21 Carrot Recipes, Split Between the Vegetable and the Cake

Carrots are about five percent sugar by weight, which makes them one of the sweetest vegetables in common use, behind beets and sweetcorn. That single fact is why this page splits almost exactly down the middle: seven recipes roast or glaze them as a vegetable, and seven put them grated into a cake. Both are using the same sugar, just in different directions.

The practical consequence is about heat and water. Roasting at a high temperature concentrates that sugar and browns it, which is why a roasted carrot tastes nothing like a boiled one. Boiling leaches the sugar into the water and pours it down the sink. In a cake the grated carrot releases its moisture into the batter instead, which is why carrot cake needs less added liquid than most cakes and keeps for days without drying out.

Roasted and Glazed

Five where the carrot is the dish. Roast at 425 degrees F, not lower: the point is to caramelise the sugar at the edges, and a moderate oven just softens them. Cut the thick ends in half lengthways so the pieces finish at the same time.

Brown Sugar Glazed Carrots

Six ingredients, tied for the shortest list on this page, in twenty five minutes, the quickest cooked recipe here, at 110 calories. A pound of carrots with brown sugar, which is adding sugar to something already sweet and works because of the butter and salt. View the full recipe — 25 minutes, serves 4, 110 calories

Indian Spiced Honey Carrots

Nine ingredients in forty minutes at 114 calories. Cumin and coriander against the sweetness, which is the pairing that makes glazed carrots interesting rather than cloying. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 114 calories

Garlic Roasted Carrots

Six ingredients, tied for the shortest list here, in forty minutes with two pounds of carrots, the most by weight on this page. 156 calories. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 156 calories

Roasted Carrots with Whipped Ricotta and Hot Honey

Seventeen ingredients in forty minutes at 346 calories. The ricotta is a cool, mild base under hot sweet carrots, which is a better idea than it sounds. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 346 calories

Spicy Maple Roast Carrots with Crispy Chickpeas

Twenty three ingredients in fifty five minutes, the longest in this group, at 444 calories, the heaviest. Sixteen small Dutch carrots, so they roast whole. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 4, 444 calories

Roasted With Other Roots

Two where carrots share the tray. Root vegetables do not all cook at the same rate, so the rule is to cut the denser ones smaller: beetroot and turnip need longer than carrot at the same size.

Roasted Turnips and Carrots

Nine ingredients in fifty minutes at 140 calories. Turnip is peppery and carrot is sweet, which balances without anything else added. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 4, 140 calories

Roasted Beets and Carrots Salad with Burrata

Eleven ingredients in forty minutes at 251 calories, served as a salad rather than a side. Beetroot bleeds, so roast it separately if you want the carrots to stay orange. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 251 calories

Carrot Cake, Five Ways

Five, and the one instruction that matters is how you grate. Use the fine side of the box grater, not the coarse one. Coarse shreds stay visible and slightly crunchy in the finished cake, while fine ones disappear into the crumb and give up their moisture, which is the whole point.

Oat Apple and Carrot Cake

Eight ingredients in sixty five minutes, eight servings at 165 calories, the lightest cake on this page. Oats instead of most of the flour. View the full recipe — 65 minutes, serves 8, 165 calories

Flourless Carrot Cake

Nine ingredients in eighty five minutes at 171 calories. Seven ounces of carrot providing both the moisture and a good deal of the structure. View the full recipe — 85 minutes, serves 8, 171 calories

Carrot Sheet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

Eighteen ingredients over two hours five, twenty servings at 338 calories, the most portions of any cake here. Three cups of finely shredded carrot, the most of any cake here. View the full recipe — 125 minutes, serves 20, 338 calories

Hawaiian Carrot Pineapple Cake

Fifteen ingredients in fifty minutes, the quickest cake here, twelve servings at 437 calories. Two cups of grated carrot with drained pineapple, and both bring water, so the pineapple has to be pressed dry. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 12, 437 calories

Pineapple Coconut Carrot Cake

Sixteen ingredients over two hours five, twelve servings at 477 calories, the heaviest recipe on this page. Three sources of moisture at once, which is why it keeps so well. View the full recipe — 125 minutes, serves 12, 477 calories

Carrot Cake That Is Not a Cake

Two that take the same flavour somewhere else. Cream cheese is not optional in either: the acidity is what stops a spiced, sweet, carrot heavy batter from tasting flat.

Carrot Cake Cream Cheese Bars

Thirteen ingredients in forty five minutes, twelve bars at 254 calories. A cup of freshly grated carrot, and bars rather than a layer cake means no frosting to level. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 12, 254 calories

Carrot Cake Cheesecake with Cream Cheese Frosting

Twenty four ingredients, the longest list on this page by a wide margin, over six hours forty, the longest recipe here. Sixteen servings at 438 calories. View the full recipe — 400 minutes, serves 16, 438 calories

Slaws and Raw Salads

Four where the carrot stays raw, and this is where its texture matters more than its sweetness. Matchsticks or coarse shreds here, the opposite of the cake rule, because you want them to stay crisp and distinct.

Creamy Buttermilk Coleslaw with Carrot and Onion

Eleven ingredients over seventy five minutes, six servings at 88 calories, the lightest in this group. Buttermilk instead of mayonnaise, which is why it is so much lighter than a standard slaw. View the full recipe — 75 minutes, serves 6, 88 calories

Red Cabbage Carrot Mint Salad

Seven ingredients in ten minutes, the quickest recipe on this page, at 107 calories. Mint with carrot is underused and works for the same reason lemon works with blueberry. View the full recipe — 10 minutes, serves 4, 107 calories

Crunchy Apple Carrot Salad with Citrus Dressing

Twelve ingredients over three hours fifteen at 170 calories. Apple and carrot are both sweet and crisp, so the dressing has to bring all the acidity. View the full recipe — 195 minutes, serves 6, 170 calories

Cabbage Carrot Thoran Salad

Fifteen ingredients in thirty minutes at 181 calories, the heaviest in this group. A South Indian style dish with coconut and mustard seed. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 181 calories

Where Carrot Is the Filling

Three where grated or diced carrot goes inside something else. In all three it is doing two jobs at once: bulking the filling out cheaply and sweetening it enough that no sugar is needed.

Cheesy Carrot Canapes

Seven ingredients in sixty minutes, thirty canapes at 50 calories each, the lightest recipe on this page and the most portions. Two large carrots across thirty servings. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 30, 50 calories

Cabbage and Carrot Egg Rolls

Ten ingredients in fifty minutes at 244 calories. A cup of carrot with cabbage, and both have to be cooked down first or the wrappers will go soggy. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 4, 244 calories

Spring Pea and Carrot Chicken Pie

Twelve ingredients in sixty minutes, six servings at 425 calories, the heaviest in this group. A cup of diced carrot, cut small so it cooks through under the pastry. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 6, 425 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Roast them hot. Carrots carry about five percent sugar, and at 425 degrees F that sugar caramelises on the cut surfaces, which is where the flavour of a roasted carrot actually comes from. At 350 they just go soft. Toss them in oil, spread them out so they are not touching, and give them thirty to forty minutes with one turn. Crowding is the usual mistake, because trapped steam stops browning, and two trays always beat one full one. Boiling is the opposite: the sugar and the water soluble flavour leach into the water, which is why boiled carrots taste of almost nothing. If you are boiling them for a mash or a soup, use the cooking water in the dish rather than draining it away. Do not peel carrots for roasting. Scrub them and leave the skin on, which holds the shape and carries flavour. Cut them evenly, and halve the thick shoulder end lengthways so the fat and thin parts finish together, since a carrot is a cone and an unmodified one always ends up burnt at the tip and raw at the top. For cake, grate fine. This is the single most common carrot cake error: coarse shreds from the big side of a box grater stay visible and slightly raw in the finished cake, whereas fine grating lets the carrot disappear into the crumb and release its water into the batter. That released moisture is why carrot cake needs less liquid than other cakes and why it stays moist for three or four days, and it is also why you must not add extra milk to compensate for a batter that looks thick. Spices belong, but keep it to cinnamon with a little nutmeg or ginger; a heavy hand turns carrot cake into a spice cake with carrots in it. And cream cheese frosting is not just tradition. Carrot cake is sweet and spiced with no acidity of its own, and the tang of cream cheese is what keeps a slice from feeling heavy. Finally, storage. Carrots go bendy because they lose water, not because they have spoiled, and twenty minutes in a bowl of ice water makes a limp carrot crisp again. Keep them in the fridge in a bag, and cut the green tops off as soon as you get them home, since the leaves keep drawing water out of the root.

Carrot Questions, Answered

What temperature should I roast carrots at?

425 degrees F, in a single layer with space between the pieces. The point is to caramelise the sugar on the cut surfaces, and a cooler oven only softens them. Thirty to forty minutes with one turn.

Should I peel carrots?

Not for roasting. Scrub them and leave the skin on, which helps them hold their shape. Peel them for a smooth soup or mash, where the skin would leave fibrous specks.

How should I grate carrots for carrot cake?

On the fine side of a box grater. Coarse shreds stay visible and slightly crunchy in the baked cake, while fine ones vanish into the crumb and release their moisture, which is what makes carrot cake moist.

Why does carrot cake stay moist for days?

The grated carrot releases water into the crumb as it bakes and holds onto some of it afterwards. That is also why you should not add extra liquid to a carrot cake batter that looks thick.

Are baby carrots better than large ones?

No. Most supermarket baby carrots are large carrots cut down and tumbled smooth, and they tend to be blander and slightly drier. Genuine young carrots sold with the tops on are excellent, but they are a different product.

How do I revive limp carrots?

Twenty minutes in a bowl of ice water. They go bendy because they have lost water, not because they have gone off, and they take it back up. Remove the green tops when you buy them, since the leaves keep drawing moisture from the root.

Why do my roasted carrots cook unevenly?

Because a carrot is a cone. The shoulder end is far thicker than the tip, so halve the top half lengthways to even out the pieces. Crowding the tray also causes it, by steaming the middle while the edges roast.

Do carrots need cream cheese frosting?

Not literally, but there is a reason it is standard. Carrot cake is sweet and spiced with no acidity of its own, and the tang of cream cheese balances it. A plain buttercream makes the same cake feel heavy.

More Vegetables and Cakes

Three more carrot recipes and the collections these sit inside.

Browse all of our recipe collections.