water, which is the whole opportunity and the whole problem. It means a cucumber salad can be 58 calories a serving and still taste of something. It also means the dressing gets diluted within twenty minutes unless you deal with the water first.

These eight split cleanly: four dressed with rice vinegar, soy and sesame, three made creamy with mayonnaise or avocado, and one with pineapple and lime. Ten minutes to forty five, and nothing here needs a stove.

Rice Vinegar, Soy and Sesame

Four built on the same three ingredients in different proportions. All four are under 110 calories a serving, and the difference is the chilli.

Asian Cucumber Salad

58 calories a serving, the lightest recipe on this page, from three Persian cucumbers with two tablespoons of rice vinegar and a teaspoon each of sesame oil and chilli oil. Forty minutes, the longest in this group, and most of that is the salting step that draws the water out. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 58 calories

Korean Cucumber Salad

Ten ingredients, the most in this group, with a tablespoon of gochugaru. Korean chilli flake is coarse and fruity rather than simply hot, and it is not interchangeable with cayenne or crushed red pepper here. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 75 calories

Spicy Asian Cucumber Salad with Chili Crisp

Two tablespoons of chilli crisp with a cup of green onion, in twenty five minutes, tied for the quickest in this group. Chilli crisp brings fried garlic and shallot along with the heat, which is why it needs so little else. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 82 calories

Garlic Sesame Cucumber Salad

Eight ingredients, the fewest in this group, at 108 calories a serving, the heaviest here, from two tablespoons of sesame oil against four Persian cucumbers. Twenty five minutes, tied for the quickest in this group. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 108 calories

Creamy, With Crab or Avocado

Three where mayonnaise or avocado replaces the vinegar dressing. The calorie count roughly triples, and these eat as a light lunch rather than a side.

California Roll Cucumber Salad

Seven ingredients, the fewest on this page, in fifteen minutes, tied for the quickest in this group. Imitation crab, avocado, Japanese mayonnaise and cream cheese, which is a California roll with the rice and nori taken out. View the full recipe — 15 minutes, serves 4, 128 calories

Cucumber Salad with Crab Meat

Forty five minutes, the longest recipe on this page, with eight ounces of imitation crab in a half cup of mayonnaise. That long rest is the point: salted cucumber needs time to release water or the mayonnaise thins out in the bowl. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 280 calories

Creamy Asian Cucumber Salad

Fourteen ingredients, the longest list on this page, at 287 calories a serving, the heaviest recipe here, across two servings, the fewest portions on this page. Crispy baked tofu, edamame and avocado with a plant based dressing, which makes it the only full lunch here. View the full recipe — 15 minutes, serves 2, 287 calories

And One With Fruit

The outlier, and the fastest thing on the page.

Pineapple Cucumber Salad

Ten minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, with two cups of fresh pineapple, a jalapeno, lime and honey. No salting step, which is deliberate: the pineapple juice is meant to be part of the dressing rather than something to drain away. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 4, 70 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

The one technique that decides whether a cucumber salad is crisp or soupy is salting, and six of these eight build it into the time. Toss the sliced cucumber with about three quarters of a teaspoon of kosher salt per pound, leave it in a colander for fifteen to thirty minutes, then drain and pat dry. Osmosis pulls a surprising amount of water out, often a quarter cup from four cucumbers, and that water is what would otherwise dilute your dressing into a puddle twenty minutes after you dress it. It also seasons the cucumber from the inside rather than just coating it. Do not rinse afterwards unless you have been heavy handed, since you want that seasoning. The second thing is the cucumber itself. Persian and English cucumbers have thin skins, small seeds and less water, which is why nearly every recipe here specifies one or the other. A standard American field cucumber has a thick waxed skin and a watery seed core, and it needs peeling and seeding before it is worth using. Finally, dress these as late as you can: even a well salted cucumber salad is noticeably better in the first hour than in the third.

Cucumber Salad Questions, Answered

Do I have to salt the cucumbers first?

For anything creamy, yes. Mayonnaise and avocado dressings get visibly watery within half an hour if the cucumber has not released its water first. For a vinegar dressing it is less critical but still better, and it is why six of these recipes show fifteen to forty five minutes of total time when the actual work takes five.

Which cucumbers should I use?

Persian or English, which is what nearly every recipe here specifies. Both have thin unwaxed skins, small seeds and a firmer, less watery flesh. A standard American field cucumber will work if you peel it and scrape the seed core out, but you lose most of the crunch.

How long does cucumber salad keep?

One to two days at most, and it is noticeably best in the first few hours. Cucumber continues to release water no matter how well you salted it, so by day two a crisp salad has become a pickled one sitting in liquid. The vinegar dressed ones hold up better than the creamy ones.

Can I make it ahead?

Partly. Slice and salt the cucumbers, drain them, and keep them covered in the refrigerator for up to a day, then dress just before serving. That gets you the time consuming part done without the texture loss. Do not dress a cucumber salad more than an hour or two ahead.

What is gochugaru and can I substitute it?

Korean chilli flake, coarsely ground, with a fruity sweetness and moderate heat rather than the sharp burn of cayenne. Crushed red pepper is hotter and flatter, and cayenne is much hotter still, so a direct swap changes the dish considerably. Use about half the quantity if you only have crushed red pepper.

Why is my dressing at the bottom of the bowl?

Water from the cucumbers, almost always. A dressing that was thick enough when you mixed it gets diluted by whatever the cucumber lets go, and it then runs straight off. Salt and drain first, pat the slices dry, and dress at the last minute.

Can I freeze cucumber salad?

No. Cucumber cell walls rupture completely on freezing and thaw into a limp, watery mess, and the creamy dressings separate as well. This is one of the few dishes where the answer is a flat no rather than a qualified one.

More Salads and Cold Sides to Try

Cucumber is one bowl on the table. These are the others.

Browse all of our recipe collections.