13 Blackberry Recipes, and the Seed Problem

A blackberry is not one berry, it is a cluster of drupelets, and every one of them contains a hard seed. In a cobbler or a crumble that is part of the character and nobody minds. In anything meant to be smooth it is a problem, and you have two honest options: strain the puree through a fine sieve and accept losing about a third of the volume, or leave the seeds in and stop apologising. There is no third option where they quietly disappear.

The other thing to know is that blackberries are low in pectin and very high in water, which means a blackberry filling needs noticeably more thickener than an apple one. Tapioca starch holds up better than cornstarch here, since cornstarch loses its grip under the long heat and fruit acid. And they bleed: the anthocyanin pigment that makes them purple turns a pale batter grey, so fold them in at the last possible moment. Thirteen recipes here, from ten minutes to four and a half hours.

Blackberry Cobblers and Crumbles

Four, and all four handle the water the same way: a generous topping that soaks up what the fruit gives off. Use the berries frozen rather than thawed, because a thawed blackberry has already released its juice and collapses into pulp in the oven.

Baked Blackberry Crumble with Butter Topping

Eleven ingredients, the most in this group, in forty five minutes, the quickest here, eight servings at 310 calories, also the lightest. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 8, 310 calories

Self Rising Blackberry Cobbler

Six ingredients, the shortest list on this page, in sixty minutes, eight servings at 331 calories. Self rising flour does the leavening, which is why the list is this short. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 8, 331 calories

Baking Mix Blackberry Cobbler

Eight ingredients in sixty five minutes, six servings at 372 calories. View the full recipe — 65 minutes, serves 6, 372 calories

Southern Butter Batter Blackberry Cobbler

Seven ingredients in eighty minutes, the longest in this group, eight servings at 396 calories, the heaviest here. A batter cobbler, so the layers go in and nothing gets stirred. View the full recipe — 80 minutes, serves 8, 396 calories

Bars, Scones and Dumplings

Four where the fruit sits inside a dough rather than under a topping. For the scones and the bars, keep the butter cold and the handling brief, and add the berries at the very end with the fewest possible folds, since each extra turn crushes more of them and purples the dough.

Buttermilk Blackberry Scones

Seven ingredients, the fewest in this group, in thirty five minutes, tied for the quickest here, eight servings at 255 calories, also the lightest. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 8, 255 calories

Blackberry Dumplings

Eleven ingredients, the most in this group, in thirty five minutes, tied for the quickest here, six servings at 274 calories. Dumplings steam under a lid, so the lid stays on for the full time. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 6, 274 calories

Shortbread Blackberry Pie Bars

Ten ingredients in seventy minutes, the longest in this group, twelve servings at 283 calories, tied for the most portions on this page. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 12, 283 calories

Brown Sugar Blackberry Crumb Bars

Nine ingredients in fifty minutes, twelve servings at 371 calories, the heaviest in this group and tied for the most portions on this page. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 12, 371 calories

Cheesecake, Dump Cake and Pie

Three of the longest here, and two of them are mostly chilling. A blackberry swirl through a cheesecake is the one place where straining the puree is worth the loss, because seeds in a smooth filling are obvious in a way they are not under a crumble.

Mini Blackberry Cheesecakes

Fourteen ingredients, the longest list on this page, in three hours seven, twelve servings at 318 calories, the lightest in this group and tied for the most portions. View the full recipe — 187 minutes, serves 12, 318 calories

Spiced Blackberry Dump Cake

Seven ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in sixty minutes, the quickest here, eight servings at 563 calories. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 8, 563 calories

Blackberry Lemonade Pie

Seven ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, in four and a half hours, the longest recipe on this page, eight servings at 680 calories, also the heaviest. View the full recipe — 270 minutes, serves 8, 680 calories

Savory and a Drink

Two that take blackberries away from dessert. The brie pairing is the better idea than it sounds: blackberries are tart and tannic enough to cut a soft rich cheese in the way a chutney would.

Honeyed Brie Blackberry Puff Pastry Swirls

Seven ingredients in fifty minutes, the longer of the two, twelve pieces at 91 calories each, the lightest recipe on this page and tied for the most portions. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 12, 91 calories

Creamy Blackberry Coconut Mojito

Eleven ingredients in ten minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, one serving at 260 calories. Muddle the berries gently; crushed too hard they release seeds into the glass. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 1, 260 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Three practical points about the fruit itself. Buying first: frozen blackberries are frequently better than the fresh ones in the same shop, and the reason is picking. Berries destined for freezing are harvested ripe and frozen within hours, while berries destined for the fresh shelf are picked firm and underripe so they survive transport. Fresh blackberries are worth it in season from a local grower, and frozen are the better choice the rest of the year. Use them frozen, never thawed: a thawed blackberry has already given up its juice and will disintegrate. Expect slightly more liquid overall and add a little more thickener to compensate. Second, thickening, which is where blackberry desserts most often fail. Blackberries hold a great deal of water and very little pectin, so they will not set themselves the way apples largely do. Reckon on a tablespoon or two of starch per four cups of fruit, and prefer tapioca starch over cornstarch for anything baked long or acidic, since cornstarch loses thickening power under sustained heat and in the presence of fruit acid. Flour works but tastes faintly raw and clouds the juice. Then bake until the filling is visibly bubbling at the edges, because that bubbling is the starch reaching the temperature at which it actually sets, and let it rest twenty minutes before cutting. Third, sweetness, which varies more in blackberries than in almost any other berry. The same variety picked a week apart can go from bracingly tart to mild, and a recipe written for one will be wrong for the other. Taste two or three before you measure the sugar, and adjust. A squeeze of lemon helps either way: with tart fruit it reads as brightness rather than more sourness, and with mild fruit it supplies the acidity the berries lack. Two notes on handling. Blackberries bruise if you wash them early, so rinse them just before use and dry them on a towel, and never soak them. And the pigment stains: it will purple a pale batter, a wooden spoon and your hands, so fold berries in last, with as few turns as possible, and use a light hand if you want the dough to stay the colour it started.

Blackberry Questions, Answered

Can I get rid of blackberry seeds?

Only by straining. Push the puree through a fine sieve and you lose roughly a third of the volume along with the seeds. For a smooth filling that is worth it; under a crumble or in a cobbler the seeds are part of the character.

Are frozen blackberries as good as fresh?

Often better outside local season. Berries for freezing are picked ripe and frozen within hours, while fresh shelf berries are picked firm and underripe to survive transport. Use frozen ones frozen, not thawed.

How much thickener does a blackberry filling need?

A tablespoon or two of starch per four cups of fruit, which is more than apples need. Blackberries carry a lot of water and almost no pectin, so nothing sets on its own. Tapioca holds better than cornstarch under long heat and acid.

Why is my blackberry cobbler runny?

Not enough thickener, or it came out before the filling was bubbling, or it was cut too hot. The bubbling is the signal that the starch has reached setting temperature, and the filling firms further as it cools, so give it twenty minutes.

Why did my batter turn grey?

The anthocyanin pigment in the berries bled into it. That happens as soon as a berry is crushed, so fold them in at the very last moment with as few turns as possible, and tossing them in a spoonful of flour first helps.

Should I wash blackberries ahead of time?

No. They bruise easily and absorb water, which dilutes the flavour and softens them. Rinse them briefly just before use and pat them dry on a towel, and never leave them soaking.

How do I know how much sugar to add?

Taste two or three berries first. Blackberry sweetness varies enormously with ripeness, and the same variety a week apart can be bracingly tart or quite mild. A squeeze of lemon works either way, as brightness in tart fruit and as the missing acidity in mild fruit.

How long do fresh blackberries keep?

Two or three days refrigerated, and less if they were already soft when you bought them. Spread them in a single layer rather than piled in the punnet, since the weight crushes the ones underneath and one mouldy berry spreads fast.

More to Try

Browse all of our recipe collections.