25 Mushroom Recipes, and Why They All Say 8 Ounces

Here is something you notice only when you line up every mushroom recipe you have: twenty four of the forty six mushroom lines in our archive call for exactly eight ounces. That is not a measurement anyone arrived at by tasting. It is the size of the package, and it tells you that in most recipes mushrooms are an ingredient someone added rather than the thing being cooked.

Only seven call for a pound or more, and those are the ones where mushrooms are actually the dish. So these twenty five are sorted that way: mushrooms as the point first, then the pastas and soups built around a pound of them, and finally the chicken and beef dishes where eight ounces is doing supporting work.

Mushrooms as the Dish

Five where nothing else is competing. Mushrooms are about ninety percent water, so the single most important instruction in this group is to give them room in a hot pan: crowded mushrooms steam in their own liquid and never brown.

Sauteed Garlic Asparagus and Mushrooms

Seven ingredients and 63 calories a serving, the lightest and quickest recipe on this page. Eight ounces each of asparagus and cremini with garlic and lemon zest, twenty minutes. View the full recipe — 20 minutes, serves 4, 63 calories

Roasted Flat Mushrooms with Thyme Butter

Eight large portobello caps roasted with thyme butter, nine ingredients, eight servings at 100 calories. A flat cap roasts rather than steams, which is why this works where sliced mushrooms would go grey. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 8, 100 calories

Garlic Panko Stuffed Mushrooms

Ten ounces of button mushrooms filled with garlic panko, eight ingredients. Button caps are small and firm enough to hold a filling, which the larger varieties are not. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 144 calories

Pizza Stuffed Mushrooms

Five large portobello caps standing in for a crust, nine ingredients. The cap is wide enough to take sauce and cheese without collapsing. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 5, 209 calories

Balsamic Marinated Mushrooms with Thyme and Garlic

A pound and a half of small white buttons marinated for nearly three hours, the longest recipe on this page. The acid firms them rather than cooking them, which is the opposite of everything else here. View the full recipe — 165 minutes, serves 4, 227 calories

Mushroom Pasta, Where the Quantity Changes Everything

Three pastas, and the mushroom weight is the honest difference between them: eight ounces, fourteen ounces and a full pound. More mushrooms means more liquid released, which means a sauce that needs less cream to come together.

Creamy Tuscan Mushroom Pasta Skillet

Eight ounces of mushrooms to eight ounces of pasta, with spinach and a cup of cream doing the work. Eight ingredients, thirty minutes. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 546 calories

Garlic Butter Mushroom Pasta with Parmesan

Fourteen ounces of mushrooms and no cream at all: butter, parmesan and reserved pasta water make the sauce. Twelve ingredients, and the only pasta here that does it without dairy cream. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 563 calories

Creamy Garlic Mushroom Pasta

A full pound of cremini sliced a quarter inch thick, with white wine to deglaze and lemon at the end. Fifteen ingredients, the longest list of the three, and the mushroom forward one. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 766 calories

Soup and Rice, Built on a Pound

Three more that need the full pound, because mushroom flavour in a liquid is a matter of quantity rather than technique. These are also the three that show what cremini brings over button.

Mushroom Rice

A pound and a half of mushrooms cooked down into the rice, ten ingredients, six servings at 305 calories. The mushrooms release enough liquid to be part of the cooking water. View the full recipe — 50 minutes, serves 6, 305 calories

Hungarian Mushroom Soup with Dill and Paprika

A pound of fresh buttons with paprika and dill, fifteen ingredients. Paprika and sour cream are what make it Hungarian rather than a generic cream of mushroom. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 4, 285 calories

Stovetop Cream of Mushroom Soup

A pound of cremini in seven ingredients, tying for the shortest list on this page. This is the one that replaces the can, and two recipes further down this page still use the can. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 309 calories

Stroganoff, Four Ways

The same dish across four proteins and two methods of making the sauce, which is the clearest comparison on this page. All four use eight ounces to a cup of mushrooms, because here they are a component rather than the subject.

Chicken Mushroom Stroganoff

Thirteen ingredients in thirty minutes, the quickest of the four. Chicken cooks faster than beef, which is the only reason. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 640 calories

Stroganoff with Cream of Mushroom Soup

A cup of mushrooms plus the canned soup as the sauce base, ten ingredients, thirty five minutes. The shortcut version, and worth comparing against the stovetop soup recipe above. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 546 calories

Creamy Ground Beef Stroganoff with Mushrooms

Eight ounces of cremini with ground beef rather than steak, fifteen ingredients, six servings. Ground beef is what makes stroganoff a weeknight dish. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 6, 519 calories

Ribeye Beef Stroganoff with Mushrooms

Ten ounces of mushrooms with ribeye, thirteen ingredients. At 834 calories it is the heaviest recipe on this page, which is what ribeye and sour cream together do. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 834 calories

Chicken, Where Eight Ounces Is the Rule

Six chicken dishes, and every one of them calls for eight ounces to a cup of mushrooms. That consistency is the package size showing through, and it also means these six are interchangeable in the mushroom aisle.

Black Pepper Chicken with Mushrooms

Twelve ingredients in thirty minutes with cracked pepper carrying the dish rather than cream. The lightest chicken recipe here at 327 calories. View the full recipe — 30 minutes, serves 4, 327 calories

Dijon Mushroom Cream Chicken

A cup of mushrooms with Dijon in the cream sauce, nine ingredients. Mustard cuts cream in a way nothing else on this page does. View the full recipe — 35 minutes, serves 4, 448 calories

Creamy Garlic Parmesan Mushroom Chicken

Eight ounces of cremini, twelve ingredients, forty minutes. Parmesan thickens the sauce so it needs less reduction. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 492 calories

Creamy Chicken with Mushrooms

Nine ingredients and eight ounces of cremini, the plainest version of this idea and the one to start from. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 493 calories

Smothered Chicken with Mushroom Gravy

Fourteen ingredients with a proper gravy rather than a cream sauce, which means flour and longer cooking. Forty minutes. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 4, 575 calories

Chicken Thighs with Mushroom Garlic Sauce

Thighs rather than breast, ten ingredients, six servings at 365 calories. Dark meat tolerates the fifty five minutes this one takes. View the full recipe — 55 minutes, serves 6, 365 calories

Salisbury Steak

Two versions of the dish that is essentially a mushroom gravy with something underneath it. Both carry the longest ingredient lists on this page, almost entirely because of the gravy.

Turkey Salisbury Steaks with Mushroom Gravy

Eight ounces of white buttons with ground turkey, eighteen ingredients, an hour. Turkey needs the gravy more than beef does. View the full recipe — 60 minutes, serves 4, 404 calories

Salisbury Steak with Mushroom Gravy

Twenty one ingredients, the longest list on this page, with only five ounces of mushrooms. The gravy is the dish here and the mushrooms are seasoning in it. View the full recipe — 45 minutes, serves 4, 471 calories

Baked and Stuffed

Two where the mushrooms go inside something. Both benefit from cooking the mushrooms down first, because an uncooked mushroom releases its water into whatever is around it.

Mushroom Stuffed Chicken Breast

Seven ounces of mushrooms cooked down and stuffed into two breasts, ten ingredients. Cooking them first is what stops the filling going watery. View the full recipe — 40 minutes, serves 2, 555 calories

Spinach and Mushroom Lasagna with Ricotta and Mozzarella

Eight ounces of cremini with spinach across eight servings, sixteen ingredients, an hour and forty. Both vegetables have to be cooked down or the layers slide apart. View the full recipe — 100 minutes, serves 8, 545 calories

Before You Choose Your Recipe

Two facts about mushrooms explain most of what goes wrong with them. The first is that they are roughly ninety percent water. Put them in a crowded pan and that water comes out faster than it evaporates, so they boil in it and come out grey and squeaky instead of browned. Give them a wide pan, high heat and space, leave them alone for the first few minutes, and salt them at the end rather than the start, because salt pulls the water out early. The second is that they are a sponge in the sense that matters: they soak up fat readily. That is why mushrooms cooked in butter taste so much better than mushrooms cooked in a dry pan, and also why the calorie figures above swing so widely for similar quantities. Beyond technique, the one thing worth deciding before you shop is quantity. The eight ounce package is the default in twenty four of our forty six mushroom recipes, and for a chicken dish or a stroganoff that is correct: the mushrooms are there for depth, not volume. But for a pasta, a soup or a rice dish where mushrooms are supposed to be the flavour, eight ounces disappears, and the recipes here that work are the ones calling for a pound or more. If a mushroom pasta has ever tasted like cream pasta with some mushrooms in it, that is the number that was wrong. And on variety: cremini and white button are the same species at different ages, so cremini is simply a firmer, deeper flavoured version and substitutes directly. Portobello is the same mushroom again, grown out, which is why it works as a cap to stuff or roast and badly as something sliced into a sauce.

Mushroom Questions, Answered

Why do my mushrooms go grey and rubbery?

Crowding. Mushrooms release a lot of water, and in a packed pan that water cannot evaporate, so they simmer rather than sear. Use a bigger pan than feels necessary, cook in two batches if you have to, and do not salt them until they have browned.

Should I wash mushrooms or wipe them?

Either is fine for anything that will be cooked in liquid. For anything you want browned, wipe or rinse briefly and dry them, because a wet surface has to be dried off by the pan before browning can start, and that is time the mushroom spends steaming.

Cremini or white button?

The same species at different ages, so they substitute one for one. Cremini are firmer and taste deeper, which matters most in the recipes here built on a pound of them and matters very little in a stroganoff where eight ounces is seasoning.

How many mushrooms do I actually need?

Eight ounces if they are supporting a chicken or beef dish, which is what twenty four of our forty six mushroom recipes call for. A pound or more if the dish is named after them. The pasta recipes on this page run from eight ounces to a full pound, and that difference is the main thing separating them.

Is canned cream of mushroom soup acceptable?

It is a thickener and a seasoning in one tin, and two recipes here use it deliberately. The stovetop version on this page is the one to make instead if you want mushroom flavour rather than a stable sauce, and comparing those two is the clearest way to decide which you prefer.

Can mushroom dishes be made ahead?

Cooked down mushrooms keep well and improve for a day, which is why the lasagna and the soups here are good leftovers. What does not hold is anything where browned mushrooms are a texture, since they soften in the fridge and never come back.

Why is the asparagus and mushroom side so low in calories?

Because it is eight ounces of each with a tablespoon of oil and nothing else. At 63 calories a serving it is the lightest recipe on this page, and it shows how much of a mushroom dish calorie count is actually butter, cream or cheese.

More Mushroom to Try

Four more, including a second mushroom pasta and the burgers where portobello replaces the beef.

Browse all of our recipe collections.