Sugar cookie dough splits into two kinds and they are not interchangeable. A cut out dough is stiff, low in leavening and chilled, so it holds a shape in the oven. A drop dough has more butter and more rise and spreads into a soft round.
These nine are grouped by that choice first, then by what goes on top. Twenty seven minutes to three hours, and 124 to 516 calories a cookie, which is almost entirely a question of how much frosting is involved.
Cut Out Doughs That Hold Their Shape
Stiffer dough, less leavening, and a chill before rolling. These three are the ones for cookie cutters and royal icing.
Classic Rolled Sugar Cookies
Seven ingredients, the fewest on this page, and 124 calories a cookie, the lightest recipe here. A quarter teaspoon of almond extract alongside the vanilla is the traditional touch that makes a plain rolled cookie taste like a bakery one. View the full recipe — 145 minutes, serves 20, 124 calories
Vanilla Cut Out Sugar Cookies with Icing
Superfine sugar rather than granulated, which dissolves more completely and gives a smoother, less grainy cookie. An hour start to finish, the quickest in this group, with a simple powdered sugar and milk icing. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 24, 201 calories
Soft Cut Out Sugar Cookies with Icing
Thirteen ingredients, the longest list in this group, over three hours, the longest recipe on this page. Two tablespoons of corn syrup go into the icing, which is what makes it dry glossy and firm enough to stack rather than dull and chalky. View the full recipe — 180 minutes, serves 24, 207 calories
Soft Drop Cookies
More butter, more leavening, no rolling pin. These spread in the oven and stay soft in the middle, and three of the four are the quickest things on this page.
Grandmas Irish Sugar Cookies
Twenty seven minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, and the only one here that splits the fat between a half cup of butter and a half cup of oil. Oil stays liquid at room temperature, which is why these stay soft for days rather than firming up overnight. View the full recipe — 27 minutes, serves 24, 141 calories
Glazed Lemon Sugar Cookies
Three tablespoons of lemon juice and a tablespoon of zest in the dough, then a powdered sugar glaze. At 134 calories a cookie it is the lightest in this group, and the zest matters more than the juice because the oils in the peel carry the flavour. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 24, 134 calories
Soft Vanilla Sugar Cookies
Nine ingredients, the fewest in this group, with a full tablespoon of vanilla extract against a cup of butter. Fifty five minutes, the longest in this group, and it finishes with icing and sprinkles. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 24, 162 calories
Chocolate Sugar Cookies with Chocolate Chunks
A half cup of cocoa powder and a cup of milk chocolate chunks, at 223 calories a cookie, the heaviest in this group. Vegetable shortening rather than butter, which holds its shape better in the oven, and turbinado sugar on top for crunch. View the full recipe — 32 minutes, serves 24, 223 calories
Frosted
Two where the frosting is most of the calorie count. Both use a real American buttercream rather than a thin icing.
Buttercream Frosted Sugar Cookies
Thirteen ingredients, tied for the longest list on this page, with a full cup of butter in the cookie and another full cup in the frosting plus four cups of confectioners sugar. Thirty eight minutes, the quickest in this group. View the full recipe — 38 minutes, serves 24, 316 calories
Soft Pink Frosted Sugar Cookies
516 calories a cookie, the heaviest recipe on this page, across twelve servings, the fewest portions here. Three cups of powdered sugar into a half cup of butter for twelve cookies is a lot of frosting per cookie, which is exactly what the bakery version is. View the full recipe — 117 minutes, serves 12, 516 calories
Before You Choose Your Recipe
The difference between a cut out cookie that keeps its shape and one that comes out as a blob is mostly butter temperature, not the recipe. Dough made with softened butter and then rolled warm will spread, because the butter melts before the structure sets. Chill the dough until firm, roll it cold, and if the cut shapes have gone soft from handling, put the whole tray in the freezer for ten minutes before it goes in the oven. That single step fixes most shape problems. The second thing is flour measurement, which matters more in sugar cookies than almost anywhere else because there is so little else in the dough. A cup of flour can vary by a quarter depending on whether you scooped or spooned it, and too much flour is the usual reason a rolled cookie comes out dry and pale. Spoon the flour into the cup and level it off. Finally, these cookies are done well before they look done: pull them when the edges are just set and the centres still look underbaked, because they continue cooking on the hot sheet.
Sugar Cookie Questions, Answered
What makes a cut out dough different from a drop dough?
Stiffness and leavening. A cut out dough uses less butter relative to flour and very little baking powder or soda, so it does not spread and holds a cutter shape. A drop dough has more fat and more rise, which is what gives you a soft, puffy round. Using a drop recipe with cookie cutters is the most common reason shapes come out unrecognisable.
Why did my cut out cookies spread and lose their shape?
The butter was too warm when they went into the oven. Chill the dough before rolling, work quickly, and freeze the cut shapes for ten minutes on the tray before baking. A hot baking sheet reused straight from the last batch will do the same thing, so let it cool or use a second one.
Do I have to chill sugar cookie dough?
For the three cut out recipes here, yes, and that is why their total times are longer. For the drop cookies it is optional and mainly affects spread; chilled dough gives a slightly thicker cookie. The frosted versions are more forgiving because the frosting hides the edges anyway.
What is the difference between icing and buttercream on a sugar cookie?
Icing is powdered sugar with liquid, dries hard and lets you stack and transport the cookies. Buttercream is powdered sugar beaten into butter, stays soft and tastes richer, but it never fully sets, which is why the two buttercream cookies here are the highest calorie recipes on the page. Corn syrup in an icing, as in one recipe here, makes it dry glossy instead of matte.
Why are my sugar cookies dry?
Almost always too much flour, and almost always from scooping the cup directly into the bag, which compacts it. Spoon the flour in and level it. Overbaking is the second cause: these should come out when the centres still look slightly underdone, because they firm up on the sheet.
Can I freeze sugar cookie dough?
Yes, and it is the best reason to make a double batch. Cut out dough freezes well as a flat disc wrapped tight, or as cut shapes on a tray, for about three months. Drop dough freezes as portioned balls and bakes straight from frozen with a couple of extra minutes.
How long do sugar cookies keep?
Unfrosted, about a week in an airtight container at room temperature. Iced cookies keep about the same once the icing has set hard. Buttercream frosted cookies are best inside three to four days and should be refrigerated if the kitchen is warm, since the frosting softens.
More Cookies and Baking to Try
If a sugar cookie is not the shape of the afternoon, these are nearby.
- Cookie Recipes — Every cookie on the site, chewy to crisp.
- Chocolate Chip Recipes — The other great drop cookie, and everything else chip.
- Dessert Bar Recipes — Easier than cookies, cut from one pan.
- Christmas Dinner Recipes — What the cut out cookies usually come after.
Browse all of our recipe collections.
















