Whether cornbread should contain sugar is the one food argument in America where both sides are right about the facts and simply want different things. Southern cornbread is all cornmeal, buttermilk, egg and fat, with no sugar and often no wheat flour at all, baked in a cast iron skillet that went into the oven to heat before the batter was mixed. It is savory, crumbly and meant to be torn apart next to beans or greens. Northern cornbread adds sugar and a good deal of wheat flour, which makes something closer to a cake: finer, sweeter, sliceable. Both appear below and they are labeled honestly rather than one being treated as the real thing.
The useful technical fact behind all of them is that cornmeal has no gluten. Cornbread is held together by egg and by starch setting, not by a gluten network, which has two consequences worth knowing: you cannot overmix cornbread into toughness the way you can a muffin, and cornbread goes crumbly and stale faster than any wheat bread because there is no gluten holding its water. Ten recipes here, from twenty five minutes to seventy.
Southern Style, Skillet and Fried
Four in the savory tradition, and the hot pan is not optional in any of them. Put the skillet in the oven with the fat in it while you mix, and pour the batter into fat that is shimmering. The outside sets instantly on contact, which is the entire source of that crisp shell, and batter poured into a cold pan simply cannot produce it.
Southern Fried Cornbread Hoecakes
Thirteen ingredients, the most in this group, in forty minutes, sixteen pieces at 120 calories each, the most portions on this page and the lightest recipe here. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 16, 120 calories
Skillet Creamed Corn Cornbread
Ten ingredients in sixty minutes, the longest in this group, eight servings at 308 calories. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 8, 308 calories
Skillet Fried Cornbread Cakes
Five ingredients, the shortest list on this page, in twenty five minutes, the quickest recipe here, at 330 calories. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 330 calories
Crispy Fried Cornbread
Nine ingredients in twenty eight minutes at 441 calories, tied for the heaviest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 28 minutes, serves 4, 441 calories
Sweet, Jalapeno and Cheese
Four with sugar, chiles or cheese, which all do the same structural favour: they add moisture and fat to a batter that has no gluten to hold either. These are the ones that keep better than a day.
Buttermilk Mexican Cornbread
Thirteen ingredients in fifty minutes, the longest in this group, eight servings at 210 calories, the lightest here. Buttermilk is worth using rather than substituting; its acid reacts with the baking soda and the crumb is noticeably more tender. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 8, 210 calories
Sweet Jalapeno Cornbread
Ten ingredients, the fewest in this group, in thirty five minutes, twelve servings at 219 calories. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 12, 219 calories
Jalapeno Cornbread Muffins with Cream Cheese Filling
Fourteen ingredients, tied for the most on this page, in thirty three minutes, the quickest in this group, twelve muffins at 228 calories. View the full recipe — 33 minutes, serves 12, 228 calories
Roasted Chile Cheese Cornbread
Eleven ingredients in forty five minutes, eight servings at 296 calories, the heaviest in this group. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 8, 296 calories
Sweet Potato and Dressing
Two that use cornbread as a component rather than a finished loaf. The dressing one is worth planning for: cornbread dressing wants cornbread that is a day or two old and dried out, since fresh cornbread turns to paste the moment stock hits it.
Sweet Potato Cornbread with Sour Cream
Fourteen ingredients, tied for the most on this page, in seventy minutes, tied for the longest here, twelve servings at 234 calories, the lighter of the two. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 12, 234 calories
Cornbread Chicken Dressing Casserole
Fourteen ingredients, tied for the most on this page, in seventy minutes, tied for the longest here, eight servings at 441 calories, tied for the heaviest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 70 minutes, serves 8, 441 calories
Before You Choose Your Recipe
Four things decide whether cornbread is good. The pan and its temperature come first. A cast iron skillet preheated in the oven with fat in it, bacon fat traditionally, gives a crust that no other method produces, because the batter sets the instant it touches the hot surface. Pour into a cold pan and the fat soaks upward into the batter instead, and you get a pale soft edge. Eight to ten inches is right for a standard recipe; too large and it bakes thin and dry. Second, the cornmeal itself. Stone ground is coarser and more flavourful but absorbs liquid more slowly, so a batter made with it should sit for ten minutes before baking or the finished crumb will be gritty. Degerminated supermarket cornmeal is finer and more uniform and needs no rest. White and yellow cornmeal taste slightly different and behave the same; this is regional preference, not technique. What you should not substitute is corn flour or masa harina, which are not the same thing and will not work. Third, the sugar and flour question, which is the North and South divide. Pure cornmeal with no sugar gives a savory, open, crumbly bread that is meant to be eaten warm with something wet. Adding wheat flour builds some gluten and makes it finer and sliceable; adding sugar makes it a cake. Neither is wrong, but know which one you are making before you start, because they suit different meals. Fourth, and this is the one most people get backwards: you cannot overmix cornbread. The warning about mixing quick breads only until just combined exists because of gluten development, and cornmeal has no gluten. Mix cornbread until it is actually smooth. What you can do is overbake it, and that is the real risk, because with no gluten network to hold water the loaf dries out quickly. Pull it when a tester comes out clean and not a minute later. Store it covered at room temperature and eat it within two days; it does not improve in the fridge, and if it has gone dry, split it, butter it and toast it in a skillet rather than reheating it in a microwave.
Cornbread Questions, Answered
Should cornbread have sugar in it?
That depends on what you want it for. Southern cornbread has none, uses all cornmeal and buttermilk, and is savory and crumbly for eating alongside beans or greens. Northern cornbread adds sugar and wheat flour and is closer to cake. Both are legitimate; decide before you mix.
Why does my cornbread have no crust?
Almost always a cold pan. Heat the skillet in the oven with the fat in it while you mix, and pour the batter into fat that is shimmering. The surface sets on contact, which is what makes the crust, and no amount of extra baking time will produce it afterward.
Can I overmix cornbread?
No, and this is the opposite of the usual quick bread advice. That rule exists because of gluten development, and cornmeal has no gluten. Mix cornbread until smooth. Overbaking is the real danger.
Why is my cornbread dry and crumbly?
Either overbaked or simply a day old. With no gluten network to hold moisture, cornbread stales faster than wheat bread. Pull it as soon as a tester comes out clean, and if it has gone dry, split it and toast it in butter rather than microwaving it.
Can I use corn flour or masa instead of cornmeal?
No. Corn flour is ground much finer and masa harina is nixtamalized, treated with lime, which changes both its flavour and how it absorbs liquid. Neither will give you cornbread.
Does buttermilk matter?
Yes, more than most substitutions. Its acid reacts with baking soda for lift and it tenderises the crumb. A milk and vinegar substitute works in a pinch but is thinner and gives a slightly tougher result.
Should I rest the batter?
With stone ground cornmeal, yes, about ten minutes, so the coarse grains can absorb liquid and the crumb is not gritty. With fine degerminated supermarket cornmeal it makes no real difference.
What cornbread should I use for dressing?
Day old and dried out, baked plain and savory without sugar. Fresh cornbread collapses into paste as soon as stock hits it. Bake it a day or two ahead, cube it, and leave it uncovered to dry.
More to Try
Cornmeal used other ways, and the collections cornbread sits inside.
- Cornmeal Battered Fish — nine ingredients, twenty five minutes
- Homemade Creamed Corn — ten ingredients, twenty five minutes
- Bread Recipes — quick breads and yeast loaves
- Side Dish Recipes — everything that goes alongside
- Biscuit Recipes — the other Southern quick bread
- Christmas Dinner Recipes — where the dressing belongs
- Buttermilk Recipes — acid and baking soda
Browse all of our recipe collections.

















