26 Brownie Recipes, Sorted From Fudgy to Cakey

Fudgy or cakey is the only brownie question that matters, and it is not a matter of opinion or baking time. It is the ratio of fat to flour. We worked it out for every recipe here and it runs from a tenth of a tablespoon of butter per tablespoon of flour up to two full tablespoons, a twentyfold spread, and the ratio predicts the texture every time.

Everything at 1.0 and above is dense and fudgy. Everything below about 0.65 is cakey, and the four recipes here that people describe as cakey all sit there. So these twenty six are sorted that way, fudgy first. None of them uses a box mix.

The Fudgiest: Twice as Much Butter as Flour

The top of the ratio, 1.25 to 2.0 tablespoons of butter per tablespoon of flour. At this end there is barely enough flour to hold the thing together, which is exactly the point: the structure comes from chocolate and egg rather than from gluten.

Easy Chocolate Brownies

Fourteen tablespoons of butter to half a cup of flour, a ratio of 1.75, with seven ounces of dark chocolate melted in. Nine ingredients. View the full recipe — 68 minutes, serves 9, 410 calories

Fudgy Chocolate Hazelnut Brownies

The same 1.75 ratio with hazelnut through it, nine ingredients. Nuts add fat of their own, which is why this reads as the richest of the three at this ratio. View the full recipe — 73 minutes, serves 12, 486 calories

Peanut Butter Stuffed Brownies

Also 1.75, with a peanut butter layer inside and a cup and a quarter of dark chocolate. At 586 calories a serving it is the second heaviest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 78 minutes, serves 9, 586 calories

Peanut Butter Swirl Brownies with Peanut Butter Cups

A ratio of 1.25 and sixteen ingredients, tying for the longest list here. The swirl stays separate because peanut butter is thicker than the batter. View the full recipe — 110 minutes, serves 16, 470 calories

Fudgy Brownie Cupcakes with Chocolate Buttercream

Two tablespoons of butter per tablespoon of flour, the highest ratio on this page, baked in a tin rather than a pan. Thirteen ingredients. View the full recipe — 123 minutes, serves 9, 442 calories

Fudgy, at One to One

Equal butter and flour by volume, which is where most recipes that call themselves fudgy actually land. Dense and sliceable rather than gooey, and much easier to get right than the group above.

Fudgy Chocolate Chunk Brownies

Eight ingredients, tying for the shortest list on this page, with eight ounces of semi sweet chocolate in chunks rather than chips. Chunks melt into pockets; chips hold their shape. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 16, 240 calories

Small Batch Air Fryer Brownies from Scratch

Ten ingredients scaled to six servings in an air fryer at 325 degrees F, the lowest temperature of any brownie here. Thirty minutes, the quickest recipe on this page. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 6, 232 calories

Caramel Fudge Brownies

A full cup of butter to a cup of flour with a cup of cocoa, eleven ingredients. The caramel layer is what pushes it to 382 calories across sixteen servings. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 16, 382 calories

Homemade Cosmic Brownies with Chocolate Ganache

Twelve tablespoons of butter to three quarters of a cup of flour, eleven ingredients, and two hours twenty, most of it waiting for the ganache to set. View the full recipe — 140 minutes, serves 16, 265 calories

Homemade Brownie Mix with Cocoa and Chocolate Chips

The dry mix made up in advance so the only work later is butter and eggs, ten ingredients. Worth knowing that a homemade mix lands at the same ratio as the scratch recipes above. View the full recipe — 65 minutes, serves 9, 334 calories

Cakey: Less Than Two Thirds

Below about 0.65 the flour starts behaving like flour, which means gluten, lift and a crumb rather than a fudge. Every recipe people describe as a cakey brownie sits in this range, and none of them is trying to be fudgy.

Fresh Milled Zucchini Brownies

Two and a half cups of flour to half a cup of butter, a ratio of 0.1, the lowest on this page by a long way. At 156 calories across twenty four servings it is the lightest recipe here, and the zucchini is doing the moisture work the butter would normally do. View the full recipe — 57 minutes, serves 24, 156 calories

Banana Bread Brownies

A cup of flour to half a cup of butter, ratio 0.5, with banana for moisture. Eleven ingredients, and it behaves much more like a quick bread than a brownie. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 12, 281 calories

Red Velvet Brownies

The same 0.5 ratio with cocoa cut back so the colour can show, nine ingredients. Cakey is correct here rather than a compromise, since red velvet is a cake. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 9, 300 calories

Iced Cafeteria Brownies

Two cups of flour to a cup of butter, ratio 0.63, across twenty four servings. This is the sheet pan tray bake texture on purpose, because it has to cut cleanly and travel. View the full recipe — 100 minutes, serves 24, 266 calories

Chocolate From Scratch, No Chips

Three where the chocolate comes from cocoa or unsweetened bars rather than chips, which gives you control over the sugar that a chip never will.

Unsweetened Chocolate Brownies with Cake Flour

Six ounces of unsweetened chocolate with a cup and a quarter of flour, a ratio of 0.6, so it sits at the cakey end despite the dense chocolate. Nine ingredients. View the full recipe — 110 minutes, serves 16, 292 calories

Boxed Style Brownies from Scratch

Nine ingredients from scratch, built to match the texture of a box mix rather than to beat it. Half a cup of unsweetened cocoa does the work. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 9, 263 calories

Brown Butter White Chocolate Walnut Blondies

Not a brownie at all: no cocoa, brown sugar and vanilla instead, with a cup of white chocolate and walnuts. Ratio 0.56, nine ingredients, sixteen servings. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 16, 216 calories

Without Wheat Flour

Two that replace wheat entirely. Both come out dense, because there is no gluten to lift anything, which means the fudgy end is the easier target when you bake this way.

Fudgy Coconut Flour Brownies

Six tablespoons of coconut flour with a third of a cup of coconut oil and raw cacao, eight ingredients. Coconut flour absorbs several times its weight in liquid, which is why six tablespoons is enough. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 16, 174 calories

Flourless Chocolate Brownies with Almond Meal

Almond meal and white rice flour rather than wheat, so gluten free rather than literally flourless. Eight ingredients and thirty five minutes, the second quickest recipe here. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 9, 311 calories

Stuffed, Layered and Swirled

Three where something else is built into the pan. All three take longer than a plain brownie, and in each case the extra time is a second batter or a setting layer rather than more baking.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Brownies

Two batters in one pan, sixteen ingredients, tying for the longest list on this page. The ratio lands at 0.57 because the cookie layer brings its own flour. View the full recipe — 100 minutes, serves 12, 426 calories

Strawberry Jam Brownies with Chocolate Topping

A 1.06 ratio with ten ounces of semisweet chocolate and jam swirled through, eleven ingredients. Jam is mostly water and sugar, so it stays as ribbons rather than mixing in. View the full recipe — 100 minutes, serves 12, 515 calories

Gooey Brownie Pie

Three cups of semisweet chocolate in a pie dish, eight ingredients, ratio 0.75. A deeper vessel means a longer bake and a softer middle, which is the whole idea. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 8, 536 calories

Brownie, Reshaped

Four that stop being a square. The ratio still applies, but the vessel changes the bake: cookies spread, cupcakes rise at the edges, and a cheesecake layer needs hours in the fridge rather than minutes in the oven.

Fudgy Brownie Cookies

A cup of flour to a quarter cup of butter, which is a cookie ratio rather than a brownie one, plus a cup of semi sweet chocolate. Eighteen cookies in thirty seven minutes. View the full recipe — 37 minutes, serves 18, 193 calories

Brownie Bottom Cheesecake Cups

A 1.5 ratio brownie base under cheesecake, fifteen ingredients and three hours, nearly all of it chilling rather than baking. View the full recipe — 190 minutes, serves 12, 250 calories

Caramel Drizzle Brownie Cheesecake

Thirteen ingredients and five and a half hours, the longest recipe on this page, at 607 calories a serving, the heaviest. The brownie layer is at a 1.0 ratio so it stays dense under the weight above it. View the full recipe — 325 minutes, serves 8, 607 calories

Chocolate Mousse Brownie Cake

A brownie base with mousse set on top, eleven ingredients, three hours. The mousse needs the base to be fudgy, because a cakey one would absorb it. View the full recipe — 182 minutes, serves 12, 408 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Work out the ratio before you start and you will know what you are getting. Count the butter or oil in tablespoons, count the flour in tablespoons, and divide. At 1.0 and above you are making a fudgy brownie: dense, slightly underbaked in the middle, structure coming from chocolate and egg. Below about 0.65 you are making a cakey one, with gluten and lift doing the work. Between the two you get something in the middle, and no amount of adjusting the bake time will move a recipe from one camp to the other, because you cannot bake flour out of a batter. Two things follow from that. First, if a brownie recipe has disappointed you, check its ratio against the one you wanted rather than blaming your oven. The twenty four recipes above with a measurable ratio run from 0.1 to 2.0, so there is a version of almost any brownie at either texture. Second, the fudgy end is less forgiving of overbaking, not more. With little flour there is nothing to hold moisture once it leaves, so two extra minutes at a 1.75 ratio does more damage than five at 0.5. Pull a fudgy brownie when a skewer comes out with wet crumbs clinging, not clean, and let it cool completely in the tin: it is still setting as it cools, and cutting warm is the most common way a good fudgy brownie gets ruined. For clean edges, chill the whole slab for an hour and cut with a long knife wiped between cuts.

Brownie Questions, Answered

What actually makes a brownie fudgy rather than cakey?

The ratio of fat to flour, not the baking time. More butter and less flour means less gluten and less lift, so the brownie sets dense. The recipes above at 1.0 and higher are fudgy and the ones below 0.65 are cakey, and that holds across all twenty four where we could measure it.

Why are my brownies dry?

Overbaking, most likely, and it hits fudgy recipes hardest because there is little flour to hold moisture. Take them out when a skewer has wet crumbs on it rather than coming clean, since they keep cooking in the hot tin for several minutes after.

How do I get the shiny crackly top?

Dissolved sugar and beaten eggs. Whisk the sugar into the warm melted butter and chocolate until it looks glossy, then beat the eggs in properly rather than just stirring. The thin meringue like layer that forms on top is what crackles.

Chips or chopped chocolate?

Chips hold their shape because they contain stabilisers, so you get distinct pieces. Chopped bars or chunks melt into pockets and seams. The chocolate chunk recipe here uses eight ounces of bar chocolate for exactly that reason.

Can I use a box mix?

You can, and none of these twenty six do. A box is cocoa, sugar, flour and leavening with the ratio already fixed, which is why a box brownie always has the same texture. The scratch recipe here that imitates one is the useful comparison.

How do I cut brownies cleanly?

Cool completely, then chill the slab for an hour. Use a long knife, press straight down rather than sawing, and wipe it between cuts. Warm brownies tear no matter how sharp the knife is.

Can brownies be frozen?

Yes, and the fudgy ones freeze best because there is less water in them to form ice crystals. Cool completely, cut, and freeze in a single layer before bagging. They thaw in about an hour and many people prefer them cold.

More Chocolate to Try

The brownie based desserts that did not fit above, plus the collections these sit inside.

Browse all of our recipe collections.