12 Potato Salad Recipes, Classic to Loaded

Almost every potato salad argument is really about the dressing, and specifically about what cuts the mayonnaise. Pickle juice, cider vinegar, buttermilk, three kinds of mustard, or nothing at all are all defensible, and they give noticeably different bowls.

These twelve are grouped that way. Six classics first, sorted by what sharpens them, then three built like a loaded baked potato with sour cream and cheddar, then three with no mayonnaise in them whatsoever. Thirty five minutes to four and a half hours, and most of that is chilling.

The Classic: Mayonnaise, Egg, Something Sharp

Boiled potatoes, hard cooked eggs, mayonnaise, and one acidic thing to keep it from tasting flat. That acid is the only real variable between these six.

Buttermilk Dressing Potato Salad

Thirty five minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, with a quarter cup of buttermilk thinning a cup of mayonnaise. Buttermilk brings acidity and a looser dressing at once, which is why this is the one that does not need a long chill to come together. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 8, 363 calories

Easy Southern Potato Salad Recipe

Eleven ingredients with a half cup of dill pickle chips and two tablespoons of the pickle juice, on russets. At 368 calories a serving it is the heaviest in this group, and the pickle juice is what makes it read as Southern rather than generic. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 8, 368 calories

Old Fashioned Potato Salad

Four and a half hours, the longest recipe on this page, nearly all of it chilling. Ten ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group: mayonnaise, white vinegar, yellow mustard, celery, onion, egg. Nothing else, which is the point. View the full recipe — 275 minutes, serves 8, 320 calories

Yukon Gold Potato Salad with Dill and Paprika

A tablespoon each of fresh dill and fresh parsley with cider vinegar, on Yukon Golds. Fresh dill behaves nothing like dried here; it is the difference between a salad that tastes of herbs and one that tastes of mayonnaise. View the full recipe — 165 minutes, serves 8, 317 calories

Deviled Egg Potato Salad

Twelve eggs in total and three different mustards, across ten servings, the most portions on this page. That egg to potato ratio is what makes it taste like deviled eggs rather than like potato salad with eggs in it. View the full recipe — 165 minutes, serves 10, 351 calories

Creamy Potato Salad with Sour Cream and Dill

Sixteen ingredients, the longest list on this page, splitting the dressing between a half cup each of mayonnaise and sour cream, with cider vinegar and pickle juice both. At 276 calories a serving it is the lightest in this group, because the sour cream replaces half the mayonnaise. View the full recipe — 215 minutes, serves 8, 276 calories

Loaded, Like a Baked Potato

Sour cream, cheddar and bacon instead of egg and mustard. These eat like a baked potato that has been cut up and dressed, and they are much richer than the classics.

Baked Russet Potato Salad with Bacon and Sour Cream

Eight ingredients, the fewest in this group, and 318 calories a serving, the lightest here. The potatoes are baked rather than boiled, which keeps them drier and stops the dressing going watery in the bowl. View the full recipe — 165 minutes, serves 8, 318 calories

Cheesy Baked Potato Salad with Bacon

Forty five minutes, the quickest in this group, with ten slices of bacon, six green onions and smoked paprika. A full cup each of sour cream and mayonnaise is doing the work here. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 8, 489 calories

Loaded Potato Salad with Bacon and Cheddar

A full pound of bacon and two cups of sharp cheddar into three pounds of red potatoes, at 771 calories a serving, the heaviest recipe on this page by a wide margin. Worth knowing before you serve it alongside anything else rich. View the full recipe — 160 minutes, serves 8, 771 calories

No Mayonnaise at All

Three that get their body from somewhere else: Greek yogurt, pesto, or a plain oil and vinegar dressing. The calorie spread between them is the widest of any group here.

Ranch Potato Salad with Greek Yogurt and Eggs

163 calories a serving, the lightest recipe on this page, from a cup and a half of plain Greek yogurt with an ounce of ranch seasoning. Yogurt carries roughly a tenth of the fat of mayonnaise, which is the entire reason for the number. View the full recipe — 90 minutes, serves 8, 163 calories

Pesto Potato Salad with Asiago and Lemon

Basil pesto and a cup of grated Asiago on baby yellow potatoes, with lemon juice for lift. Eight ingredients, tied for the fewest in this group, and it is the one here that works served warm as well as cold. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 386 calories

Red Potato Salad with Bacon and Corn

Thirteen ingredients, the longest list in this group, dressed with cider vinegar and a half cup of olive oil rather than anything creamy. At 527 calories a serving it is the heaviest here, which is a useful reminder that skipping mayonnaise is not the same as making it light. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 527 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Two steps decide whether potato salad is good, and both happen before the dressing. The first is salting the water properly and dressing the potatoes while they are still warm. Warm potatoes absorb vinegar or pickle juice; cold ones just get coated by it, which is why a salad that tastes flat usually got dressed too late. Toss the hot drained potatoes with the acid first, let them sit five minutes, then add the mayonnaise once they have cooled enough not to break it. The second is the potato itself. Waxy varieties, meaning red potatoes and Yukon Golds, hold their shape and give distinct cubes. Russets are starchy, break down at the edges and give a softer, creamier salad that some people prefer and others call mush; both are correct and the recipes here use both deliberately. Whatever you use, cut the pieces after boiling rather than before if you want them intact, and never boil them from already-boiling water, which cooks the outside to mush before the centre is done.

Potato Salad Questions, Answered

Which potatoes are best for potato salad?

It depends on the texture you want. Red potatoes and Yukon Golds are waxy, hold their shape and give you clean cubes in the bowl. Russets are starchy and break down at the edges, which makes a creamier, softer salad and soaks up more dressing. Neither is wrong, and the recipes here are split between them on purpose.

Should I dress the potatoes warm or cold?

Dress them warm with the acid, cold with the mayonnaise. Warm potatoes actually absorb vinegar, pickle juice or lemon, which is how the seasoning gets inside rather than sitting on the surface. Mayonnaise added to hot potatoes can separate and go oily, so let them cool to barely warm first.

How long does potato salad keep?

Three to four days refrigerated in a covered container. The bigger issue is time out of the refrigerator: the USDA guidance is no more than two hours at room temperature, and one hour if it is above ninety degrees Fahrenheit, which matters at a summer cookout. Serve it over a bowl of ice if it is going to sit out.

Can I make potato salad the day before?

Yes, and most of these are better for it. The flavours need a few hours to settle, which is why several here show two to four hours of total time that is almost entirely chilling. If it tastes dull straight out of the refrigerator the next day, a splash of vinegar and a little salt wakes it back up.

Why is my potato salad watery?

Usually under-drained potatoes, or boiled potatoes that kept steaming in the colander and then went into the bowl wet. Let them sit in the colander until the surface looks dry and matte. The baked versions here avoid the problem entirely because no water goes near the potato.

Can I freeze potato salad?

No, and it is one of the few dishes where that is a flat answer. Mayonnaise and sour cream separate on thawing and boiled potatoes turn grainy, so you get an oily bowl of mealy potato. Make a smaller batch instead.

Is potato salad without mayonnaise lighter?

Not necessarily. The Greek yogurt one here is 163 calories a serving, but the vinaigrette version with bacon and olive oil is 527, which is higher than four of the six mayonnaise classics. What matters is the total fat in the dressing, not whether that fat came from a jar of mayonnaise.

More Sides and Potato Dishes to Try

Potato salad is one slot on the cookout table. These cover the rest of it.

Browse all of our recipe collections.