Nearly every cherry dessert in American baking was written for sour cherries, and sour cherries are almost never sold fresh. Montmorency, the standard tart variety, is too soft and too perishable to ship, so it reaches you canned, frozen or as pie filling. The cherries you buy fresh in June are sweet cherries, Bing or Rainier, bred for eating out of hand.
That matters because the acid is doing the work. A cherry pie tastes of cherry because tart cherries are sharp enough to read as fruit against a cup of sugar. Make the same pie with sweet cherries and it comes out flat and cloying, which is the usual disappointment of a first homemade cherry pie. The fix is simple: if you are baking with fresh sweet cherries, add two or three tablespoons of lemon juice and cut the sugar. Eight recipes here, from ten minutes to four hours forty.
Cherry Drinks
Two, and frozen cherries are the better choice in both. They chill a drink without diluting it the way ice does, and there is no pitting to do.
Frozen Cherry Limeade Margarita with Tart Cherry Juice
Eight ingredients, the more of the two, in ten minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, at 76 calories, also the lightest. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 4, 76 calories
Sparkling Cherry Lemonade
Four ingredients, the shortest list on this page, in seventy minutes at 166 calories. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 4, 166 calories
Cookies and Candy
Two using cherries in processed form. Worth knowing what a maraschino cherry is, since one of these depends on it: it is a light coloured sweet cherry that has been brined in salt and sulfur dioxide until it loses its colour and flavour entirely, then soaked in sugar syrup and dyed red. It is a confection that began as a cherry rather than a cherry as such, and nothing else tastes like it.
Maraschino Cherry Chocolate Chip Cookies
Ten ingredients, the more of the two, in twenty seven minutes, the quicker here, twenty four cookies at 225 calories each, the lighter and the most portions on this page. Pat the cherries dry or their syrup will loosen the dough. View the full recipe — 27 minutes, serves 24, 225 calories
White Chocolate Rocky Road with Pistachios and Cherries
Six ingredients in three and a half hours, sixteen servings at 246 calories. View the full recipe — 210 minutes, serves 16, 246 calories
Cake, Pie and Cheesecake
Four, and all four need more thickener than feels reasonable. Cherries are low in pectin and release a great deal of juice, so a filling without starch runs out of the pie the moment you cut it. Tapioca starch holds better than cornstarch under long heat and fruit acid.
Black Forest Cake Roll with Cherries and Whipped Cream
Fourteen ingredients, the most on this page, in seventy five minutes, tied for the quickest in this group, eight servings at 315 calories, the lightest here. Black Forest cake is built on kirsch and sour cherries, which is the pairing this whole page is about. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 8, 315 calories
Fresh Cherry Pie with a Golden Crust
Eight ingredients in eighty minutes, eight servings at 335 calories. Made with fresh cherries, so add lemon juice if yours are the sweet kind. View the full recipe — 80 minutes, serves 8, 335 calories
Cherry Cheesecake Dessert Salad
Seven ingredients, the fewest in this group, in seventy five minutes, tied for the quickest here, eight servings at 394 calories. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 8, 394 calories
Cherry Pecan Cheesecake Lush
Twelve ingredients in four hours forty, the longest recipe on this page, twelve servings at 446 calories, the heaviest here. View the full recipe — 280 minutes, serves 12, 446 calories
Before You Choose Your Recipe
Which cherry to use, in plain terms. Sweet cherries, meaning Bing, Rainier, Lambert and the rest, are firm, dark or blush coloured, high in sugar and low in acid, and they are what you buy fresh. They are at their best eaten raw, and they are a poor choice for baking unless you add acid. Sour or tart cherries, chiefly Montmorency, are smaller, softer, brighter red and far more acidic, and they are what cherry pie, cherry filling, Black Forest cake and clafoutis were built on. You will find them canned in water, frozen, or in a can of prepared pie filling, and all three are legitimate. Canned in water is the most useful form: drain it, keep the liquid, and use the liquid as part of the thickening slurry. If all you have is sweet cherries, add two to three tablespoons of lemon juice per four cups of fruit and reduce the sugar by a quarter, which gets you most of the way there. Thickening is the second decision and cherries need it. They are low in pectin and very juicy, so reckon on a tablespoon or two of starch per four cups, and tapioca over cornstarch for anything baked long or acidic, since cornstarch loses its grip under sustained heat and fruit acid. Bake until the filling bubbles at the edges, because that bubbling is the starch setting, then rest it twenty minutes before cutting. A cherry pie cut hot will always run. Pitting, which is the reason most people buy them frozen. A proper cherry pitter is cheap and worth it if you do this more than once a year; a paper clip bent into a hook or a sturdy chopstick pushed through from the stem end both work and both are slow. Four cups of cherries is a serious amount of hand pitting. Frozen pitted sour cherries cost less than fresh sweet ones, require none of this, and are the better ingredient for baking anyway. Use them frozen, not thawed, and add a little extra thickener for the water they bring. Two last notes. Cherry juice stains permanently, so wear an apron and keep it off wooden boards. And almond is the pairing to reach for: the compound that gives almond extract its character is closely related to one in the cherry pit, which is why almond and cherry taste as though they were designed together, and why a quarter teaspoon of almond extract makes a cherry pie taste more like cherry rather than less.
Cherry Questions, Answered
What is the difference between sweet and sour cherries?
Sweet cherries, such as Bing and Rainier, are firm and high in sugar and are what you buy fresh to eat. Sour cherries, chiefly Montmorency, are softer and far more acidic and are what cherry pie and Black Forest cake were written for. They are sold canned or frozen, almost never fresh.
Can I use fresh sweet cherries for cherry pie?
Yes, but add acid. Sweet cherries lack the sharpness that makes a cherry pie taste of cherry, so it comes out flat and cloying. Add two or three tablespoons of lemon juice per four cups and cut the sugar by about a quarter.
Are canned or frozen cherries acceptable for baking?
They are usually better. Canned and frozen cherries are the tart variety that the recipes assume, and frozen pitted cherries save a great deal of hand work. Use frozen ones frozen rather than thawed, with a little extra thickener.
How much thickener does a cherry filling need?
A tablespoon or two of starch per four cups of fruit. Cherries are low in pectin and very juicy, so nothing sets on its own. Tapioca holds better than cornstarch under long heat and fruit acid, and flour tastes faintly raw.
Why does my cherry pie run when I cut it?
It was cut too hot, or the filling never reached a bubble, or there was not enough starch. The bubbling at the edges is the signal that the starch has set, and the filling firms further as it cools, so give it twenty minutes.
What is a maraschino cherry?
A light coloured sweet cherry brined in salt and sulfur dioxide until it loses its colour and flavour, then soaked in sugar syrup and dyed red. It is a confection rather than a cherry in any useful sense, and nothing else substitutes for it.
What is the easiest way to pit cherries?
A cherry pitter if you do this regularly. Otherwise a paper clip bent into a hook, or a chopstick pushed through from the stem end. Both work and both are slow, which is why frozen pitted cherries are the sensible choice for baking.
Why does almond go so well with cherry?
Because the aromatic compound behind almond extract is closely related to one found in cherry pits. A quarter teaspoon of almond extract in a cherry filling makes it taste more intensely of cherry rather than of almond.
More to Try
- Pie Recipes — and the thickener question
- Cobbler and Crisp Recipes — what separates them
- Cheesecake Recipes — two cherry versions
- Chocolate Recipes — Black Forest and rocky road
- Dessert Recipes — everything sweet
- Cocktail Recipes — where the margarita belongs
Browse all of our recipe collections.















