Two completely different dishes share this name in the United States. American goulash is a skillet of ground beef, canned tomato and elbow macaroni, usually on the table in forty minutes. Hungarian goulash is a slow paprika beef stew with no pasta in it at all.
Six of the seven here are the American dish, separated by what thickens the sauce and how much beef goes in. The last one is the Hungarian original, and it is worth knowing which one somebody means before you start cooking.
American Goulash: Ground Beef, Macaroni, Canned Tomato
A pound of beef, two cups of elbow macaroni, and the pasta cooked in the sauce rather than drained separately. What changes between these four is the tomato product and how much cheese goes in.
One Pot American Goulash with Beef and Macaroni
390 calories a serving, the lightest recipe on this page, from ninety ten beef with Worcestershire and a bay leaf. Fifty minutes, the longest in this group, and at twenty one grams of protein it is the leanest here, which is the trade for the lower calorie count. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 6, 390 calories
American Goulash with Ground Beef and Macaroni
Thirteen ingredients, the longest list in this group, with two teaspoons of paprika, dried oregano and a quarter cup of Parmesan stirred in at the end. The paprika is the one nod to the Hungarian dish in an otherwise entirely American recipe. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 6, 416 calories
Macaroni Beef Goulash
Twenty nine ounces of stewed tomatoes rather than diced, plus chili powder and a half teaspoon of hot sauce. Stewed tomatoes come already cooked with onion and celery, which is why this one tastes simmered after forty minutes. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 6, 426 calories
Cheesy American Goulash
A cup of shredded cheese stirred through at the end, which takes it to 617 calories a serving, the heaviest recipe on this page, and forty three grams of protein, the most here. Four servings rather than six from the same pound of beef. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 617 calories
Two Pounds of Beef and a Bigger Pot
Both of these double the meat. One stays on the stovetop and one goes into a Dutch oven for eight servings.
Dutch Oven Beef Goulash with Macaroni
Eight servings, the most portions on this page, from two pounds of lean beef with three tablespoons of soy sauce and three bay leaves. Soy sauce is not traditional and is doing a real job here, adding the savoury depth a longer simmer would have built. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 8, 458 calories
Stovetop Elbow Macaroni Goulash
Two pounds of beef across six servings, which is the highest meat to pasta ratio in this group and gives forty grams of protein a serving. Fifty minutes, the longest in this group, and ten ingredients, the fewest here. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 6, 525 calories
And the Hungarian Dish It Is Named After
Gulyas is a different dish entirely: cubed beef, a great deal of sweet paprika, and time. No macaroni, no canned tomato sauce.
Paprika Beef Goulash with Caraway and Sour Cream
Two pounds of beef chuck with three tablespoons of sweet paprika, caraway seeds and a cup of sour cream, over two and a half hours, the longest recipe on this page. Paprika scorches and turns bitter in hot fat, so it goes in off the heat; that single step is what separates a good gulyas from a harsh one. View the full recipe — 155 minutes, serves 6, 498 calories
Before You Choose Your Recipe
Two things matter in the American version and one matters enormously in the Hungarian one. For the skillet recipes, the macaroni cooks in the sauce rather than in a separate pot, which means the starch stays in and thickens everything. It also means the pasta keeps absorbing after the heat goes off, so stop it a minute short of tender and expect leftovers to be thick rather than saucy. Add a splash of broth when you reheat. For the Hungarian stew, the paprika is the whole dish and it burns easily. Three tablespoons of sweet paprika hitting hot oil will turn bitter in under a minute and there is no recovering it, so pull the pot off the heat, stir the paprika into the onions, then return it to the stove and add the liquid. Buy paprika that is actually red rather than brown, since it loses its colour and most of its flavour within about a year of opening.
Goulash Questions, Answered
What is the difference between American and Hungarian goulash?
They are not variations of each other. American goulash is a ground beef and elbow macaroni skillet in a tomato sauce, closer to chili mac than to a stew, and it takes about forty minutes. Hungarian gulyas is cubed beef slow cooked with a large amount of sweet paprika and no pasta at all, and it takes two to three hours. The American dish picked up the name in the early twentieth century and kept almost nothing else.
Should I cook the macaroni in the sauce or separately?
In the sauce, for all six American versions here. The pasta releases starch that thickens the tomato base, and it absorbs the seasoning instead of sitting in it. The cost is that you lose control of the texture, so check it early, and it is the reason leftovers thicken overnight.
Why did my goulash get thick and pasty the next day?
Because elbow macaroni keeps drinking liquid for as long as there is any, and in a one pot dish there is no separate pot of plain pasta to even it out. It is normal rather than a mistake. Loosen it with a quarter cup of broth or water per portion when reheating and it comes back.
What cut of beef do I use for Hungarian goulash?
Chuck, which is what the recipe here calls for. It carries enough collagen to go tender over two hours and enough fat to stay moist. A lean cut like round will be dry and stringy no matter how long you cook it, because there is no connective tissue to break down into gelatin.
Why does my paprika taste bitter?
It was almost certainly scorched. Paprika is mostly sugar and pigment, both of which burn fast in hot oil, and once it is bitter the whole pot is. Take the pan off the heat before the paprika goes in, stir it through the onions, then add liquid to drop the temperature before returning it to the stove.
Can I freeze goulash?
The Hungarian stew freezes very well for about three months, and improves on reheating. The American versions freeze poorly because the macaroni comes back mealy, so if you want to freeze one, make the meat sauce and freeze that, then boil fresh pasta into it when you reheat.
How long does it keep in the refrigerator?
Three to four days, which is the USDA guidance for cooked ground beef and for cooked beef cubes. The pasta versions are best inside two days simply because the texture drifts, while the stew is arguably better on day two.
More Beef and Pasta Dinners to Try
If goulash is the shape of dinner you want, these are next door to it.
- Ground Beef Recipes — The cheapest pound of protein, in every direction.
- Stew Recipes — More long simmers, including beef chuck.
- Mac and Cheese Recipes — The other great elbow macaroni dish.
- One Pot Pasta Recipes — More dinners where the pasta never leaves the pan.
Browse all of our recipe collections.














