Pasta salad divides cleanly on one question: creamy or vinaigrette. A mayonnaise based macaroni salad and an Italian dressing rotini are not variations of the same recipe, they behave differently, keep differently and belong next to different food.
These nineteen are grouped by dressing first, then by how much protein is in them, because four of these are a full dinner rather than a side. Twenty seven minutes to nearly seven hours, and 307 to 847 calories a serving, which is a wider spread than any other side dish on the site.
Deli Style: Mayonnaise, Vinegar, Mustard
The plain macaroni salad from the supermarket counter, done properly. Mayonnaise thinned with vinegar, mustard for sharpness, something crunchy diced small.
Deviled Egg Pasta Salad
Twenty seven minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, with six eggs into eight ounces of pasta plus Dijon, cider vinegar and dill pickles. That egg ratio is high enough that it reads as deviled eggs rather than as macaroni salad. View the full recipe — 27 minutes, serves 6, 345 calories
Macaroni Salad with Sour Cream and Celery
307 calories a serving, the lightest recipe on this page, from a cup of mayonnaise loosened with a quarter cup of sour cream. Nine ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, and sour cream is what keeps a mayonnaise dressing from tasting heavy. View the full recipe — 85 minutes, serves 8, 307 calories
Bell Pepper Macaroni Salad with Dijon Dressing
Fourteen ingredients, the longest list in this group, with red and green bell pepper, celery and red onion all diced into three cups of macaroni. Three tablespoons of whole milk thin the dressing, which is the trick that keeps it from stiffening up in the refrigerator. View the full recipe — 85 minutes, serves 8, 356 calories
Tangy Dijon Macaroni Salad
Nine ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, and 386 calories a serving, the heaviest here. Two tablespoons of white vinegar against a full cup of mayonnaise with a teaspoon of sugar, which is the classic sweet and sour deli balance. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 6, 386 calories
Dressed With Oil and Vinegar
No mayonnaise. These keep far better at a hot cookout, travel without worrying anyone, and taste better the next day rather than worse.
Addictive Crack Pasta Salad
328 calories a serving, the lightest in this group, from a half cup of bottled Italian dressing with feta, olives, cucumber and bell pepper. Ten ingredients and nothing to cook except the pasta. View the full recipe — 57 minutes, serves 6, 328 calories
Classic Italian Pasta Salad with Salami and Mozzarella
Nine ingredients, the fewest in this group, over an hour forty, the longest here: tri colour rotini with salami, mini mozzarella, peperoncini and basil. The peperoncini is the ingredient people leave out and the one carrying the acid. View the full recipe — 100 minutes, serves 8, 355 calories
Rotini Pasta Salad with Feta
A half cup of olive oil with red wine vinegar and Dijon, plus a can of beans and sunflower seeds for texture. Fourteen ingredients, and the beans are what make it filling enough to eat as a light lunch. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 455 calories
Marinated Vegetable Pasta Salad with Feta
Nineteen ingredients, the longest list in this group, with bell pepper, eggplant, zucchini, mushrooms and asparagus all roasted before they go in. Forty five minutes, the quickest in this group, and roasting rather than using the vegetables raw is what concentrates them. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 6, 455 calories
Bacon, Cheddar and Pickle
Creamy, but built around smoke and salt rather than vinegar. All four of these are closer to a dip you can put a fork in.
BLT Macaroni Salad
Eight ingredients, the fewest on this page, at 322 calories a serving, the lightest in this group. Six slices of bacon, cherry tomatoes and shredded lettuce, and the lettuce goes in at the last minute or it wilts into the dressing. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 6, 322 calories
Jalapeno Popper Macaroni Salad
Eight ounces of cream cheese as the base of the dressing, with cheddar, bacon and two fresh jalapenos. Cream cheese sets firmer than mayonnaise as it chills, so this one is scoopable rather than loose. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 8, 473 calories
Dill Pickle Bacon Pasta Salad
Thirteen ingredients, the longest list in this group, over an hour thirty five, the longest here, with a quarter cup of dill pickle brine in the dressing. Brine rather than vinegar brings salt and dill along with the acid, which is why it tastes of more than it looks. View the full recipe — 95 minutes, serves 8, 441 calories
Creamy Bacon Cheddar Ranch Pasta Salad
529 calories a serving, the heaviest in this group, from a full cup each of sour cream and ranch dressing into only eight ounces of pasta. Nine ingredients, and the dressing to pasta ratio is the highest here by some distance. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 6, 529 calories
Big Enough to Be Dinner
Four with a pound of protein in them. These are not side dishes, and the calorie counts reflect that.
High Protein Tuna Pasta Salad
Four servings, the fewest portions on this page, with two cans of tuna and a dressing split between Greek yogurt and mayonnaise. Thirty minutes, the quickest in this group, and the yogurt is doing most of the creaming. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 406 calories
Shrimp Pasta Salad with Dill and Celery
402 calories a serving, the lightest in this group, from a pound of cooked shrimp into a pound of macaroni with two tablespoons of fresh dill. Cooked shrimp need no cooking at all here, which is why an eight serving salad takes almost no active time. View the full recipe — 85 minutes, serves 8, 402 calories
Club Sandwich Pasta Salad
Nine ingredients, the fewest in this group, over nearly seven hours, the longest recipe on this page, almost all of it chilling. Bacon, deli ham and deli turkey with sharp cheddar, which is exactly a club sandwich with rotini standing in for the bread. View the full recipe — 405 minutes, serves 8, 594 calories
Chicken Bacon Pasta Salad with Creamy Dressing
Eighteen ingredients and 777 calories a serving, the heaviest in this group, with three cups of chicken, five ounces of bacon, two cups of cheddar and two avocados. A cup each of mayonnaise and sour cream dresses a full pound of macaroni. View the full recipe — 65 minutes, serves 8, 777 calories
Tex-Mex and Avocado
Lime, chilli and corn instead of vinegar and mustard. Two of the three have chicken in them and eat as a main.
Mexican Street Corn Pasta Salad with Cotija
424 calories a serving, the lightest in this group, with two cups of corn cooked in butter first and a cup of crumbled cotija. Cooking the corn rather than using it from the can is the step that gets it close to elote. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 6, 424 calories
Fiesta Ranch Chicken Pasta Salad with Corn Chips
Thirty minutes, the quickest in this group, with black beans, corn, pepper Jack and a cup and a half of corn chips folded in at the end. The chips go in last and they are the whole texture of it, so add them at the table if it is sitting out. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 8, 520 calories
Chicken Avocado Pasta Salad with Bacon
Twenty one ingredients, the longest list on this page, and 847 calories a serving, the heaviest recipe here, over two hours fifty. A cup and a third of mashed avocado with buttermilk makes the dressing green, and it will darken within a day no matter what you do, so this one is best made to eat. View the full recipe — 170 minutes, serves 6, 847 calories
Before You Choose Your Recipe
Three things separate a good pasta salad from a bowl of cold, dull noodles. First, cook the pasta a minute past al dente. Pasta firms up as it chills, so what tastes right hot will feel hard and chalky out of the refrigerator. Second, rinse it. This is the one place where the usual rule reverses: you want the surface starch gone so the dressing coats rather than glues, and you want the pasta cold before anything creamy touches it. Third, dress it twice. Pasta absorbs dressing as it sits, so a salad that was perfectly coated at noon will look dry by six. Hold back about a third of the dressing, then stir it in just before serving, and taste for salt again at that point because cold food needs noticeably more than warm food. For the mayonnaise based salads, the USDA limit outdoors is two hours at room temperature, or one hour above ninety degrees Fahrenheit. The five vinaigrette salads here are the ones to take to a long afternoon event.
Pasta Salad Questions, Answered
Should I rinse pasta for pasta salad?
Yes, which is the opposite of the rule for hot pasta. Rinsing washes off the surface starch that would otherwise make the noodles stick to each other, and it drops the temperature fast so mayonnaise or sour cream does not split when it goes in. Drain it well afterwards, because water left on the pasta thins the dressing.
What pasta shape works best?
Anything short with ridges or cups to hold dressing: rotini, elbows, shells, farfalle. Long shapes clump when cold and smooth shapes shed the dressing. The recipes here are split between elbow macaroni for the creamy ones and rotini for the vinaigrette ones, which is the conventional and correct division.
Why does my pasta salad taste bland?
Two reasons, and both are fixable at the table. Cold food reads as less seasoned than warm food, so it needs more salt and more acid than you would use hot. And pasta soaks up dressing while it sits, so by serving time there is less than you think. Hold back a third of the dressing and stir it in at the last minute, then taste for salt again.
How far ahead can I make pasta salad?
The vinaigrette ones actually improve overnight and several here show chilling times of an hour or more for that reason. Creamy ones are best made the same day, within about four to six hours, because the pasta keeps drinking the dressing. The avocado one should be made to eat, since the dressing darkens within a day.
How long does pasta salad keep, and how long can it sit out?
Three to five days refrigerated. Out of the refrigerator, the USDA guidance is two hours maximum, dropping to one hour if it is above ninety degrees Fahrenheit, and that applies to the mayonnaise based ones and to anything with chicken, shrimp, egg or deli meat in it. Serve the bowl nested in ice if it is going to sit on a table.
Can I freeze pasta salad?
No. Cooked pasta goes mealy, mayonnaise and sour cream separate, and fresh vegetables collapse. There is nothing in a pasta salad that survives a freezer, which is why none of these say otherwise.
Which of these are a side dish and which are dinner?
The first twelve are sides, portioned at six to eight servings alongside something else. The four in the dinner group each carry a pound of protein and run 402 to 777 calories a serving, and the chicken avocado one is 847. If you are feeding people a main course from this page, start there.
More Cookout Sides and Cold Dishes to Try
Pasta salad is one bowl on the table. These cover the others.
- Potato Salad Recipes — The other great cookout bowl, twelve ways.
- Side Dish Recipes — Everything else that goes next to the grill.
- Pasta Recipes — The same shapes, served hot.
- Summer BBQ Recipes — The mains these sit beside.
Browse all of our recipe collections.


























